Remove this Banner Ad

SC Trading Thread (Part II)

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Round 4 trades

peteshep said:
Hmm i'm very very stumped with this one...

As stated the thing with Rioli is consistency... Higgins has that part covered. Then again he (Rioli) has looked pretty consistent so far (though it's only been two games). If Hawthorn had have won that game against Geelong I would estimate that Rioli's score would have been more like 100-105 than 82 or so. I remember checking at 3 quarter time and alot of the Hawthorn players were on track for tons (Mitchell, Franklin, Rioli) and then they ended up with 80's and 90's after Geelong got the win.

So what does this add to the debate? A lot more confusion for me that's what :confused:...
Click to expand...

Yeah, you can make it alot more confusing.. That is what this forum is about!! getting confused half the time!!

Rioli has had 2 great games, but he hasn't proved he can string consistency together. It's been a great start that's for sure, just have a feeling he could do a hamstring like last year or have an ordinary game.. Having said that Higgins did it last year lol. Bugger it, I'll back Higgins on this one.

Anyone is better then Medhurst lol. Can't believe I got sucked in!
 
Re: Round 4 trades

There is no way I'm touching Rioli.

He can't even train properly. Too much risk for mine.
 
Re: Round 4 trades

peteshep said:
Hmm i'm very very stumped with this one...

As stated the thing with Rioli is consistency... Higgins has that part covered. Then again he (Rioli) has looked pretty consistent so far (though it's only been two games). If Hawthorn had have won that game against Geelong I would estimate that Rioli's score would have been more like 100-105 than 82 or so. I remember checking at 3 quarter time and alot of the Hawthorn players were on track for tons (Mitchell, Franklin, Rioli) and then they ended up with 80's and 90's after Geelong got the win.

So what does this add to the debate? A lot more confusion for me that's what :confused:...
Click to expand...
Yeah you are right about the his score in that game I think he should have hit the ton, and he did score 140 in a loss on the weekend, so he could be the guy to go for, if he holds up phisicly, you will be over the moon with him. Just about best player on that list with Mitchell snd Hodge. Keep in mind Higgins is set to peak at 510k (only 35k from were he is now) Ciryl, if he does keep this avg up (a bit unlikely) will hit about 540k but it doesnt really matter because they are both keepers. The reason He will hit 540k is because of the 140 on the weekend, his price will do up dramaticly over the next 2 weeks. But all Higgins needs is 1 130-140 game to reach the same hights.

Mitchell actual scored 68 in that game and that was with 32 possies I think, complete bull, he is on my radar Mitchell, droped a few $$

Just think WWLRD (What would Liverpool Red Do) ;)
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Re: Round 4 trades

What do you guys think of these trades:
Stanton > Harvey, Ball > Mitchell/Delideo, Medhurst > Harvey/Franklin, Bock > Newman

Also you guys might wanna keep an eye out for Hargraves He started at 515k and if he scores 75 in the next 2 rounds he will drop to 360k, I should be able to trade maguire or Silvagni for him ;)
 
Re: Round 4 trades

HeartOfMelbourne said:
What do you guys think of these trades:
Stanton > Harvey, Ball > Mitchell/Delideo, Medhurst > Harvey/Franklin, Bock > Newman

Also you guys might wanna keep an eye out for Hargraves He started at 515k and if he scores 75 in the next 2 rounds he will drop to 360k, I should be able to trade maguire or Silvagni for him ;)
Click to expand...

newman is out this week isn't he?
 
Re: Round 4 trades

generalstraw said:
is it worthwhile trading kennelly to malcheski?
Click to expand...
I'm wondering the same thing... In hindsight, it should have been done last week. Last week I thought it looked a bit sideways though and there had only been two games played and I wanted to base it on more than that.

Things look a lot different this week though; three games seems like so much more than two and Malceski's average looks so much better than Kennelly's... Mal's price is just going to continue to grow and I can picture kicking myself in the later rounds for not picking him up so cheaply earlier.

Taking into account previous comments made about Malceski (about playing easy opposition so far and that he may be targeted in the future), I still think I'm going to make the trade. Tadgh is my lowest scoring back at the moment and this would set me up with, what I consider to be, a solid backline.

It would probably be helpful if I had had the chance to actually see any Sydney games this year :eek:
 
Re: Round 4 trades

HeartOfMelbourne said:
Yeah you are right about the his score in that game I think he should have hit the ton, and he did score 140 in a loss on the weekend, so he could be the guy to go for, if he holds up phisicly, you will be over the moon with him. Just about best player on that list with Mitchell snd Hodge. Keep in mind Higgins is set to peak at 510k (only 35k from were he is now) Ciryl, if he does keep this avg up (a bit unlikely) will hit about 540k but it doesnt really matter because they are both keepers. The reason He will hit 540k is because of the 140 on the weekend, his price will do up dramaticly over the next 2 weeks. But all Higgins needs is 1 130-140 game to reach the same hights.

Mitchell actual scored 68 in that game and that was with 32 possies I think, complete bull, he is on my radar Mitchell, droped a few $$

Just think WWLRD (What would Liverpool Red Do) ;)
Click to expand...

haha indeed. Where art thou wise Supercoach feedback givers such as Liverpool Red, Unknown Identity, FB Donkey, Judd Magic, Impromptu, September 27, spud jjj, thomas18 (I've probably left some of you out) to offer me there two cents on this conundrum!!

You all must be out there somewhere!

Higgins vs Rioli (+60k)...
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Re: Round 4 trades

Having dilemas which one to go for

Gia OUT Rioli IN OR
Medhurst OUT Reimers IN

Or is there any other decent players that i have missed between 300 - 400k?

Then
Rie OUT Chapman IN

Thanks
 
Re: Round 4 trades

Saints_87 said:
Having dilemas which one to go for

Gia OUT Rioli IN OR
Medhurst OUT Reimers IN

Or is there any other decent players that i have missed between 300 - 400k?

Then
Rie OUT Chapman IN

Thanks
Click to expand...

Medhurst for Rioli? or you tight for cash??

Went away and had a toss between Higgins and Rioli out of 10 and Higgins one 5-3. amazing what you can do with coins :rolleyes:
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Re: Round 4 trades

Hot Tiges said:
Medhurst for Rioli? or you tight for cash??

Went away and had a toss between Higgins and Rioli out of 10 and Higgins one 5-3. amazing what you can do with coins :rolleyes:
Click to expand...


yeh only have 13k in the kitty, makes its difficult.

Which player would be better Rioli or Higgins? was thinking Rioli orginally.
 
Re: Round 4 trades

Saints_87 said:
yeh only have 13k in the kitty, makes its difficult.

Which player would be better Rioli or Higgins? was thinking Rioli orginally.
Click to expand...

Rioli is about 60k cheaper but coming off OP this pre-season.. Higgins, basically 3 tons so far.
 
Re: Round 4 trades

Windas_Magic said:
Need to trade Roo, but am undecided on either Chapman, Brown or Goodes?

And also, Moles or Coyler?

Thanks guys
Click to expand...

I'm a little biased but I'd go Moles. Liam Picken is out for 6 - 8 weeks and I'm pretty sure Molesy will play over that time and probably even beyond. His NAB scoring was really good and is averaging 73 in his first 2.

Supercoachfan said:
Brown and Rioli
or
Pavlich and Brennan ?

i can't split them.
Click to expand...

Toss a coin. ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

SC fish
  • Locked
Trades 2025 Round 24 Trades
2 3
Replies
61
Views
3K
SC fish
SC fish
BOMBERBLITZ
Trades 2025 Round 23 Trades
2
Replies
48
Views
2K
Sherman41
S
SELFCONFESDAFLNERD
Trades 2025 Round 22 Trades
2 3 4
Replies
85
Views
4K
Obese Arachnid
Obese Arachnid
kyri
Trades 2025 Round 21 Trades
2 3 4 5
Replies
101
Views
5K
1989
1989
SC fish
Trades 2025 Round 20 Trades
2 3 4
Replies
88
Views
5K
Sherman41
S
Maybe Tomorrow
  • Locked
Trades 2025 Round 19 Trades
7 8 9 10 11
Replies
261
Views
12K
SC fish
SC fish
Jiska
  • Locked
Trades 2025 Round 18 Trades
3 4 5 6 7
Replies
172
Views
9K
Scythe
Scythe

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top