Opinion Scharenberg vs Aish

[TradeDraft]

Unless Scharenberg's career gets ended because of injury, then I still back it in as the right choice.

Aish would've just been another mid-paced 182cm midfielder with a light frame. We needed a 190cm defender to replace Shaw and eventually Maxwell.

I think Beams and Pendlebury can do the Aish role. Freeman adds dynamite speed. Scharenberg adds the utility that can cut you up. I think he'll turn out a bit like Goddard.

Definitely the right decision structure wise.

If the injuries never heel, then it will obviously go down a mistake. But too early to tell and from what I know he is back running and looking at a return this year.

Spot On. We had Simmlar Players to Aish where we did not with Scharanberg.

Freeman gives the Dynamite Speed we have been Mising

 

[sloth6]

Rocket said this morning at the breakfast that the club is in no worry to get scharenberg on the park this year. Scharenberg is a pretty determined kid and will look to get back, if so it will be around round 16, 17. His next progression is a fitness program.

 

[loki04]

Rocket said this morning at the breakfast that the club is in no worry to get scharenberg on the park this year. Scharenberg is a pretty determined kid and will look to get back, if so it will be around round 16, 17. His next progression is a fitness program.

Well if thats his best bet for a full recovery so be it.

 

[TradeDraft]

Rocket said this morning at the breakfast that the club is in no worry to get scharenberg on the park this year. Scharenberg is a pretty determined kid and will look to get back, if so it will be around round 16, 17. His next progression is a fitness program.

Well Grundy came back last season about then too

 

[Angus Young]

Aish has just slotted straight in and looks like he belongs straight away... I can't believe a few clubs passed him up

 

[76woodenspooners]

If Lennon debutes then everyone from the top 13 of the 2013 draft will of played except for the Collingwood boys...

To be fair, they are (by design) playing for amongst the worst clubs of 2013

GWS x 2
St Kilda
Western Bulldogs
Gold Coast
Brisbane
North Melbourne
Melbourne
West Coast
Richmond
Carlton

 

[THATSGOLD]

Well if thats his best bet for a full recovery so be it.

Exactly. He'll need to get injury free so he can join in preseason THEN play footy next year. No point trying to run around in round 19 or something killing himself because he simply won't have any sort of a tank. Pointless and lets just forget about in until the start of 2015. He will be our new recruit with Moore.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Well Grundy came back last season about then too

Grundy ran out of gas in the final. We played him for one game too many.

 

[OniAu]

Wanted to add.

If we did get Aish , who is to say he would have broken into our midfield. Not really our biggest issue for selection atm. Adams, Kennedy & Thomas all playing 2's currently.

Would be hard for Freeman to get a game if he was currently fit.

 

[TradeDraft]

Grundy ran out of gas in the final. We played him for one game too many.

Did the whole team run out of gas in the Finals?

 

[Shaneprice97]

 

[Heir Apparent]

The future looks magic with these two, pushing players like Blair and Goldsack to their limits.

 

[TradeDraft]

View attachment 187237

 

[Apex36]

View attachment 187237

Solid bump.

 

[TheBaron]

Karma

 

[BLS World Wide]

Google;
Judd chicken wing
And;
Judd eye gouging.
And;
Judd Pressure Point.
Then you will see why Hodge has it over Judd as a player in our great game.

please hodgey is an outright

 

[Seedsfan]

We really ****ed up taking Schrenberg that Aish will be a star for the Lions

 

[Pie eyed]

Mothra versus Godzilla?????


Good God don't pontificate.............

Just stand back and watch the bystanders hit the floor.