Remove this Banner Ad

FTA-TV Scream

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

My money is on Noah. Though Kieran's cousin saying something about being mysterious and liking to be someone he is not or whatever he said.

Good episode this week, I enjoyed it.

Yeah Noah as the killer would be surprising, haven't thought of him as potentially being the new killer, I think if it was him though there'd be to many plot holes.

Emma's mum would also be a very big surprise if it was her but I very much doubt that.

What do we make of the sheriffs son acing the mask? I don't think it is him, I think he is a bit odd but is one of the good guys, they're adding all of this 'unknown mystery' to his character.
lol as soon as he picked it up I was like, why the **** would you pick that up when it could potentially be evidence. Stupid lol
 
The killer has to be one of the new characters, so one of Eli or Gustavo.
Unless the new killer is spying using a different malware, then the killer (or one of them) has to be a member of the Lakewood 6 - the 'Boy Interrupted' jibe with Jake shows that they were at the party at the start of the season.

Like I said, I see it as being Noah at the moment.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Kevin/Branson stick out to me because I'm not sure why the show brought them back other than to be a killer, especially Branson. Kevin has had a role so far but could be the master mind behind it all and Branson arrival this season seems suspicious to me.

I have read a lot of theories that Noah is the killer but I just can't see it. If he was the killer they would have to kill him off and Noah is the show IMO, unless the show runners know there is no season 3.
 
Kevin/Branson stick out to me because I'm not sure why the show brought them back other than to be a killer, especially Branson. Kevin has had a role so far but could be the master mind behind it all and Branson arrival this season seems suspicious to me.

I have read a lot of theories that Noah is the killer but I just can't see it. If he was the killer they would have to kill him off and Noah is the show IMO, unless the show runners know there is no season 3.

I was thinking Kevin and Branson could be the killer/s too.
 
Yeah I watched the 4 episodes again and he was the most obvious to me. It makes sense that he would be texting Brooke and leaving flowers for her knowing spoiler is dead.
 
Anybody could have figured out it was Audrey, he was caught spying on people in season 1. He would need to be in a lot more episodes coming up to be a worthy killer. I would like it to be a complete surprise like Maggie because season 1 wasn't much of a surprise.

Watched preview and looks like Branson might get his face ironed off next episode, ill have to come up with a new theory now
 
Last edited:
Anybody could have figured out it was Audrey, he was caught spying on people in season 1. He would need to be in a lot more episodes coming up to be a worthy killer. I would like it to be a complete surprise like Maggie because season 1 wasn't much of a surprise.
I'd have to watch Season One back again but I thought Branson was just a pawn and not the one with the malware himself. Maybe you're right.

Either way, he's 99% not the killer IMO.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Wait, who is Branson?

The teacher who had a thing with Brooke in Season 1.

latest
 
Only just noticed something from the first episode (maybe everyone else noticed this, idk) on rewatch.

The pig toy that Jake walked towards and led him into the bear trap is Noah's - he had it with him earlier in the episode at his shop place.
 
Only just noticed something from the first episode (maybe everyone else noticed this, idk) on rewatch.

The pig toy that Jake walked towards and led him into the bear trap is Noah's - he had it with him earlier in the episode at his shop place.
I went and checked it out.
Noah had a red money box at the beginning and the thing that led Jake to the bear trap was pink. Unless you were referring to a different scene?
 
I went and checked it out.
Noah had a red money box at the beginning and the thing that led Jake to the bear trap was pink. Unless you were referring to a different scene?
If it was different the similarity was striking yet subtle - like I said I didn't realise until the second viewing.

Probably just a red herring!
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

If it was different the similarity was striking yet subtle - like I said I didn't realise until the second viewing.

Probably just a red herring!
Pig themes have been in both seasons, I don't read too much into it. But I'm 100% convinced it's can't be Noah so I may be biased;)
 
Pig themes have been in both seasons, I don't read too much into it. But I'm 100% convinced it's can't be Noah so I may be biased;)
I'm 70% convinced it is him, messing with Audrey. But anyway, we'll see! ;)
 
Another person I was suspicious of on rewatch that not many people talk about is the new sheriff. He has connections to the original murders and seems pretty incompetent.
The only thing that made me doubt him was that he was keen to find jake, when he would know jake was dead if he was the killer. Maybe he was pretending to think Jake was alive
 
I'm disappointed, I was expecting the killer to make a statement now that everybody knows there is a killer. I thought the killer would terrorize the school, everybody to fear for their life and get a kill. Kinda like the bowling alley episode last season. The killer has done f'all in 5 episodes, im getting impatient...

Not sure what to think about the psych teacher, she looked like an obvious accomplice in the episode but they wouldn't tell us in episode 5 who a killer is.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom