Should Hall be suspended?

[Effes]

Yes or No

 

[lifelike_]

No.

 

[ELfooty]

Clear strike to the stomach behind play, obviously hit the right spot. Don't reckon he has a good record to help him out either.

 

[patsmith]

If you punch someone in the guts, especially off the ball, you get suspended. We've seen it plenty of times this year, yet players still do it. Stupid, especially in a final.

 

[windyhill]

Gone. One week.

 

[WhyWilliams]

Hall was stiff Channel 10 accidently got it on film. They miss most of the action.

What are we going to see!

1 video tape lost
2 supreme court injunction (aka Dunkley last time)
3 Maguire suspended for running in to Halls fist especially behind play maguire will get Two LOL
4 If Adelaide get up today well it will be the worst Grand Final since Hawthorn v Melbourne.

So yeah let Hall Play he deserves two for being stupid but he might Grand Final day interesting

 

[monfries_young-gun]

Gherig did, Hall should

 

[Minkus_Swan]

Gherig did, Hall should

Archer didn't, Hall shouldn't

 

[BarcaRulz]

As much as id like to see him play, id have to say YES! he hit a bloke with a clenched fist right in the stomach, 40 meters off the ball... that is just plain dumb!

 

[Poptart]

Hall will play, no doubt about that.

He has a clean record for the past 3 years according to AFL, investigated by Bondy at 3AW. Low contact, Hall will say he was trying to get McGuire out of the play to contest the ball.

Will recieve a reprimand and around 90 odd points, not enough for suspension if he pleads guilty.

Besides do you really think the AFL would want Barry to miss, not a chance in hell!

 

[SBI]

The full video which sees him running back with McGuire and then turning looks better for Hall.

And McGuire will no doubt say he dived.

 

[Awesome_Wells]

No.

 

[Corrosion]

If Judd and Archer and co didn't get suspended over their incidents in the past 10 weeks, then the tribunal needs to keep its consistency and NOT suspend Hall.

 

[Croat tiger]

he's a dog,off with his head.

 

[Shell]

Yes, going on how the (ridiculous) tribunal has gone this year. Behind play, past record... doesnt look good.

 

[Juddyzthebest]

Based on other chargable offences during the year, Judd/Gehrig/Gardiner he should go.

Having said that he wont. Massive sympathy cause he is like the captain or whatever and cause its the GF. They will not suspend Barry Hall.

 

[Markthirtytwo]

No, now that Adelaide is out of the race.

 

[Bretski]

yes

 

[Borry]

hes not, and he shouldn't.