Simon Black, Shane Crawford, Scott West

[blue_n_wyte]

Black is parking the car outside the ballpark.

Crawford was on the way but his car broke down.

West hasn't left home yet.

Id say that's the worst comment on football I've ever read! West was a champion n crawf broke down on the way? 1st black/west 2nd crawford If dogs played more finals whist west has been there he'd of been a dual brownlow medialst not to mention 8 b/f's

 

[lancaster]

1. That one piece of play is just an example of the class of Scott West. He's been doing those sorts of things for years, I only highlight that particular one because it was against your mob in a big game.

2. I didn't suggest Collingwood's eagerness to sign him meant that he must be considered as good as the others mentioned. How you could misconstrue it in this fashion leads me to question your brightness. It does however, appear quite likely a contributing factor towards your overt bitterness towards him. You offered your hand, and he rejected it.

3. I only 'quoted' that particular post of yours because it was (to that point) the latest in a string of vitriolic and closed-minded posts that led me to believe such anger could only be the result of jealousy and envy.

4. You may well be waiting quite some time for an answer on that one, as I agree with the large amount of replies that suggest to compare KP players and midfielders is pure folly.

5. 5 times All-Australian. 7 time club best & fairest winner. 5 top five finishes in the Brownlow medal including twice runner-up. 324 games of perhaps unmatched consistency. Hard, tough worker in the 'engine-room'. No squibbing from the outskirts for Westy.

How could he NOT be mentioned amongst the elite midfielders of his generation?

well done mate, absolutely smashed him.

Maybe Mokbel should appoint you as his defence counsel!