LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Great pick. If I kept 19, he would have been the one.
-
Mobile App Discontinued
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Trading Places Snake's trading game draft thread
- Thread starter Snake Charmer
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Great pick. If I kept 19, he would have been the one.
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
3 for me, maybe 4, just haven't decided how many I'm upgrading. Probably see how the draft is going and whether I upgrade a rookie, or take a gamble.
I won't take a heap of time with 3 picks in the next five, so can give Prochard123 a little more time...
LukeParkerno1
Post-Human
Give him till 11:15am.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Prochard123
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jul 28, 2014
- 7,147
- 5,773
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
alright ill need 10 minutes
Prochard123
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jul 28, 2014
- 7,147
- 5,773
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Pick 24-Will Hayward
Pick 25 - Geelong
Harrison Macreadie - Henty
Three reasons, one, i like him, two I see him as a replacement for the aging Harry Taylor and Tom Lonergan in my backline, and three I feel he was the most likely of my next few to be taken Port at the next pick before my two...
Magpies2010 your up...
Harrison Macreadie - Henty
Three reasons, one, i like him, two I see him as a replacement for the aging Harry Taylor and Tom Lonergan in my backline, and three I feel he was the most likely of my next few to be taken Port at the next pick before my two...
Magpies2010 your up...
Prochard123
Norm Smith Medallist
- Jul 28, 2014
- 7,147
- 5,773
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Since we are planning to get others to rate the performance. I suggest you all do what I did and make a short summary of all the trade/draft moves like this.
Collingwood
1 Greene, Toby
2 De Goey, Jordan
3 Talia, Daniel
4 Grundy, Brodie
5 Elliott, Jamie
6 Goldsack, Tyson
7 Treloar, Adam
8. Hartlett, Hamish
9 Jenkins, Josh
10 Pendlebury, Scott
11 Grimes, Jack
12 Scharenberg, Matthew
13 Collins, Sam
14 Aish, James
15 Dunn, Lynden
16 Barlow, Michael
17 Rosa, Matt
18 Sinclair, Ben
19 Maric, Ivan
20 Reid, Ben
21 Phillips, Tom
22 Sidebottom, Steele
23 Keeffe, Lachlan
24 Mayne, Christopher
25 Thomas, Josh
26 Cutler, Tom
27 Hayward, Will
29 Broomhead, Timothy
30 Moore, Darcy
31 Ramsay, Jackson
33 Wills, Rupert
34 Hoskin-Elliott, Will
35 Jarrad Mcveigh
37 Maynard, Brayden
38 Howe, Jeremy
39 Crocker, Ben
46 Cox, Mason
35 players.
Best 22:
B: Jeremy Howe ~ Daniel Talia ~ Brayden Maynard
HB: Jarrad Mcveigh ~ Ben Reid ~ Hamish Hartlett
C: Steele Sidebottom ~ Scott Pendlebury ~ Daniel Wells
HF: Will-Hoskin Elliot ~ Josh Jenkins ~ Toby Greene
F: Chris Mayne ~ Darcy Moore ~ Jamie Elliot
R: Brodie Grundy ~ Adam Treloar ~ Michael Barlow
Int: Matthew Scharenberg, James Aish, Jordan De Goey, Tim Broomhead
Emergency: Sam Collins, Tom Cutler, Will Hayward
Collingwood will not listen to offers for the following players:
Trades:
1. Taylor Adams + Pick 44 for Daniel Talia
2. Levi Greenwood for pick 43
3. Pick 28+Jesse White for Josh Jenkins
4. Tom Langdon for Sam Collins
5. Pick 62 for Scott Thompson
6. Pick 65 for Ivan Maric:
7. Jarryd Blair + Pick 43 for Pick 38
Thank god Jarryd Blair is gone.
8. Adam Oxley for Tom Cutler
9. Pick 51, Brayden Sier, Travis Varcoe for Sam Reid and Jarrad Mcveigh
10. Josh Smith+ Pick 38 for Pick 30, 31
11. Sam Reid for Pick 32
12. Pick 32, Ben Sinclair for Scott Selwood, 28, 72
13. Jack Crisp + Pick 72 for Dom Tyson + Pick 102
14. Scott Selwood for pick 33.
15. Scott Thompson for pick 63.
16. Alex Fasolo + Pick 63 for Pick 32 (Required trade)
17. Dom Tyson + Pick 30 for Pick 14 + Pick 16
18. Pick 16, 33 for Toby Greene, 49
19. Pick 31, 32, 82 for Fremantle's 2017 first round pick, pick 56, 60
20. Pick 28 for Hamish Hartlett
21. Pick 56, 60 for Matt Rosa, Michael Barlow
22. Pick 14 for Pick 24, 33, Sinclair
Picks available:
2016
24, 33, 49
2017
Collingwood 1st round pick, Fremantle 1st round pick.
In:
1. Toby Greene
All Australian dynamic half forward at the age of 23. Also has some midfield capabilities while kicking multiple goals per game. At such a young age, he has already entered into elite territory and we are thrilled to have him.
2. Daniel Talia
All Australian full back at the age of 25. We couldn't believe it when the Adams-Talia deal went through. If there's 1 addition that would strengthen our team the most, it would be Talia. The All Australian key defender is everything the Pies had hope for and more. Perfect list fit, massive trade bargain.
3. Hamish Hartlett
One of the most damaging outside player there is. Top level run and carry and has an absolutely potent kick. Has previously struggled with tags but that won't be an issue at Collingwood with others such as Wells, Treloar, Pendlebury, Sidebottom.
4. Jarrad Mcveigh
After recruiting the talented half-back Tom Cutler, we felt that our backline was still too young and needed further development before full AFL exposure, so we brought in the experienced Jarrad Mcveigh. Despite being in the later stages of his career, Mcveigh still offers very good rebounding service and will prove to be invaluable towards the development of Tom Cutler and Matthew Scharenberg
5. Josh Jenkins
Jenkins probably was the Pies' second greatest recruit in the offseason. Kicked 62 goals in the year, averaging close to 3 a game, while also playing a large proportion of his game as a lead up forward and back up ruckman, some would argue he deserved a final spot in the All Australian Squad. Regardless, being part of the AA 40 men squad, Jenkins is a high profile centre half forward and would immediately strengthen our best 22.
6. Jack Grimes
Picked up as a DFA. Purely from a best available basis, we felt he still had something to offer in AFL, and would be a solid back up to our best 6 defenders.
7. Sam Collins
Before recruiting the highly touted Daniel Talia, we were set on having Collins shoulder the full-back responsibility in 2017. He is undoubtedly a talent we really rate. At the age of 22, he has already held his spot as an AFL full-back to a very high level of performance. The growth potential is immense, and having him as the back-up to Reid, Talia gives us the green light to HEAVILY pursue Key forwards in the 2017 draft.
8. Michael Barlow
I never understood why he was so underrated by Fremantle and Ross Lyons. He is in our opinion a top 20 inside midfielder in the comp, and was criminally played out of position in the last few years. His contested ability and contribution to clearances is elite. Being a strong bodied player (189 cm 91 kg), he would add the grunt and defensive work necessary to complement the offensive midfielders such as Wells, Pendlebury, Treloar and Sidebottom. Considering how cheap he went for, another massive bargain.
9. Matt Rosa
With the departure of Crisp, Adams, Greenwood. We felt that the inclusion of solely Barlow isn't enough to take us far in our 2017 premiership campaign. Therefore, we brought in Rosa as our depth midfielder, who on a good day, can still be a solid B grader.
10. Ivan Maric
We brought him in as our back-up ruckman and ruck coach. We thought Maric was the ideal fit for this position for a number of reasons. Firstly, performance wise he's achieved a very high level in his prime years. Secondly, he plays a very similar playstyle to Grundy, being that mobile ruckman who is superb around the ground but only above average in taps. Thirdly, he still can offer decent AFL level performance when Grundy is rested. Other candidates considered: Minson, Currie.
11. Tom Cutler
Tom does not nearly get the credit he deserves, perhaps due to not many people watching Brisbane matches, but he has been undoubtedly one of Brisbane's few shining lights in 2016. Strong run and carry, good footskills, pace, he's got it all. He is part of our future plans and will currently compete a defense spot on the bench with Matthew Scharenberg. We hope the 2 together can eventually take over from Hartlett and Mcveigh and resume the damaging half-back roles.
12. Fremantle's 2017 1st round pick.
The 2017 draft is looking like the strongest Key forward draft in the past decade. Currently, Collingwood has 2 first round picks and will use one of them for a highly regarded key forward, and the second one perhaps for another KPF or a slider as others are immersed by the wealth of key position players. There's also the synergy with the recruitment of Jenkins, who will shoulder the Key forward load for a few years, just enough time for the 1 or 2 key forwards we will recruit next year.
13. Will Hayward (Pick 24)
15th on my list for the 2016 draft. He's a strong marking half forward, who is both damaging on the lead as well as being a great marking option inside 50. As the list stands, Collingwood is set in terms of defence and ruck talents, and will continue to pursue midfielders and non-KPF forwards in the draft.
14. (Pick 33)
15 (Pick 49)
Out:
-Taylor Adams
-Jack Crisp
-Levi Greenwood
-Adam Oxley
-Jesse White
-Alex Fasolo
-Jarryd Blair
-Tom Langdon
-Josh Smith
-Brayden Sier
-Travis Varcoe
-Pick 28
-Pick 44
-Pick 51
-Pick 62
-Pick 65
-Pick 82
Makes it easier for the judges.
Collingwood
1 Greene, Toby
2 De Goey, Jordan
3 Talia, Daniel
4 Grundy, Brodie
5 Elliott, Jamie
6 Goldsack, Tyson
7 Treloar, Adam
8. Hartlett, Hamish
9 Jenkins, Josh
10 Pendlebury, Scott
11 Grimes, Jack
12 Scharenberg, Matthew
13 Collins, Sam
14 Aish, James
15 Dunn, Lynden
16 Barlow, Michael
17 Rosa, Matt
18 Sinclair, Ben
19 Maric, Ivan
20 Reid, Ben
21 Phillips, Tom
22 Sidebottom, Steele
23 Keeffe, Lachlan
24 Mayne, Christopher
25 Thomas, Josh
26 Cutler, Tom
27 Hayward, Will
29 Broomhead, Timothy
30 Moore, Darcy
31 Ramsay, Jackson
33 Wills, Rupert
34 Hoskin-Elliott, Will
35 Jarrad Mcveigh
37 Maynard, Brayden
38 Howe, Jeremy
39 Crocker, Ben
46 Cox, Mason
35 players.
Best 22:
B: Jeremy Howe ~ Daniel Talia ~ Brayden Maynard
HB: Jarrad Mcveigh ~ Ben Reid ~ Hamish Hartlett
C: Steele Sidebottom ~ Scott Pendlebury ~ Daniel Wells
HF: Will-Hoskin Elliot ~ Josh Jenkins ~ Toby Greene
F: Chris Mayne ~ Darcy Moore ~ Jamie Elliot
R: Brodie Grundy ~ Adam Treloar ~ Michael Barlow
Int: Matthew Scharenberg, James Aish, Jordan De Goey, Tim Broomhead
Emergency: Sam Collins, Tom Cutler, Will Hayward
Collingwood will not listen to offers for the following players:
- Brodie Grundy
- Adam Treloar
- Darcy Moore
- Daniel Talia
- Jamie Elliot
- Steele Sidebottom
- Ben Reid
- Toby Greene
Trades:
1. Taylor Adams + Pick 44 for Daniel Talia
2. Levi Greenwood for pick 43
3. Pick 28+Jesse White for Josh Jenkins
4. Tom Langdon for Sam Collins
5. Pick 62 for Scott Thompson
6. Pick 65 for Ivan Maric:
7. Jarryd Blair + Pick 43 for Pick 38
Thank god Jarryd Blair is gone.
8. Adam Oxley for Tom Cutler
9. Pick 51, Brayden Sier, Travis Varcoe for Sam Reid and Jarrad Mcveigh
10. Josh Smith+ Pick 38 for Pick 30, 31
11. Sam Reid for Pick 32
12. Pick 32, Ben Sinclair for Scott Selwood, 28, 72
13. Jack Crisp + Pick 72 for Dom Tyson + Pick 102
14. Scott Selwood for pick 33.
15. Scott Thompson for pick 63.
16. Alex Fasolo + Pick 63 for Pick 32 (Required trade)
17. Dom Tyson + Pick 30 for Pick 14 + Pick 16
18. Pick 16, 33 for Toby Greene, 49
19. Pick 31, 32, 82 for Fremantle's 2017 first round pick, pick 56, 60
20. Pick 28 for Hamish Hartlett
21. Pick 56, 60 for Matt Rosa, Michael Barlow
22. Pick 14 for Pick 24, 33, Sinclair
Picks available:
2016
24, 33, 49
2017
Collingwood 1st round pick, Fremantle 1st round pick.
In:
1. Toby Greene
All Australian dynamic half forward at the age of 23. Also has some midfield capabilities while kicking multiple goals per game. At such a young age, he has already entered into elite territory and we are thrilled to have him.
2. Daniel Talia
All Australian full back at the age of 25. We couldn't believe it when the Adams-Talia deal went through. If there's 1 addition that would strengthen our team the most, it would be Talia. The All Australian key defender is everything the Pies had hope for and more. Perfect list fit, massive trade bargain.
3. Hamish Hartlett
One of the most damaging outside player there is. Top level run and carry and has an absolutely potent kick. Has previously struggled with tags but that won't be an issue at Collingwood with others such as Wells, Treloar, Pendlebury, Sidebottom.
4. Jarrad Mcveigh
After recruiting the talented half-back Tom Cutler, we felt that our backline was still too young and needed further development before full AFL exposure, so we brought in the experienced Jarrad Mcveigh. Despite being in the later stages of his career, Mcveigh still offers very good rebounding service and will prove to be invaluable towards the development of Tom Cutler and Matthew Scharenberg
5. Josh Jenkins
Jenkins probably was the Pies' second greatest recruit in the offseason. Kicked 62 goals in the year, averaging close to 3 a game, while also playing a large proportion of his game as a lead up forward and back up ruckman, some would argue he deserved a final spot in the All Australian Squad. Regardless, being part of the AA 40 men squad, Jenkins is a high profile centre half forward and would immediately strengthen our best 22.
6. Jack Grimes
Picked up as a DFA. Purely from a best available basis, we felt he still had something to offer in AFL, and would be a solid back up to our best 6 defenders.
7. Sam Collins
Before recruiting the highly touted Daniel Talia, we were set on having Collins shoulder the full-back responsibility in 2017. He is undoubtedly a talent we really rate. At the age of 22, he has already held his spot as an AFL full-back to a very high level of performance. The growth potential is immense, and having him as the back-up to Reid, Talia gives us the green light to HEAVILY pursue Key forwards in the 2017 draft.
8. Michael Barlow
I never understood why he was so underrated by Fremantle and Ross Lyons. He is in our opinion a top 20 inside midfielder in the comp, and was criminally played out of position in the last few years. His contested ability and contribution to clearances is elite. Being a strong bodied player (189 cm 91 kg), he would add the grunt and defensive work necessary to complement the offensive midfielders such as Wells, Pendlebury, Treloar and Sidebottom. Considering how cheap he went for, another massive bargain.
9. Matt Rosa
With the departure of Crisp, Adams, Greenwood. We felt that the inclusion of solely Barlow isn't enough to take us far in our 2017 premiership campaign. Therefore, we brought in Rosa as our depth midfielder, who on a good day, can still be a solid B grader.
10. Ivan Maric
We brought him in as our back-up ruckman and ruck coach. We thought Maric was the ideal fit for this position for a number of reasons. Firstly, performance wise he's achieved a very high level in his prime years. Secondly, he plays a very similar playstyle to Grundy, being that mobile ruckman who is superb around the ground but only above average in taps. Thirdly, he still can offer decent AFL level performance when Grundy is rested. Other candidates considered: Minson, Currie.
11. Tom Cutler
Tom does not nearly get the credit he deserves, perhaps due to not many people watching Brisbane matches, but he has been undoubtedly one of Brisbane's few shining lights in 2016. Strong run and carry, good footskills, pace, he's got it all. He is part of our future plans and will currently compete a defense spot on the bench with Matthew Scharenberg. We hope the 2 together can eventually take over from Hartlett and Mcveigh and resume the damaging half-back roles.
12. Fremantle's 2017 1st round pick.
The 2017 draft is looking like the strongest Key forward draft in the past decade. Currently, Collingwood has 2 first round picks and will use one of them for a highly regarded key forward, and the second one perhaps for another KPF or a slider as others are immersed by the wealth of key position players. There's also the synergy with the recruitment of Jenkins, who will shoulder the Key forward load for a few years, just enough time for the 1 or 2 key forwards we will recruit next year.
13. Will Hayward (Pick 24)
15th on my list for the 2016 draft. He's a strong marking half forward, who is both damaging on the lead as well as being a great marking option inside 50. As the list stands, Collingwood is set in terms of defence and ruck talents, and will continue to pursue midfielders and non-KPF forwards in the draft.
14. (Pick 33)
15 (Pick 49)
Out:
-Taylor Adams
-Jack Crisp
-Levi Greenwood
-Adam Oxley
-Jesse White
-Alex Fasolo
-Jarryd Blair
-Tom Langdon
-Josh Smith
-Brayden Sier
-Travis Varcoe
-Pick 28
-Pick 44
-Pick 51
-Pick 62
-Pick 65
-Pick 82
Makes it easier for the judges.
- Apr 11, 2011
- 8,345
- 6,157
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Minnesota Timberwolves
- Thread starter
- #109
- May 14, 2012
- 8,334
- 13,246
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Apr 11, 2011
- 8,345
- 6,157
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Minnesota Timberwolves
- Thread starter
- #114
All good, I'm gonna do my write ups at the end
- Apr 11, 2011
- 8,345
- 6,157
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Minnesota Timberwolves
- Apr 11, 2011
- 8,345
- 6,157
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Minnesota Timberwolves
- Oct 6, 2013
- 9,139
- 6,332
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Sixers, Exers, GWS Womens
Has Taranto and Scrimshaw been picked yet?
- May 14, 2012
- 8,334
- 13,246
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Picks 9 and 12
- Apr 11, 2011
- 8,345
- 6,157
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Minnesota Timberwolves
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
- May 14, 2012
- 8,334
- 13,246
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Oct 6, 2013
- 9,139
- 6,332
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Sixers, Exers, GWS Womens
I'll list 3 players from favourite(1) and least(3) for my next 2 Picks(31, 32) as I don't know who Thommo will get
1. Jack Graham
2. Jordan Ridley
3. Patrick Kerr
1. Jack Graham
2. Jordan Ridley
3. Patrick Kerr
- May 14, 2012
- 8,334
- 13,246
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- May 14, 2012
- 8,334
- 13,246
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Good games a quick game
- Apr 11, 2011
- 8,345
- 6,157
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Minnesota Timberwolves
- Thread starter
- #125
Bulldogs take Luke Ryan.
