So then who comes in next week

[lynchy4610]

Out: Browne, Griffiths, Helbig, Batchelor?, Farmer? Grigg? Nahas? Jackson?,

In: Graham McGuane, Tuck, Miller, , Morton, Connors (if fit if not Conca)

Wish we where in a position where we could drop guys like Grigg ,Jackson, Nahas etc but we are not.

Our forward line is okay, midfield very soft, backline is a shambles

 

[Jisha]

Just bring in everyone from Coburg, can't be any worse.

 

[Croat tiger]

Time to throw up some kids like westhoff just to see what they have got, they can't be any worse than what's going around right now.

 

[RichosGuns]

Damn Helbig was shit today.

How he got a game is beyond me?

Hasn't even appeared in the best at Coburg.

 

[Fumbles]

For a down right horrible day I didn't think Browne did anything to warrant dropping him. He was actually decent below his knees a couple of times today. He certainly put in effort for the day which can't be said for everyone.

 

[peejay]

For a down right horrible day I didn't think Browne did anything to warrant dropping him. He was actually decent below his knees a couple of times today. He certainly put in effort for the day which can't be said for everyone.

gotta disagree with that - he applied no physical pressure whatso ever - none !

 

[Rustof]

I'll put my hand up to play.

 

[Fumbles]

gotta disagree with that - he applied no physical pressure whatso ever - none !

Hardly any player did. I couldn't put a number of the amount of times tackles didn't stick

 

[RichoRichoRicho]

Not that simple. Team needs games and kgs. Outmuscled everytime. That's said there 3-5 that need to go based on skill and courage. Thurs Edwards farmer etc

 

[heyjoe3]

if tuck is not in the side next week its a joke! how can we continue to get smashed in the clearances! our young guys would not be learning anything from that.yeh it wouldnt of changed anything today but u just cant let it happen week in week out

 

[rideclutch]

Don't think it matters who they put in, it's not like we're running rich with depth. Players need to have a good look at themselves after today, but really they're still in the early stages of a long-term development.

if tuck is not in the side next week its a joke! how can we continue to get smashed in the clearances! our young guys would not be learning anything from that.yeh it wouldnt of changed anything today but u just cant let it happen week in week out

Yeah that's a good point, but if they've decided that Tuck is not part of the long term picture, I'd prefer they just copped it on their chin and get on with it. Don't want them to go back to using stop-gap players to fill the team.

 

[tunksy]

tuck in helbig out.

wouldnt question edwards courage, just his skills.

 

[Cathal Brugha]

..Goo..

 

[heyjoe3]

Don't think it matters who they put in, it's not like we're running rich with depth. Players need to have a good look at themselves after today, but really they're still in the early stages of a long-term development.

Yeah that's a good point, but if they've decided that Tuck is not part of the long term picture, I'd prefer they just copped it on their chin and get on with it. Don't want them to go back to using stop-gap players to fill the team.

does every player of your team have to be part of the future? no but surely you need to address the areas u continue to get smashed in!

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Damn Helbig was shit today.

How he got a game is beyond me?

Hasn't even appeared in the best at Coburg.

He had an ankle injury for most of the match.

 

[Gak Attack]

If Tuck doesn't get a game in the guts from the first bounce after that effort today we should all boycott the game....

Graham is certainly the lesser of two evils and needs to come back in.

Thursfield is just as shit as fumbles it seems, both probably delisted at the end of the year... perhaps worth going in undersized? we couldn't do much worse and Rance, Grimes and Moore are clearly ahead of those 2 so it would be wasted spots playing them now finals is clearly out of the picture.

 

[Rubber Hips]

gotta disagree with that - he applied no physical pressure whatso ever - none !

Be fair... He was double teamed againgst 2 quality ruckmen... More of a selection error BBD was ok certainly not the worst

 

[Hipster Doofus]

Griff should stay in if the hit to the ribs wasn't to bad, the kid has got talent, plaease just let him stay in the team and develop alongside Jack and Vick

 

[dothebowdenshuffle]

In - Graham, Gourdis, Tuck, Morton, Conca, Nason

Out - Browne, Thursfield, Helbig, Hislop, Grigg, Griffiths (inj)

No Coburg game this weekend so not subject to who plays well at VFL level

 

[Bojangles17]

does it matter...TBH cotchin, martin and lids should the the first dropped, played like irish rookies the lot of them, good players are they...pfffftttttttttt...could have ****en well fooled me, ed curnow was better than the lot of them, thats right some bum thats kicked around in the VFL for last few seasons, was first to the ball, TACKLED and showed some interest

 

[Hipster Doofus]

does it matter...TBH cotchin, martin and lids should the the first dropped, played like irish rookies the lot of them, good players are they...pfffftttttttttt...could have ****en well fooled me, ed curnow was better than the lot of them, thats right some bum thats kicked around in the VFL for last few seasons, was first to the ball, TACKLED and showed some interest

Didn't play, must have been real bad

 

[TheCuzEffect]

Blokes who haven't played a game yet... Don't care who comes out.

 

[delediofan3]

I'll put my hand up to play.

Me too, i'm 15. I'm an accurate kick. I get my own contested ball. I lead up for teammates. I've got lightning speed. I've got good defensive skills.
Where do i sign up??

 

[Neen]

In - Graham, Gourdis, Tuck, Morton, Conca, Nason

Out - Browne, Thursfield, Helbig, Hislop, Grigg, Griffiths (inj)

No Coburg game this weekend so not subject to who plays well at VFL level

I agree with the changes. Browne needs a rest. Griffiths looked underdone but showed signs that as long as he is fit, he has a big future.

Edwards should be told that if he does not contribute, then White will automatically take his place in the side. A fit Connors could replace Farmer.

 

[Groupie_]

Thursfield should never again play in a yellow and black jumper. In: Gourdis. Should not have been dropped. Simple.