Autopsy Swans vs Tigers - 3 things you learnt

[Chaisa]

Goodes grabbed the guys nuts?

Not really. Barely touched Hunt IMO. Clearly Hunt wasn't happy though.

 

[SBD Gonzalez]

Maybe its called passion for your club through thick and thin. Something swans supporters should learn from.

Thanks for the advice.

Yes, we all came on board at 5pm on Saturday 29th September 2012, so we have quite a bit to learn.

P!ss off.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Thanks for the advice.

Yes, we all came on board at 5pm on Saturday 29th September 2012, so we have quite a bit to learn.

P!ss off.

Showing disappointment at the result = abandoning and ripping up your membership apparently

 

[The King!]

Maybe its called passion for your club through thick and thin. Something swans supporters should learn from.

Oh yeah so where do we order the manure from to send to our club, got my membership in the microwave and will go spit on longmire next week #passion

 

[scaryness]

Showing disappointment at the result = abandoning and ripping up your membership apparently

Good thing he dropped by. Richmond supporters are very experienced in properly disposing of a membership.

 

[MickyG]

1. Teams that have had a bye should be playing against each other the following week.
2. Very reliant on midfield performance
3. I need a cup of tea, a becs and a good lie down

 

[Punts]

heck the bye bullshit , looked good in the first half to me. Lazy 2nd half with no guts when it counted.

Cats last year was of a bye

 

[The King!]

Agree

As i said if it is somehow the bye then manage everyone better

Known since october there was a bye coming

 

[RW]

I would say Buddy was at least Medium. Tippett's could be Low.

Honestly at the time I thought there was nothing in Buddy's, Edwards was fine though he did come off for a concussion test (which he passed) so I can understand the contact being assessed as medium. I saw it as more of a collision than a bump, though he did run past the ball and it was high, so he could get a week, at most two. Tippett really shouldn't get more than a fine.

Incidentally, Hardwick said he didn't think either player would be suspended:

"I think they will both be OK, we want to see the good players playing," Hardwick said post-match.

"Accidents happen. I think the Tribunal has done a pretty good job at this stage with those sorts of incidents and the reality is we want to see good players play.

"They will make a decision in due course."

 

[HighFlyer]

Wow I reckon buddy and Tippet are going to get stuffed big time here by the AFL. The media want blood and have a look at the opp fans jump aboard.

Tippet will get a fine you'd think. While it looked "nasty" there wasn't much force and was more careless than intentional.

 

[SilentHunter_]

Tippet will get a fine you'd think. While it looked "nasty" there wasn't much force and was more careless than intentional.

My thoughts as well, but lol MRP is unpredictable buddy should get 2 and fair enough, or maybe at worst 3 down to 2.

 

[HighFlyer]

Richmond fans are pretty out and about for a team that will bow out in Week 1 yet again.

I think you'll find the majority of us are pretty realistic. We are a 6-8 side. Having said that right now Sydney's credentials aren't that much better this year. You've beaten the Hawks and GWS inside the 8.

My thoughts as well, but lol MRP is unpredictable buddy should get 2 and fair enough, or maybe at worst 3 down to 2.

If Edwards had been concussed it would have been 3 down to 2 you'd think. It's likely a 2 down to 1. I think the media are all over him because he keeps doing it and he's stated he needs to tackle more and bump less. When he is frustrated he tries to get into the game and tries to hard .

 

[Superstar swan]

No excuse for shaw to be in the side. Jones showed alot more in the 20 minutes he played. Cannot see any advantage of playing shaw instead of jones.

 

[The King!]

No excuse for shaw to be in the side. Jones showed alot more in the 20 minutes he played. Cannot see any advantage of playing shaw instead of jones.

A few here want to crucify Jones for the 50

 

[The King!]

Wayne Carey reckons a month for buddy

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Wayne Carey reckons a month for buddy

Wait so 5 weeks down to 4?

LOL

 

[Superstar swan]

A few here want to crucify Jones for the 50

No way. He is a young kid who slipped up in the heat of battle. It shows me a couple of things...he has intensity, passion and cares. This kid has largely been skipped over by horse and he still showed commitment to re sign.

He cannot be blamed for the loss. If some of his teammates had shown the same intensity and passion throughout the game, his indescretion would have been irrelevent

 

[The King!]

No way. He is a young kid who slipped up in the heat of battle. It shows me a couple of things...he has intensity, passion and cares. This kid has largely been skipped over by horse and he still showed commitment to re sign.

He cannot be blamed for the loss. If some of his teammates had shown the same intensity and passion throughout the game, his indescretion would have been irrelevent

Im with you

More young guys with promise getting a bloody go the better

 

[RW]

Wayne Carey reckons a month for buddy

Yeah I heard that on the radio, that's crazy considering the nature of the incident. Has he lost his mind?

 

[The King!]

Wait so 5 weeks down to 4?

LOL

He said extremely lucky if he gets 4 reduced to 3

 

[The King!]

Yeah I heard that on the radio, that's crazy considering the nature of the incident. Has he lost his mind?

Seems almost as Anti sydney as dermie when i hear him

Especially hates our forwards

 

[Jack2Jack]

Lol Carey towing the company line, what a dead shit flog. MRP are pretty spineless won't be surprised to see them bow down to media pressure. They're all desperate for Buddy to be suspended long enough to miss the Hawks..pretty transparent.... If we were playing the dockers in 3 weeks they wouldn't care less.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

So Buddy Bump was worst than this?



Sidebottom got 4 weeks 3 with a early plea

 

[robbieando]

He said extremely lucky if he gets 4 reduced to 3

Well the woman basher should learn himself a few facts - 4 down to 3 isn't even on the MRP penalty table so to get a penalty like that Buddy would have to be referred to the tribunal by the MRP. I think most would agree this isn't worthy of going to the tribunal.

But like most drug taking woman bashers facts aren't their strong point

 

[robbieando]

So Buddy Bump was worst than this?



Sidebottom got 4 weeks 3 with a early plea

That was under last years system, so different table the MRP are now to consider and yes its worse than Buddy's Bump