The official "X v Y" thread

[Clutch]

Thats a real tough choice, either way i think u will be ok. Pavlich for consistency and Buddy for those amazing scores but also some low scores. I would jsut lean towards Pav at this stage but Buddy could be as good if not better. Mine is:
Hodge and Hasleby vs P Burgoyne and J Selwood.

 

[Sunday Red]

I have two options:

Upgrade Dal Santo to Cross/Judd?

Upgrade O'keefe to Boomer?

Second one easily. Boomer will average you those great 100+ scores but Dal Santo should as well. In other words, I can see the difference between O'Keefe/Boomer being greater than that to Dal Santo/Judd/Cross.

 

[Doc Wieldon]

T Tuck vs C Masten? i can afford to ugrade one to Selwood and i can't work out who'll get me the greatest points/cash return. Thoughts?

 

[IDIG]

Should be Tuck v Morton imo. Tuck playing for a winning side but probably less likely to get 22 games compared to Morton. Morton playing for a losing side with probbaly more pressure with disposal but more likely to play a significant role for his team.

 

[AD03]

Gruffles, I'd go Judd to be honest, Wells hasn't convinced me, too inconsistent.... whoopty doo he performed well in the pre-season! I'd like Foley but I'd prefer to go with the known gun in Judd!


2 Decisions to go and my team is finally finished!

1st Dilemma:

- Hodge, Adcock, Bartel??

- S. Fisher, Drummond, Bartel??

- Hodge, Drummond, Dane Swan??


other midfielders: Ablett, Judd, Selwood, Gibbs, Rich
other defenders: Goddard, Cornes, Malceski, Raines, Hill


2nd Dilemma:

- Cox and Leunberger??

- Hille and McIntosh??

 

[trix17]

i would go with fisher, drummond, bartel for your first dilemma, although im not sold on drummond myself.

2nd one is a toughie, not having cox is a big risk, but having leuenberger is just as much of a risk, id say toss a coin, haha, sorry cant help with that one.

mine is:
Dal Santo + Gilbee
OR
Cross + Gilbee
OR
Mitchell + Fisher

these positions are for my 2nd defender and my 3rd mid

 

[atcocc]

ok guys this is the last decision i need to make. Ive got 570,000 left in the bank and i foward to pick. So who do u guys think is the best option?

Ive tossed up between picking richo, petrie or okeefe. Who out of these guys would u pick or is there a different option maybe delido

 

[Clutch]

Thats are tough decision to make, i dont have any of those in my team i think i would go for the Del Santo + Gilbee option just ahead of the Cross + Gilbee.

What are thoughts on this decison i have to make:

Hodge and Hasleby vs P Burgoyne and J Selwood?

 

[carltonfan43]

Tough Choice Prob slightly leaning towards the second option as burgoyne gets lot of easy touches on the half back line and selwood is just a gun.

Mine is Adcock Vs Marty Clarke
Also the final spot on my bench Wade Thompson vs Taylor Walker? who will score more and play the most games

 

[Cool Cat]

Tough Choice Prob slightly leaning towards the second option as burgoyne gets lot of easy touches on the half back line and selwood is just a gun.

Mine is Adcock Vs Marty Clarke
Also the final spot on my bench Wade Thompson vs Taylor Walker? who will score more and play the most games

I prefer Adcock to Clarke and I would say Thompson except that he hasn't yet been upgraded from the rookie list has he?

Here's a few for you

Drummond vs McLeod
Kerr vs Wells
Nimrod Vs Finklestein
N Brown vs Rich

 

[carltonfan43]

I Have no idea if he has. Is Taylor Walker on the senior list?

Drummond Mcleod looks to be going downhill
Wells if he doesnt get heavily tagged every game. there is a chance kerr could get suspended.
never heard of the 3rd players. who are they?
Rich will proberly have the biggest year out of all the rookies this year i reckon.

 

[Windas_Magic]

Hille + Leunberger + Deledio + Dal Santo

OR

Cox + McIntosh + Houlihan + Dal Santo

OR

Cox + Leunberger + Houlihan + Hodge

 

[Fitty]

Nathan Krakouer or Hayden Skipworth?

Im leaning towards Krakouer, but who would most likely play more games?

 

[Cool Cat]

I Have no idea if he has. Is Taylor Walker on the senior list?

Drummond Mcleod looks to be going downhill
Wells if he doesnt get heavily tagged every game. there is a chance kerr could get suspended.
never heard of the 3rd players. who are they?
Rich will proberly have the biggest year out of all the rookies this year i reckon.

Sorry, I meant N Brown vs Richo

 

[BenjiXXX]

Sorry, I meant N Brown vs Richo

Richo

Plays his heart out and is a match winner giving his scores great boost. N Brown too injury prone for mine.

My one is simple

Hille or Sandilands?

 

[Cool Cat]

Richo

Plays his heart out and is a match winner giving his scores great boost. N Brown too injury prone for mine.

My one is simple

Hille or Sandilands?

Cheers for the input. Gotta say Hille for your one - been dissappointed when I have chosen Sandilands the last two years and I am keeping away now (potential or no potential).

Here's a complicated one:

Drummond, J. Selwood and Raines

versus

Malceski, Kerr and Brad Johnson

 

[Spartan]

Here's a complicated one:

Drummond, J. Selwood and Raines

versus

Malceski, Kerr and Brad Johnson

not complicated at all. Option 1 easily.

Anyway.

Raines + Richo-man vs Henderson + Boomer

 

[Cool Cat]

not complicated at all. Option 1 easily.

Anyway.

Raines + Richo-man vs Henderson + Boomer

Gotta go option A on that one I'd say. By the way, would you go Richo over Nathan Brown?

 

[Baxter23]

not complicated at all. Option 1 easily.

Anyway.

Raines + Richo-man vs Henderson + Boomer

Raines & Richo.

Both WILL score.
We don't know about Henderson yet, even if he does play I don't think he'll score much.

Gilbee & McIntosh

or

Newman & Kreuzer

 

[Windas_Magic]

not complicated at all. Option 1 easily.

Anyway.

Raines + Richo-man vs Henderson + Boomer

Raines and Richo for me. At least Raines is guaranteed to score 70+ where as with Henderson, number one we don't know if he'll be in their best 22 and number two, it is most likely he'll score reasonably poorly.

Now, mine that got missed (may be a little complicated):

Hille + Leunberger + Deledio + Dal Santo

OR

Cox + McIntosh + Houlihan + Dal Santo

OR

Cox + Leunberger + Houlihan + Hodge

 

[marcmurphy3]

I'd go option 3 there mate narrowly ahead of option 2.

Gibbs vs Selwood vs Wells?

oh and what are peoples thoughts on having a team with all 3 of Selwood, Ablett and Bartel? Is it to much Geelong in one position?

 

[Cool Cat]

I'd go option 2 windas magic - just don't think luenberger's quite there yet. As for wells vs selwood vs squibs I've gotta say selwood's the man. I aim to have selwood, ablett and bartel all in my midfield by season's end.

What do people think of Nathan Brown vs Richo?

 

[Spudregus_87]

RICHO Cool Cat. The man will average 97-105.


This one's doing my head in.......

Adcock & Chapman + 30-odd grand

verses

Drummond & any forward under $488,600. (StevieJ/Porps/Fev/Roughy/Cloke)

If option 2, which forward.....

Thanks guys.

 

[Stanton_Legend]

Franklin or Richo or J Brown

and

Robinson or Otten?

 

[Cool Cat]

RICHO Cool Cat. The man will average 97-105.


This one's doing my head in.......

Adcock & Chapman + 30-odd grand

verses

Drummond & any forward under $488,600. (StevieJ/Porps/Fev/Roughy/Cloke)

If option 2, which forward.....

Thanks guys.

I think option A, although I have moved heaven and earth to fit drummond into my team. Thanks for the input everyone, time for me to knock off (I've been working hard this afternoon, obviously)!