The Player A Vs Player B SUPERMEGATHREAD!!

[jack_lord]

Tom Hawkins or Nathan Thompson

Will Hawkins be getting regular games?
Is Thompson worth picking up or do you think its too soon after injury?

 

[blue_boys]

Riewoldt or B.Johnson ???

Will Riewoldt be effected by his injury ... or is he even injured??

 

[Juddtastic]

Nash vs Jones

I would really like to get people's thoughts on this one!

Leaning towards Jones at the moment due to the fact i think he'll be more consistent

 

[powaflag08]

Cox and Wood

or

Mcintosh and Simmonds?

 

[flackjack]

Bowden + M. Murphy

OR

P.Burgoyne + Goodes

OR

B.Johnson + M. Murphy

 

[Virgil]

^^McIntosh and Simmonds

Bowden + M. Murphy

OR

P.Burgoyne + Goodes

OR

B.Johnson + M. Murphy

Good scoring potential, and provides a suitable captain.

Thoughts on:

Jonathon Brown (406) or Steve Johnson (412)?

 

[trueblue_91]

Kane Cornes and Andrew Mackie

or

Hayes and Joel Bowden

 

[trizzler]

Kane Cornes and Andrew Mackie

or

Hayes and Joel Bowden

kornes + mackie


josh fraser or kosi ?

 

[trueblue_91]

kornes + mackie


josh fraser or kosi ?

for a ruck neither, wood and simmonds are better value for their prices.....and if you don't have him it is allways good to have dean Cox in there.

with my dilemna i am just worried how mackie will perform in the star studded squad like geelong. Kornes is a star, but both lenny and bowden are capable of averaging 95+, Kornes is 100+ but mackie does worry me

 

[mushda]

Hey guys,

Mcintosh and Ellis

or

Wood and Milburn + 20k?

 

[__DaVE]

lucas and simmonds

or

kosi and micintosh/fraser

 

[trueblue_91]

Hey guys,

Mcintosh and Ellis

or

Wood and Milburn + 20k?

Wood + Mackie

 

[geelong16]

Prismall or Dyson?

What do you reckon? both young guns who possibly could have a break through year but who to choose? also what player do you think will get the most game time and matches?

 

[foxy_dal]

Re: Prismall or Dyson?

been trying to decide on this one for a while

 

[mushda]

Thanks trueblue.

 

[powaflag08]

Hey guys,

Mcintosh and Ellis

or

Wood and Milburn + 20k?

Wood, Milburn.

 

[pieman123]

j.brown or riewoldt???

 

[hotchilli5]

barry hall or brendon fevola

 

[Virgil]

barry hall or brendon fevola

In that price range I'd probably take Robert Murphy (I think he's between the two), but of those two I'd take Barry Hall. I think you're in for frustration with either one to be honest.

 

[hotchilli5]

joel corey or pal chapman?

 

[spence]

joel corey or pal chapman?

Chapman

S Thompson or Swan or Stanton or Priddis

 

[Toadvine]

Waters or McPhee

 

[RAW TALENT]

E.Barlow/Houli/B.Johnson
T.Murphy/S.Buckley/S.Johnson ......... + Waters or Birchall????? who should i go i just dont want to make wrong decision.

 

[kingyubbo]

Chapman

S Thompson or Swan or Stanton or Priddis

Your mate Thompson should be the guns this year, if not probably go with Stanton as the Dons have a lack of superstar midfielders, saving you 30k+ to go elsewhere.

 

[spence]

Your mate Thompson should be the guns this year, if not probably go with Stanton as the Dons have a lack of superstar midfielders, saving you 30k+ to go elsewhere.

Cheers mate