The Untouchables

[Turbocat]

Ive heard that Geelong has a list 12 untouchables.Considering some of nanes flying around I thought Id get some feedback on who we thought fell into this group.My list would go deeper than 12 , more like15 or 16
1,KING
2,LING
3,SCARLETT (F/S)
4,HARLEY
5,ABLETT (F/S)
6,BARTEL
7,COREY
8,GRAHAM
9,TENACE
10,S.JOHNSON
11,CHAPMAN
12,MOONEY
13,CALLAN (F/S)
13,MACKIE
15,MILBURN
16,BLAKE (F/S)

Now some of my untouchables are not in my best 22 players such as Blake but I wouldnt trade him so on the list he goes.Probably the highest rated player not on my list would be Wojinski.

 

[Unwritten_Law]

Mine:

Scarlett, King, Harley, Milburn, Ling, Bartel, Kelly, Ablett, Corey, Chapman, Steve Johnson, Mackie, Tenace, Blake, Callan.

 

[Fall Out Boy]

If i had to go with 12, they would be:

King
Harley
Scarlett
Ablett
Ling
S Johnson
Chapman
Tenace
Kelly
Bartel
Milburn
Corey

 

[Catman]

My list would be.

King
Harley
Bartel
Kelly
Tenace
Corey
S.Johnson
Mooney
Ablett
Scarlett
Chapman
Milburn
Hunt
Ling

 

[bulletproof]

If i had to go with 12, they would be:

King
Harley
Scarlett
Ablett
Ling
S Johnson
Chapman
Tenace
Kelly
Bartel
Milburn
Corey

Pretty Close i reckon, drop Chapman and add Mackie.

 

[Fall Out Boy]

Blasphemy

 

[JUBJUB]

Pretty Close i reckon, drop Chapman and add Mackie.

What you talk'in about Willis ????????????

 

[bulletproof]

Not saying he should be traded for anyone but i would be more inclined to trade away a forward pocket than a young developing KPP. Chapman has a lot of trade value and if he can get the deal done i would be happier trading him than any of the others on my list. He is our third best small forward and has been found wanting in a midfield role this is what makes him a trade option (only for Ottens or like) in my books.

 

[skywalk750]

Gardiner showed some good signs and I would be suprised to see him go

 

[Robin Hood]

Chappy is not tradable. Chappy is the heart and soul of this team, if Chappy was traded I would be outraged! I would tear up by membership card and no longer bear any passion for this club.


CHAPPY IS STAYING.

 

[GeeCat]

...if Chappy was traded I would be outraged! I would tear up by membership card and no longer bear any passion for this club.

If such was the case I'd begin to doubt whether such passion was rightly founded in the first place. That really is pathetic if you're being serious.

 

[WestCat]

I'm another Chappy fan. I love the little bald man, his passion and hardness exemplifies exactly what we're trying to build in the club, a willingness to take a hit and go for the ball, giving 110% every week. He along with Ling, Mooney and Ablett show that passion for the club every week and these players must stay.

 

[Robin Hood]

If such was the case I'd begin to doubt whether such passion was rightly founded in the first place. That really is pathetic if you're being serious.

Chappy is such a competitor, I love Chappy, he is so important to the team in terms of passion and enthusiasim. Hands off chappy!

 

[nananana catman]

Gardiner showed some good signs and I would be suprised to see him go

You are Kidding yourself if he is untouchable though.

King
Harley
Bartel
Kelly
Tenace
Corey
Johnson
Ablett
Scarlett
Chapman
Milburn
Smith
Ling

 

[GeeCat]

I'm another Chappy fan. I love the little bald man, his passion and hardness exemplifies exactly what we're trying to build in the club, a willingness to take a hit and go for the ball, giving 110% every week. He along with Ling, Mooney and Ablett show that passion for the club every week and these players must stay.

Chappy is such a competitor, I love Chappy, he is so important to the team in terms of passion and enthusiasim. Hands off chappy!

When did I say we should trade Chapman? I'm anything but for that idea.

I'm simply saying that if indeed your loyalty and attitude towards the club hinges upon one player, it really is quite pathetic.

 

[Turbocat]

Mine:

Scarlett, King, Harley, Milburn, Ling, Bartel, Kelly, Ablett, Corey, Chapman, Steve Johnson, Mackie, Tenace, Blake, Callan.

Thanks Lawo , how could I have missed Kelly,he'd be in anybodys top10
Looking at some other lists , I suppose one could make an argument to trade Mooney but one of these day we are going to be in a GF and it would be nice to have an agro guy thats above 185 just for a change.
The other bone is Chapman or Mackie.Long term Mackie is the keeper, Chapman however would have to be the unluckest player in my Elliot Ness mob to get traded, it would have to be a mind blower of a trade.Top five pick for Chapman would really test our loyalty

 

[GazDude]

mine: ( i got heaps)
scarlo
king
ling
ablett
s. johno
bartel
dash
harley
kelly
joel corey
enright
mackie
wosza
chapman
hunt
moondog
blake