Remove this Banner Ad

thylacine60

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tim H
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

T

Tim H

Team Captain
Joined
Sep 23, 2006
Posts
333
Reaction score
319
Location
Home
AFL Club
Carlton
Revisited apost from last August today and found it

showed up a lot of "experts" with very strong opinions.

thylacine60 is the only poster not to embarass

himself when giving his views on who should be

delisted and who should be kept on.:thumbsu:

Here is a list of players that other posters wanted

delisted or traded.

Gone

Kouta
Lappin
Teague
Whitnall

McLaren
Raso
Flint
Young [rookie]

TRADED

Kennedy [How can we get him back cheap.]

Going

Saddington

The Rest

Bannister
Bentick
Betts
Fevola
Hartlett
Houlihan
Jacobs
Russell
Wiggins

Does anyone else want to change their opinion?

 
you have far too much spare time my friend. its a good find... but seriously. people DO change their minds you know?
 
Tim H said:
Revisited apost from last August today and found it

showed up a lot of "experts" with very strong opinions.

thylacine60 is the only poster not to embarass

himself when giving his views on who should be

delisted and who should be kept on.:thumbsu:

Here is a list of players that other posters wanted

delisted or traded.

Gone

Kouta
Lappin
Teague
Whitnall

McLaren
Raso
Flint
Young [rookie]

TRADED

Kennedy [How can we get him back cheap.]

Going

Saddington

The Rest

Bannister
Bentick
Betts
Fevola
Hartlett
Houlihan
Jacobs
Russell
Wiggins

Does anyone else want to change their opinion?
Click to expand...


So Tim, you've been trawling the boards from a year ago and, as a newbie, have decided to coagulate the combined opinions of hundreds of posters into a universal condemnation (and a piss in the pocket for Thy)?

Way to win friends and influence people! :rolleyes:
 
Blue Dawn said:
So Tim, you've been trawling the boards from a year ago and, as a newbie, have decided to coagulate the combined opinions of hundreds of posters into a universal condemnation (and a piss in the pocket for Thy)?

Way to win friends and influence people! :rolleyes:
Click to expand...
try two years
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Is this an alias of your Thylacine...
 
I don't get it. Some of it happened. :confused:

It just depends how many players the club wanted to take in the draft and whether a trade would offer more than the retention of 'said' player.

It proves nothing; again I add...:confused:
 
Blue Dawn said:
So Tim, you've been trawling the boards from a year ago and, as a newbie, have decided to coagulate the combined opinions of hundreds of posters into a universal condemnation (and a piss in the pocket for Thy)?

Way to win friends and influence people! :rolleyes:
Click to expand...

That was MY post from last August. Don't know why I am listed as a newbie as Iv'e been a member and poster for 2 years now.

No idea whom thy is actually just did not realise BF is for abuse only please accept my apology.:):confused::rolleyes::eek:

Oh dear is that too many smilies again?:o

Would actually like to hear if posters have had opinions changed by

1. performance of listed players.

2. increasingly good track record of CFC selectors.

3. correct dosage or perhaps a new Doctor.

Any sarcasim is in the eye of the beholder.:rolleyes:
 
Tim H said:
That was MY post from last August. Don't know why I am listed as a newbie as Iv'e been a member and poster for 2 years now.

No idea whom thy is actually just did not realise BF is for abuse only please accept my apology.:):confused::rolleyes::eek:

Oh dear is that too many smilies again?:o

Would actually like to hear if posters have had opinions changed by

1. performance of listed players.

2. increasingly good track record of CFC selectors.

3. correct dosage or perhaps a new Doctor.

Any sarcasim is in the eye of the beholder.:rolleyes:
Click to expand...


Well Tim, if your intentions were pure my friend, may i suggest that you refrain from suggesting that the "so called 'experts' on this board managed to embarrass themselves" and look at a more constructive approach to discussing the issue. ;)
 
Hmm, you put up a list of players that apparently everybody but Thylacine wanted gone, posted no link and then want people to revisit an opinion from some time ago to correct it.

I'm not sure that I posted the list you have above but if you care to post the link, I would be happy to appraise my part in the thread.

You can't lump questionable calls from many posters into one and then hold everybody accountable for it. Let's get specific here.
 
Tim H said:
Gone

Kouta
Lappin
Teague
Whitnall

McLaren
Raso
Flint
Young [rookie]

TRADED

Kennedy [How can we get him back cheap.]

Going

Saddington

The Rest

Bannister
Bentick
Betts
Fevola
Hartlett
Houlihan
Jacobs
Russell
Wiggins

Does anyone else want to change their opinion?
Click to expand...

Why don't you post the thread, or bump it up?
All bar Betts, Fev Houlihan and Bentick are still in the air really......Banno might have saved himself.

But Fev had currency and could have been traded in the right cirumstnaces, Betts, well I don't know why anyone would want to get rid of him, Bentick has improved, but with Judd and Hadley arriving, and Stevens back from injury, fair enough he is on the fringes.......

The question is, why do you have a problem with people's opinions?

Do you love Thy?
Are you Thy using another username to get some self lovin?

Bump the thread and deal with the stupid comments.:thumbsu:
 
Exactly, it's people's opinions. I didn't do that list last year as I joined this site very late last year. I've done 2 lists of who will go at the end of this year and probably changed my mind, and quite frankly I can't be ****ed bumping the threads again listing who I think won't be at the club next year.
Well done to thylacine though, even though I couldn't really care less.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

HBF said:
I'm feeling very uneasy about the praise heaped on Thylacine on these boards lately. Very uneasy indeed. ;)
Click to expand...

Couldn't agree more HBF.

It mean it's one thing when it's warranted, but THIS?!?! :p:D
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

1340614.jpg


:cool:
 
Tim H said:
Revisited apost from last August today and found it

showed up a lot of "experts" with very strong opinions.

thylacine60 is the only poster not to embarass

himself when giving his views on who should be

delisted and who should be kept on.:thumbsu:
Click to expand...

I've found your shown up 'expert':

Tim H said:
Koutoufides R
Lappin R
Teague R
McLaren Delist
Bentick Delist
Jacobs Delist?
Raso Delist?
Saddington Delist?
Hartlett Trade?
Houlihan Trade?
Russell ?????
Wiggins ?????

Any thoughts?
Click to expand...

The retirees were no brainers so let's leave them aside.

Of your 5 de-listees, only 2 were actually delisted.

Of your 4 suggested trades, none were traded.

Tim H said:
Does anyone else want to change their opinion?
Click to expand...

Great suggestion! :rolleyes:
 
prettyboy65 said:
carefull
he will have you killed for suggesting that
Click to expand...
Well there was the war between him and AWG from a couple of years ago and last year. Unfortunately I wasn't a member of this site at the time, but I've heard about it, and from what it seems, after more casualties than the 2 World Wars combined, AWG defeated him.
I'd love to have a read of them, I'm a bit bored at the moment.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom