Remove this Banner Ad

Tippett's Gone - READ RULES BEFORE POSTING

  • Thread starter Thread starter doodle48
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

Which AFC deserter were/are you most salty towards?

  • Total voters
    33
  • Poll closed .

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Firstly let me qualify what I'm about to say.. I like the swans, my favourite AFL team besides the crows, the bloods hype doesnt phase me or anything like that, I like the way their players go about it.

Get on Sydney for bottom 4 next year.

Serious.

With the combination of old players, some of which need PCL, ACL, hamstring transplants and wont be back for half a season and now possibly (its not over til the fat lady sings on this one) with the divisory element that is Tippett amongst the ranks, can see bad things happening for them.

I make big calls......but I'll back myself in..........I do well with them........
 
jackster83 said:
Spare a thought for the Sydney players in all this.

They bust their asses all year, win a flag and then find out that the club is going to bring someone else in on greater money than them and possibly at the expense of one or more of them.

They must also be feeling like they are grossly underpaid if the club has that much money left in the cap.
Click to expand...

I agree. This could have much adverse affect on Sydney that crazy Voss had on Brisbane when he tried to trade Bradshaw.
 
jackster83 said:
Spare a thought for the Sydney players in all this.

They bust their asses all year, win a flag and then find out that the club is going to bring someone else in on greater money than them and possibly at the expense of one or more of them.

They must also be feeling like they are grossly underpaid if the club has that much money left in the cap.
Click to expand...

Got it in one. My 74 year old mother worked this out some hours ago - and shes rarely wrong!!!

You know I think there is a high possibility of this deal falling over/never happening. I'm sure sydney want to trade fairly - thats their way and track record - its simply breaking up their premiership group to get the deal done is too high a price to pay for the precious princess. And I wouldn't blame them one iota. In fact the more I think about it, the more I wonder why on earth they would risk such a successful formula and culture? Hmn... is there another play going on here??? Dunno. But somethings really fishy here...
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Schulzycrow said:
He doesn't care as long as Kurt and him with his % get the best deal possible. From some of the stuff quoting what he has said a tool of the century contender. The gagging sound is him shoving his foot further down his throat.
Click to expand...
Not sure it's a foot......
 
Skirt has already destabilized two clubs, more to follow stay tuned.

This time next week we could be on a 400page thread lol.

I would rather lose Skirt to GWS then to get unders from one of our contenders for the flag next year!
 
fairfooty said:
Got it in one. My 74 year old mother worked this out some hours ago - and shes rarely wrong!!!

You know I think there is a high possibility of this deal falling over/never happening. I'm sure sydney want to trade fairly - thats their way and track record - its simply breaking up their premiership group to get the deal done is too high a price to pay for the precious princess. And I wouldn't blame them one iota. In fact the more I think about it, the more I wonder why on earth they would risk such a successful formula and culture? Hmn... is there another play going on here??? Dunno. But somethings really fishy here...
Click to expand...

I'm not sure this is right either. Not every player that won a premiership is a premiership player (if that makes sense - think Shane Ellen). Just because they played and won the flag, does not automatically make them superstars. So there is definitely room to move. We also have to assume that they have the room in their salary cap given they've made this offer. With Kennedy and pyke yet to re-sign, perhaps they've taken that into account? I can't see them trading Kennedy (who just won their b&f), certainly not back to hawthorn where he was given away in the first place.
 
jenny61_99 said:
Yes I know that, but that's not what blucher is now saying.
Click to expand...

But he can make any statement he likes, and he will to put any pressure on Adelaide he can to get what he's client wants. I can bet you that Tippett doesn't want to go into the PSD.
Maybe that is why Tippet put the "Was born in Sydney and has lots of family there" ?
 
jenny61_99 said:
I'm not sure this is right either. Not every player that won a premiership is a premiership player (if that makes sense - think Shane Ellen). Just because they played and won the flag, does not automatically make them superstars. So there is definitely room to move. We also have to assume that they have the room in their salary cap given they've made this offer. With Kennedy and pyke yet to re-sign, perhaps they've taken that into account? I can't see them trading Kennedy (who just won their b&f), certainly not back to hawthorn where he was given away in the first place.
Click to expand...
Unless he has already told them he wants to move back to Melbourne? Purely speculation
 
Vader said:
If he goes into the PSD then GC will grab him - which is probably still his 2nd preference anyway. The likes of Freo & Carlton are completely irrelevant at this stage, unless you're talking about 3-way trade options.
Click to expand...
At this stage ....but if a deal can't be done with Sydney, forget GC there's still GWS, Carlton, Melbourne & Freo

What everyone forgets is the $1M pricetag over 4 years ........if GC could afford, don't you think they would have upped their offer .....wrong to assume all of a sudden they can match the deal in PSD
 

Remove this Banner Ad

AusTerran said:
But he can make any statement he likes, and he will to put any pressure on Adelaide he can to get what he's client wants. I can bet you that Tippett doesn't want to go into the PSD.
Maybe that is why Tippet put the "Was born in Sydney and has lots of family there" ?
Click to expand...

I know, you have to laugh at the stupidity of that. Even drew Morphett on abc radio today almost choked with laughter when he read that belcher had said that. And added, yes, if the cheque book is big enough!
 
Wayne's-World said:
At this stage ....but if a deal can't be done with Sydney, forget GC there's still GWS, Carlton, Melbourne & Freo

What everyone forgets is the $1M pricetag over 4 years ........if GC could afford, don't you think they would have upped their offer .....wrong to assume all of a sudden they can match the deal in PSD
Click to expand...

Did GC finish above Carlton Melbourne and freo? o_O
 
Carmo said:
Firstly let me qualify what I'm about to say.. I like the swans, my favourite AFL team besides the crows, the bloods hype doesnt phase me or anything like that, I like the way their players go about it.

Get on Sydney for bottom 4 next year.

Serious.

With the combination of old players, some of which need PCL, ACL, hamstring transplants and wont be back for half a season and now possibly (its not over til the fat lady sings on this one) with the divisory element that is Tippett amongst the ranks, can see bad things happening for them.

I make big calls......but I'll back myself in..........I do well with them........
Click to expand...

Transplants?:confused:

Only one player on our list requires end of season surgery and that's Tommy Walsh.
 
Vader said:
This actually looks like a fair trade for all 3 clubs. The only real catch would be convincing Roughead that he wants to move to Adelaide.
Click to expand...
Doubt Roughead would be ameniable to that .......but he is a country lad and would depend on the contract Adelaide put to him .....increase his current contract an as we know $$$$talks
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

jenny61_99 said:
Did GC finish above Carlton Melbourne and freo? o_O
Click to expand...
No but wrong to assume GC can match contract .....Port are next , Melb, Carlton & Freo

Would suggest Carlton & Freo who both put in Cloke offers have the salary cap room .......not sure GC does or more importantly wants to given their need to satisfy their wealth of talent on the list
 
Wayne's-World said:
What everyone forgets is the $1M pricetag over 4 years ........if GC could afford, don't you think they would have upped their offer .....wrong to assume all of a sudden they can match the deal in PSD
Click to expand...

They might have just wanted to not overpay him given they have heaps of kids coming out of contract soon. Though if they didn't have to trade for him, it might change their mind.
 
Tippett nominates Swans

Kurt Tippett has this morning advised the Adelaide Football Club that he wishes to be traded to the Sydney Swans.

Tippett has accepted a conditional four-year contract with the Swans, which is subject to Sydney being able to satisfy Adelaide's trade demands for the key foward.

Adelaide list manager David Noble said the Crows would now focus on securing the best-possible outcome for the Club in the trade period, which starts on Monday and runs through until October 26.

"Now that we know Kurt's preferred club we can start considering the trade options available to us and start formal negotiations when the trade period opens on Monday," he said.

Tippett said his decision to join Sydney was based on football and lifestyle.

"It would have been easy to accept a generous five-year offer to stay in Adelaide, or something similar from the Gold Coast or Brisbane," Tippett said in a statement.

"But this was a combined football/lifestyle decision and the balance between the two. I was born in Sydney, I have a lot of friends and family there, and this offers me a chance to play football in a lifestyle which I really enjoy.

“I want to thank the Adelaide Football Club for the opportunity and support they’ve given me over the past six years. It is an outstanding Club and I’ve really enjoyed playing there. I wish Brenton Sanderson and the Club all the best for the future."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

1970crow
    • Like
    • Haha
Have West Coast gone past us?
2 3
Replies
59
Views
1K
Mr_Moogle
Mr_Moogle
baldandbroke
    • Like
    • 100%
    • Haha
  • Poll Poll
Opinion Non-Crows AFL 14: Brad Scott gone
221 222 223 224 225
Replies
6K
Views
122K
Pea Nut
Pea Nut
Milo Cyrus
Opinion Fix the Rules and get rid of the whistle!
Replies
16
Views
342
Brasher
Brasher

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom