Opinion Top 50 2012

[robertg22]

From Syd v Coll:
10 - Kennedy
9 - McVeigh, O'Keefe
8 - Goodes, Hannebery, Richards
7 - A. Johnson, H. Shaw, Smith, Jetta, Pendlebury, O'Brien

I would have thought Pendlebury was better than a 7, would have almost rated him a 9

 

[Dandy_GO]

Scott Thompson fumbled a bit, and was dead on his feet by the end of the match, but he was the only thing keeping us in the game in the third. He's a machine. Deserves an 8.
Danger was outstanding in the last, but his first half was very quiet. Drop him down to an 8.
I think Rioli and Tippett probably deserve 9s.
Jacobs has looked very tired these last few weeks. I don't think he deserves a 7. Was good, but not close to his best.

 

[Guardian Hawk]

Breust was the other Hawthorn player deserving of votes - definately our best in the first half.

From Adelaide, I thought Sloane was instrumental and cut us up with his run.

 

[eaglespremiers]

I would have thought Pendlebury was better than a 7, would have almost rated him a 9

What are other people's thoughts?
Pendlebury a 7, 8 or 9?

 

[eaglespremiers]

So revised:

From Haw v Adel:
9 - Sewell, Tippett, Rioli
8 - Walker, Dangerfield, Mitchell, Thompson
7 - Breust, Sloane, Franklin, Proplyzia

How does this look?

 

[eaglespremiers]

From the Grand Final
10. Sewell
9. Hannebery, O'Keefe
8. Pyke, Hale, LRT, McVeigh, Malceski
7. Jetta, Goodes, Johnson, Bolton

 

[The Swert]

From the Grand Final
10. Sewell
9.Hannebery, O'Keefe
8. Pike, Hale, LRT, McVeigh, Malceski
7. Jetta, Goodes, Johnson, Bolton

Franklin played well. 24 disposals, 8 marks, 6 tackles, 3 goals, 132 DT points.

I can't believe people saying he choked.

 

[hawkman]

From the Grand Final
10. Sewell
9. Hannebery, O'Keefe
8. Pyke, Hale, LRT, McVeigh, Malceski
7. Jetta, Goodes, Johnson, Bolton

Not many Hawthorn players in there to say it was only a 10 point game. Although, thinking about it, hard to find a good player for us. Would give Franklin a 7 or 8. Did have 24 disposals along with 3.4. Maybe Burgoyne as well

Agree with Sewell being best on ground

 

[eaglespremiers]

Franklin played well. 24 disposals, 8 marks, 6 tackles, 3 goals, 132 DT points.

I can't believe people saying he choked.

Am undecided on Franklin.
Happy to give him a 7 is that is the general concensus.

 

[Dwight Schrute]

Am undecided on Franklin.
Happy to give him a 7 is that is the general concensus.

I'd give him a 9 to be honest. 24 possessions for a kpf is great and on top of that he got 3 goals.

 

[eaglespremiers]

Hi guys,

Over the next couple of weeks going to do a run down of my top 50 player-by-player.
Without further ado here is no. 50:

 

[eaglespremiers]

 

[eaglespremiers]

 

[eaglespremiers]

 

[AG]

Yeah, Franklin was awesome. Only that miss before HT was the real brain fart moment. The rest of his misses were close or on the run from memory.

Would have given him a vote in the NS.

3. Hannebery
2. McVeigh
1. Franklin

Sewell and ROK round out a clear top 5 imo.

That's what I had at the game. Franklin was a Hawthorn win and another goal away from the NS imo.

 

[pacman]

From the Grand Final
10. Sewell
9. Hannebery, O'Keefe
8. Pyke, Hale, LRT, McVeigh, Malceski
7. Jetta, Goodes, Johnson, Bolton

Haha you're obviously high on some real good gear.
Surprised Mumford isn't on that list.
Everyone in the 7 & 8 other than McVeigh better than Franklin. please.
Bring AG back.

 

[pacman]

Yeah, Franklin was awesome. Only that miss before HT was the real brain fart moment. The rest of his misses were close or on the run from memory.

Would have given him a vote in the NS.

3. Hannebery
2. McVeigh
1. Franklin

Sewell and ROK round out a clear top 5 imo.

That's what I had at the game. Franklin was a Hawthorn win and another goal away from the NS imo.

Right on time.

 

[eaglespremiers]

 

[eaglespremiers]

Haha you're obviously high on some real good gear.
Surprised Mumford isn't on that list.
Everyone in the 7 & 8 other than McVeigh better than Franklin. please.
Bring AG back.

My lists are never exclusive and I'm happy to place Franklin at an 8.

 

[eaglespremiers]

 

[eaglespremiers]

 

[AG]

Good work this year eaglespremiers. Great read and it takes a fair bit of time doing this every week.

 

[TiggerMan22]

Good list so far

 

[MR]

eaglespremiers

Hey, I was just wondering if this was going to be completed. It was a great list and was eagerly awaiting your final results.

 

[eaglespremiers]

eaglespremiers

Hey, I was just wondering if this was going to be completed. It was a great list and was eagerly awaiting your final results.

It will be done.
Just moving at the moment + working 6 days a week.
But I will finish it.