Trade Idea

[PP34]

Do we have to give away Murphy or Gibbs for someone like Pav because lets face it we ain't gonna win a flag with our forward line at the moment or should we invest in a key posi player in the draft and hope he might learn to mark and kick goals?

 

[Lukesta63]

Do we have to give away Murphy or Gibbs for someone like Pav because lets face it we ain't gonna win a flag with our forward line at the moment or should we invest in a key posi player in the draft and hope he might learn to mark and kick goals?

Mate I'm as pissed off as anyone ,but you're being ridiculous!

 

[BowerTower]

Pavlich is too old. Murphy is untouchable. I'd trade Gibbs though for a good forward.

 

[Big Red is back]

Do we have to give away Murphy or Gibbs for someone like Pav because lets face it we ain't gonna win a flag with our forward line at the moment or should we invest in a key posi player in the draft and hope he might learn to mark and kick goals?

Mate we need more quality mids not less.

 

[PP34]

Mate we need more quality mids not less.

Yes I know but you can have all the midfielders you like but you need someone who can take a mark surely in this draft they should use a few picks on key position players.

 

[Mentallo]

Giggs signed a new deal just recently thus is untradeable unless he agrees to a trade, i believe Murp signed a new contract extension as well this year that puts him in the same catagory.

 

[Big Red is back]

Yes I know but you can have all the midfielders you like but you need someone who can take a mark surely in this draft they should use a few picks on key position players.

God knows what we will do, our trading is typically not to flash

 

[PP34]

How bout Carrazzo not for Pavlich obviously

 

[Big Red is back]

Travis Cloke goes ok and has put of discussions to year end

 

[The Big Sticks]

We don't need a forward who can't kick

 

[PP34]

We don't need a forward who can't kick

Very true we have enough of them

 

[setantypants]

After long and arduous thought, I have decided I would be happy to trade Carrazzo for Nick Riewoldt. Fair trade?

No way we should trade Gibblet or Murph.

 

[PP34]

Haha yeah Carrazzo and a pick for Kennedy?

 

[Thommo 42]

We'll give you John Anthony for your first round pick.

Although Ratts would probably play him in defence

 

[The Grover]

Jacobs - Port Adelaide

Walker & Carrazzo - Gold Coast

 

[Sir CJ]

Travis Cloke goes ok and has put of discussions to year end

I popped this question in another thread and I honestly reckon Cloke would be a handy player at our club, even though I can't see him leaving he has a big body and can actually take a contested mark and would help fast track henderson's development, he's kicking is not great but he's a target, there's not many other big forwards out there who will be coming out of contract

 

[Tanks_Alot]

If we're gonna trade anyone and get something decent out of it, then it would probably have to be Carrazzo and/or Walker. Maybe to the GC for some decent picks, Pav is too old and there's no way we're getting any of the Riewoldts, Franklin, Brown etc. Not for Walker and Carrazzo anyway.

 

[The Grover]

I got an idea maybe we should recruit Staker & Schulz, oh shit might be a year late.

 

[deptholigest]

how about gibbs to adelaide for a tayler walker or kurt tippet?

 

[Bic]

Such dramatic overreactions

Wait until Murphy and Gibbs hit 24/25 years of age, that is when the next level is reached.

 

[AFC979810]

I don't think we would get rid of Walker or Tippet (nor do they want to go to Melbourne as Walker is from NSW / Tippet QLD)...

Nor do I think that Gibbs wants to come home...

 

[Azzurri Blues]

Hammer and Walker to GC for pick 5 and 36

Pick 5 + 22 + 36 to Freo for Pavlich and pick 28

----------

We may go for t. cloke as i understand he wants to win a premiership during his career.

 

[Cazbah]

Such dramatic overreactions

Wait until Murphy and Gibbs hit 24/25 years of age, that is when the next level is reached.

Exactly my thoughts, they will be A-Graders. Give them a bit more time!

Sick of people being so dramatic after a bad loss.

 

[DVD Player]

I can see Gibbs and Murphy being top 5 players in the comp and part of a premiership team. The Gazz and Bartel or Hodge and Mitchell of Carlton if you like. You would only trade them for someone like Franklin, not Cloke...

 

[goreds]

Hammer and Walker to GC for pick 5 and 36

Pick 5 + 22 + 36 to Freo for Pavlich and pick 28

----------

We may go for t. cloke as i understand he wants to win a premiership during his career.

I think for us to be part of any trade at the end of the season one of our rucks has to be put up for trade...

GC, the crows and Port could do with a ruckman...