Trade

[WestCat]

Pick 15
Pick 31
Charlie Gardiner

for

Pick 18
Andrew MacDougall

Why is McDougall worth more than Charlie?

I must be one of the shrinking group who still thinks that Charlie's going to become a proper footballer one day and don't want to see him traded. I'd like to see him tried in a few other positions in the VFL if he struggles to make the firsts, I just think he has the right assets to make it.

I think the Eagles will persist with Doogs for another year anyway, he's got another year left on his contract and was hampered by injury this year.

 

[scottydeewah]

I am surprised Jack-Pack doesnt want to play Charlie at CHF, he tore it up there last year against the doggies.

Get rid of Chambers and our first rounder for Spida, man it would be awesome to have him at Geelong, King and Spida in a ruck tandom, Ottens forward, King floating back, Mooney the tall utility.

I wouldnt mind us having a go at Lappin. Three year contract last made up of match payments only.