Remove this Banner Ad

Tribunal Trouble

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Juddtastic

Juddtastic

Team Captain
Jul 6, 2007
416
2
Adelaide
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
Devin Harris, Scull Murphy
Waters and Burton offered two weeks a piece

Rob Murphy offered a week(with an early plea)
 
if bloody waters did something to earn his spot it would make this so much easier to take, wish i had trades to burn he would be outa my side so wuick it would make his head spin
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

So there is a chance of Murphy playing this week if he challenges right?

My trades this week were:

Wonnaman to Armfield
Rioli to Murph.

I guees depends on neagle playing now
 
____ing Waters! Can't afford to use a trade on him and was already going to draft in Wilkes to have a playing backline emergency, will probably score more than Waters anyway.
 
Big Question - Will Waters come good in the 2nd half of the season?

I have Kennelly and Waters in my backline, one will be my 7th back. Which one should I keep?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Beau_Waters for PM said:
As much as I love Waters, I think he'll get the boot this week.
Been rubbish since I picked him in Round 3.
Click to expand...

I'm thinking heavily of trading him out as well, though at his best he is a keeper...How many trades have you got left BW4PM..? I'm just wondering the amount you've got left because I've got 8 trades left, two possibly three upgrades to go and have got $200,000 in the bank atm...I don't think I can afford to trade him out unfortunately, though I'd love to no doubt...
 
GreaT SourcE said:
I'm thinking heavily of trading him out as well, though at his best he is a keeper...How many trades have you got left BW4PM..? I'm just wondering the amount you've got left because I've got 8 trades left, two possibly three upgrades to go and have got $200,000 in the bank atm...I don't think I can afford to trade him out unfortunately, though I'd love to no doubt...
Click to expand...
Well, I've got 8 left and ~$90k cash in bank. Was planning to upgrade Mundy this week because he and Waters have been frustrating me to no end this season!

With any potential keeper, I'm normally reluctant to trade them out because the chances are that they will eventually find some form and hit back. And by trading them now you've got dead money (i.e. the amount that they decreased). But at some point you have to cut your losses.

I'm looking at Birchall, Bowden and Milburn. Birchall has a good run home, and Bowden and Milburn look to have regained their form and are on the up.

Will definitely upgrade either Mundy or Waters though. If I only had Waters then I would be less inclined to upgrade, but still might have ended up doing it anyway, assuming I could grab a player who will average, say, 88+ for the rest of the season at a cost not too great.
 
Beau_Waters for PM said:
Well, I've got 8 left and ~$90k cash in bank. Was planning to upgrade Mundy this week because he and Waters have been frustrating me to no end this season!

With any potential keeper, I'm normally reluctant to trade them out because the chances are that they will eventually find some form and hit back. And by trading them now you've got dead money (i.e. the amount that they decreased). But at some point you have to cut your losses.

I'm looking at Birchall, Bowden and Milburn. Birchall has a good run home, and Bowden and Milburn look to have regained their form and are on the up.

Will definitely upgrade either Mundy or Waters though. If I only had Waters then I would be less inclined to upgrade, but still might have ended up doing it anyway, assuming I could grab a player who will average, say, 88+ for the rest of the season at a cost not too great.
Click to expand...

Hmm, yeah, pretty tough decision...I really want to trade him out but I'm worried about having 0 trades left with a fair few rounds remaining in the season...I'll keep him for the time being, but if I hear of some niggling injuries still bothering him, he will most probably get the almighty chop..!
 
GreaT SourcE said:
Hmm, yeah, pretty tough decision...I really want to trade him out but I'm worried about having 0 trades left with a fair few rounds remaining in the season...I'll keep him for the time being, but if I hear of some niggling injuries still bothering him, he will most probably get the almighty chop..!
Click to expand...
Yeah. Don't want to scare you (or anyone else), but there have been (unsubstantiated) rumours that Waters may have OP. Not sure whether to buy that or not, but you can't deny that since Rd3 he has been out of form and struggling through at least one injury of some kind. Not a good sign for a DT coach.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Beau_Waters for PM said:
Yeah. Don't want to scare you (or anyone else), but there have been (unsubstantiated) rumours that Waters may have OP. Not sure whether to buy that or not, but you can't deny that since Rd3 he has been out of form and struggling through at least one injury of some kind. Not a good sign for a DT coach.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I've heard that as well, but will only be trading him out if anything sort of official comes out 'cause who really knows what's going on behind the scenes besides the club's themselves...
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Tribunal Trouble

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top