Trimming the List

[Tyger]

Four years into the five year plan and we are showing just glimpses of improvement. Time to be tough. Who stays who goes.

Trade:

Hyde, Jackson, Johnson, Tambling, Pettifer, Polo

Delist:

Tivendale, Meyer, JON

Need

Mongel Midfielder
Running Half Back

 

[T4P]

Four years into the five year plan and we are showing just glimpses of improvement. Time to be tough. Who stays who goes.

Trade:

Hyde, Jackson, Johnson, Tambling, Pettifer, Polo

Delist:

Tivendale, Meyer, JON

Need

Mongel Midfielder
Running Half Back

mongrel midfielder is in jackson - keep him as well as tambling, polo and j.o.n
delist pettifer, hyde and tivendale nobody wants them
we need a few talls

 

[beaver fever]

Delist: Pettifer, Bowden, Jackson, Hyde, Tivendale, Johnson, Howat, Silvestor, Cartledge.

Trade: Anyone except Deledio, Foley, Cotchin, Rance, Riewoldt, Richardson, Thursfield.

Need: 200+cm ruckman, inside midfielders, tall forwards and defenders, tough small defenders, defensive forwards.

 

[Richo Rules]

Delist - Hyde - Tivendale

Trade - Jackson - Pettifer - Polo - Schulz - Tuck

not saying those guys should be gone from the club just we should chuck their names around to see what we could get in return

Ben Cousins is one guy we need to teach our kids to do gut busting runs instead of going through the motions

Warnock is another we need to target as our ruck stocks are not that strong

A CHF is another spot we need

A good midsized backman

and a wingman

 

[getthefooty]

Trade: Shultz, Bowden, Pettifer

Delist: Tivers, Hyde, Howat, Silvester

Need: Midfielders, Midfielders.
Maybe Warnock.
Unsure about a KP forward - I would like to take the best player available with our first pick, that could mean a KP forward, however I wouldn't mind if we left this for another year and see how Hughes, Riewoldt, Gourdis, Putt, Morton etc develop

 

[Mario Speedwagon]

Delist - Hyde - Tivendale

Trade - Jackson - Pettifer - Polo - Schulz - Tuck

not saying those guys should be gone from the club just we should chuck their names around to see what we could get in return

Ben Cousins is one guy we need to teach our kids to do gut busting runs instead of going through the motions

Warnock is another we need to target as our ruck stocks are not that strong

A CHF is another spot we need

A good midsized backman

and a wingman

Whilst we are lacking a specialist wingman...I think we have a surplus of utility players who can potentially fill that role quite well....just need some competent coaching....maybe we lack a larger player to put out there (I'm not counting Richo as a long term solution)..still, I don't regard it as high a priority as other positions we need...

 

[Peter SasseGum]

I'm pretty happy with the way the list is now taking shape.

It's got a great blend of youth, rapidly developing players approaching their prime years, and some teriffic senior leaders.

Well done to TW and the coaching staff for developing, nuturing and delivering a group of players that will make Richmond an AFL powerhouse for the next decade

 

[True Thylacine]

Delist - Hyde - Tivendale

Trade - Jackson - Pettifer - Polo - Schulz - Tuck

not saying those guys should be gone from the club just we should chuck their names around to see what we could get in return

Ben Cousins is one guy we need to teach our kids to do gut busting runs instead of going through the motions
Warnock is another we need to target as our ruck stocks are not that strong

A CHF is another spot we need

A good midsized backman

and a wingman

You actually think his ability to run that hard has some credibility? Got to be joking. Let's see how hard he runs when he is clean.

 

[ize_]

Four years into the five year plan and we are showing just glimpses of improvement. Time to be tough. Who stays who goes.

Trade:

Hyde, Jackson, Johnson, Tambling, Pettifer, Polo

Delist:

Tivendale, Meyer, JON

Need

Mongel Midfielder
Running Half Back

Need a running half back? Are McMahon, White, Newman, Howat and Raines invisible?

 

[Tivers]

Delist: Pettifer, Bowden, Jackson, Hyde, Tivendale, Johnson, Howat, Silvestor, Cartledge.

If the Captain of our footy club is really worth no more than delisting.........we're all wasting our time and we may as well just close the doors now and give it away !!!
(And Bowden........BOG two starts ago).

 

[Supertiger]

Trade

Chris Newman is of interest to Carlton & Essendon
Adam Pattison is of interest to Hawthorn
Jarrad Oakley Nicholls and Casserley should be offered to Freo for Warnock.

Others to be delisted if no offers come

Tivendale
Pettifer
Howat
Hyde
Silvestor

 

[footyfan_25]

I think Pettifer will be retained.

If anything offered for Trade, but wll not be de-listed

 

[footyfan_25]

Trade

Chris Newman is of interest to Carlton & Essendon
Adam Pattison is of interest to Hawthorn

Newman - Won't even be mentioned in a trade. Much required player.

Pattison - With Taylor, Campbell, Renouf and their other 2 young rucks ... why would they be interested in Patto

 

[matsta1975]

Delist: Terry " if i talk enough bullshit everyone will believe me" Wallace and Mr it is not my fault Miller and get in people that are realists and know how dire the job at hand is and are prepared to make the hard long term decisions.

I honestly think you have enough talent within your youth ranks but Wallace has to keep playing them regardless of the consequences to bring them on to a standard where they will compete week in week out

 

[RichosGuns]

Retire: Tivendale

Delist: Hyde, Silvestor (r), Howatt (r)

Elevate: Cartlege (unless we pick up Warnock or similar in which it would then be okay to delist him)

Retain on the rookie list: Collard

Trade bait: Pettifer, JON, Casserly, Schultz, Meyer, Jackson, Polo, TAMBLING, Pattison, King

Trade: Our 2nd pick (20-24) + Casserly/JON/Meyer + our 3rd round pick (36-40) to Fremantle for Robbie Warnock + their 3rd round pick (34-36) - Fair trade imo

Also try and trade player or combination of players from the trade bait list who may be able to secure us another top 35 or better pick. Ie Schultz and Meyer to Port Adelaide or Adelaide for their 2nd rounder.

Final delisment: Delist 2-4 of Jackson, Casserly, Meyer, Schultz, Pettifer, McGuane

1 year contracts: Bowden, Simmonds, Johnson

Veterans: Richo, Bowden

This will end up giving us probably 3 picks in the National draft (roughly 5, 35, 54), 1 in the PSD (5), 2 or 3 in the rookie draft (5, 21, 37) + Robert Warnock

What we should aim for:
ND
Pick 5 - Hurley, Watts or McKerna. In otherwords best available KPP.
Pick 35 - Best small/medium sized defender who can actually defend possible.
Pick 54- Undersized speculative inside midfielder. Someone like a Mitchell, Crawford, Rodan or Foley who may only be 174-178cm and may be thought as being to small to draft by recruiters but who dominates at Carnival and TAC level anyway.

PSD
Pick 5 - Mundy from fremantle. Unlikely to happen, but there's always one decent player who slips through. If not the best available youngster. Geartner is still likely to be around at this stage, so he could be the one

Rookie - We should look to rookie mids and small fowards. Hopefully we take on another Coburg player this year. Hopefully that man is Nick Carnell.

 

[Supertiger]

Newman - Won't even be mentioned in a trade. Much required player.

Pattison - With Taylor, Campbell, Renouf and their other 2 young rucks ... why would they be interested in Patto

Absolutely 100% stand by what I said before.

 

[mrs_richo]

Trade

Chris Newman is of interest to Carlton & Essendon
Adam Pattison is of interest to Hawthorn
Jarrad Oakley Nicholls and Casserley should be offered to Freo for Warnock.

Others to be delisted if no offers come

Tivendale
Pettifer
Howat
Hyde
Silvestor

Super, trading Chris Newman? what the f are u on son.

 

[Supertiger]

None of you are reading what I wrote, Im just telling you that Chris Newman is wanted by Carlton. Essendon also want Newman. Im also telling yas that Hawthorn have a huge interest in Pattison.

I dont know what RFCs admin is gonna do, Im just telling you all that these players are being chased.


The end.

 

[richcogs]

None of you are reading what I wrote, Im just telling you that Chris Newman is wanted by Carlton. Essendon also want Newman. Im also telling yas that Hawthorn have a huge interest in Pattison.

I dont know what RFCs admin is gonna do, Im just telling you all that these players are being chased.


The end.

Simply putting it, Chris Newmans name should not be mentioned in this thread.

 

[cormick]

Retire: Tivendale

Delist: Hyde, Silvestor (r), Howatt (r)

Elevate: Cartlege (unless we pick up Warnock or similar in which it would then be okay to delist him)

Retain on the rookie list: Collard

Trade bait: Pettifer, JON, Casserly, Schultz, Meyer, Jackson, Polo, TAMBLING, Pattison, King

Trade: Our 2nd pick (20-24) + Casserly/JON/Meyer + our 3rd round pick (36-40) to Fremantle for Robbie Warnock + their 3rd round pick (34-36) - Fair trade imo

Also try and trade player or combination of players from the trade bait list who may be able to secure us another top 35 or better pick. Ie Schultz and Meyer to Port Adelaide or Adelaide for their 2nd rounder.

Final delisment: Delist 2-4 of Jackson, Casserly, Meyer, Schultz, Pettifer, McGuane

1 year contracts: Bowden, Simmonds, Johnson

Veterans: Richo, Bowden

This will end up giving us probably 3 picks in the National draft (roughly 5, 35, 54), 1 in the PSD (5), 2 or 3 in the rookie draft (5, 21, 37) + Robert Warnock

What we should aim for:
ND
Pick 5 - Hurley, Watts or McKerna. In otherwords best available KPP.
Pick 35 - Best small/medium sized defender who can actually defend possible.
Pick 54- Undersized speculative inside midfielder. Someone like a Mitchell, Crawford, Rodan or Foley who may only be 174-178cm and may be thought as being to small to draft by recruiters but who dominates at Carnival and TAC level anyway.

PSD
Pick 5 - Mundy from fremantle. Unlikely to happen, but there's always one decent player who slips through. If not the best available youngster. Geartner is still likely to be around at this stage, so he could be the one

Rookie - We should look to rookie mids and small fowards. Hopefully we take on another Coburg player this year. Hopefully that man is Nick Carnell.

I like this, except I'd be tempted to keep Silvestor just as an absolute back up in case we get dire KP injuries. I know Gourdis and Putt will be ahead in the pecking order next year, but it'd still be handy to have another 23ish yo KPD whos got good size about him

 

[sante]

Four years into the five year plan and we are showing just glimpses of improvement. Time to be tough. Who stays who goes.

Trade:

Hyde, Jackson, Johnson, Tambling, Pettifer, Polo

Delist:

Tivendale, Meyer, JON

Need

Mongel Midfielder
Running Half Back

Running half back? LMAO, you got to be joking.

Your whole post has to be a joke. Tambling, Jackson and Polo are all ahead of Collins, Connors.

DELIST

Tivendale
Howat
2 of Jackson/Meyer/Casserley/Collins

TRADE

Pettifer
Hyde (Shop him around)

 

[sante]

None of you are reading what I wrote, Im just telling you that Chris Newman is wanted by Carlton. Essendon also want Newman. Im also telling yas that Hawthorn have a huge interest in Pattison.

I dont know what RFCs admin is gonna do, Im just telling you all that these players are being chased.


The end.

You do this every year and you're always wrong

 

[Madtiger2006]

Why would we trade Polo and Jackson? Both players who are/will be regulars soon. They are both required midfielders

 

[Tyger]

Running half back? LMAO, you got to be joking.

Your whole post has to be a joke. Tambling, Jackson and Polo are all ahead of Collins, Connors.

DELIST

Tivendale
Howat
2 of Jackson/Meyer/Casserley/Collins

TRADE

Pettifer
Hyde (Shop him around)

Tambling, Jackson and Polo have all been tried and are found to be very much wanting.

A running half back that can hit targets and break lines.

If it's a joke have a laugh and move on.

 

[mattdwyer]

Four years into the five year plan and we are showing just glimpses of improvement. Time to be tough. Who stays who goes.

Trade:

Hyde, Jackson, Johnson, Tambling, Pettifer, Polo

Delist:

Tivendale, Meyer, JON

Need

Mongel Midfielder
Running Half Back

wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong ...

none of those will happen champ ...