umpires

[Bird Man]

Umpires were filth tonight ... they gave Carlton the game.. in all seriousness Carlton got lucky

 

[Wallaby]

Not true.

 

[Gak Attack]

Umpires were filth tonight ... they gave Carlton the game.. in all seriousness Carlton got lucky

LOL that's just silly. Judd got his usual phantom frees and perhaps they got the better of more 50/50's but that's always the case when a lower team like us plays a finals contender. This game was decided because we were the far worse side in 3 of the 4 qtrs.

 

[Harvey Leadpipe]

Pipe down Birdy. Scoreboard flattered us.

 

[Roachy8]

Umpires were fine.

 

[aNImatedTiger]

The morton holding the ball in the last quater was a real game changer. I was disgusted with the channel 10 coverage and felt like throwing a brick through my TV. To say the umpires were a joke is an understatement.

 

[Bird Man]

LOL that's just silly. Judd got his usual phantom frees and perhaps they got the better of more 50/50's but that's always the case when a lower team like us plays a finals contender. This game was decided because we were the far worse side in 3 of the 4 qtrs.

what game were u watching mate? the amount of times jack got pushed in the back and the amount of times they held the ball was ridiculous

the tankers were favored in the last and you know it

 

[captain blood 17]

Umpires were only rewarding guys who got in front or in first for the pill. For 60% of the game we were second in every area. We lost it. Umpires actually put the whistle away for the last quarter.

 

[007Tigers]

The morton holding the ball in the last quater was a real game changer. I was disgusted with the channel 10 coverage and felt like throwing a brick through my TV. To say the umpires were a joke is an understatement.

totally agree that was a joke

 

[Lamp]

They just did not at all, what a bad thread.

 

[the ranger]

Overall the umpiring wasn't too bad. Favoured them slightly, I'd say but not enough to change the result by any means.

 

[Lance Uppercut]

From a neutral perspective, umps were fine. Consistent, no side favoured. No impact on the result whatsoever.

 

[Bird Man]

Overall the umpiring wasn't too bad. Favoured them slightly, I'd say but not enough to change the result by any means.

and that favoring in the end pushed them across the line

 

[Gak Attack]

what game were u watching mate? the amount of times jack got pushed in the back and the amount of times they held the ball was ridiculous

the tankers were favored in the last and you know it

Same as you and the same as everyone else who doesn't agree with you, sure they might of got a better run but it didn't decide the game like you claim. We were shit in the last and were lucky to be in it at half time and that was to do with playing poor more than it was to any umpiring.

 

[the ranger]

and that favoring in the end pushed them across the line

The Morton decision was really the only glaringly bad one and while it did come at a bad time, I don't think you could blame the loss on one play. They were better for most of the game and deserved the win (in the sense of what happened on the ground...Carlton don't actually deserve any wins ever because they are cheating, tanking scum).

 

[Fumbles]

From a neutral perspective, umps were fine. Consistent, no side favoured. No impact on the result whatsoever.

think they got a slight slight favour, but totally agree that it didn't impact on the result at all.

 

[RFC7]

I thought the ref's let a lot go, actually was a good performance compared to all the over-officiating they usually do.

 

[turtle27]

Silly thread. Umps were fine. Missed a couple that were there, and paid a couple that weren't. No favourtism either way.

 

[PHX]

Can discuss this here. http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=805797