Umpiring

[Achilles Heel]

Nothing has changed

 

[rosetech]

Honestly some of you idiots need to chillax and watch netflix, just because the umpiring differentials shift dramatically doesn't mean the umpires hate us. These results were 100% predictable & always will be when the rule committee changes the rules to deweaponize your gameplan.

Razor is that you?

 

[GhostofJimJess]

Razor is that you?

No. Razor likes Richmond more.

 

[Groupie_]

Angus Brayshaw's brother says AFL wants the Pies to win the flag. It's happening, it's real. We are not nuts. Everyone can now see it!!

if the ump didnt call that dodgey advantage bears wouldve won

I have never seen Richmond get umpired like colonwood were in 22/23

not even once !!

one of the biggest cheat asterisk flags of all time . stand rule and 4th umpire allows them to cheat for whoever they want to lift the cup

 

[Achilles Heel]

if the ump didnt call that dodgey advantage bears wouldve won

I have never seen Richmond get umpired like colonwood were in 22/23

not even once !!

one of the biggest cheat asterisk flags of all time . stand rule and 4th umpire allows them to cheat for whoever they want to lift the cup

Welcome back campaigner, did you have to sign a non disclosure for your ban?

 

[Al Heimer]

Question for anyone: does the AFL identify the umpire who has given the Brownlow votes for that game?
I have been looking at our game stats on afltables.com and they have who the pricks were but not in alphabetical order.
Could I assume the first named is the senior umpire and the blind biased prick who votes?
Would explain why when Curtis is first named we rarely get a 3 vote player even when we comfortably win [emoji848]

On SM-A426B using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Hank Heavenly]

Question for anyone: does the AFL identify the umpire who has given the Brownlow votes for that game?
I have been looking at our game stats on afltables.com and they have who the pricks were but not in alphabetical order.
Could I assume the first named is the senior umpire and the blind biased prick who votes?
Would explain why when Curtis is first named we rarely get a 3 vote player even when we comfortably win [emoji848]

On SM-A426B using BigFooty.com mobile app

all 3 decide votes together, not one individual umpire.

And perhaps they are listed in number order???

 

[4tune8]

Here's an interesting tidbit of information, shows the 50m penalties given away by each club and I'm gobsmacked to see us leading the pack by a considerable margin.

 

[SplintWhisky]

Here's an interesting tidbit of information, shows the 50m penalties given away by each club and I'm gobsmacked to see us leading the pack by a considerable margin.



View attachment 1877028

Pretty sure that a lot of those can be explained by the fact Josh Caddy played like 50 games with us and that we always seemed to get reamed in Round 1 vs Carlton with whatever bullshit they took a hard stance on over the summer.

 

[Groupie_]

Here's an interesting tidbit of information, shows the 50m penalties given away by each club and I'm gobsmacked to see us leading the pack by a considerable margin.



View attachment 1877028

42 last year when they guinea pigged us with the new dissent 50 rule lmao

totally no corruption

 

[4tune8]

Pretty sure that a lot of those can be explained by the fact Josh Caddy played like 50 games with us and that we always seemed to get reamed in Round 1 vs Carlton with whatever bullshit they took a hard stance on over the summer.

Bolton has the most from our lot with 14 over those 3 seasons, only Rankine with 16 and Kozi Pickett with 15 have more

 

[4tune8]

42 last year when they guinea pigged us with the new dissent 50 rule lmao

totally no corruption

Of course there's no corruption or bias.

16 teams have between 50 & 67 fifty metre penalties with an average of around 58

Next is an outlier with Norf on 77 which is 31% above the average.

Then there's us with a double outlier of 89 which is 53% above the league average.

 

[Meteoric Rise]

Here's an interesting tidbit of information, shows the 50m penalties given away by each club and I'm gobsmacked to see us leading the pack by a considerable margin.



View attachment 1877028

Lol, 3rd most penalised team has conceded 5% more 50m penalties than the 7th most penalised team, and 28% more than the 17th most penalised team.

Richmond has conceded 39% more than the 3rd most penalised team and a near unbelievable 100+% more than of the least penalised team.

The most conceded in a single season is Richmond with 42 in 2022 when we were looking a bit too threatening, obviously.

Most in a single season:

42 Richmond(2022) wtaf
28 Collingwood(2022) & North(2023)
27 Port(2023) Eagles(2023)
25 Richmond(2021) Lions(2022) North(2022) Essendon(2021)
24 Saints(2022) North(2021) Suns(2023) Crows(2022)
23 Bulldogs(2022) Swans(2022)
22 Richmond(2023) Hawks(2022 & 23)

So of 54 individual seasons teams played, Richmond's 3 seasons ranked 1st, 6th and 16th for the most penalised individual seasons.

In each of the 3 seasons Richmond ranked as most penalised:

2021 1st
2022 1st
2023 4th

heck off campaigners.

 

[4tune8]

Lol, 3rd most penalised team has conceded 5% more 50m penalties than the 7th most penalised team, and 28% more than the 17th most penalised team.

Richmond has conceded 39% more than the 3rd most penalised team and a near unbelievable 100+% more than of the least penalised team.

The most conceded in a single season is Richmond with 42 in 2022 when we were looking a bit too threatening, obviously.

Most in a single season:

42 Richmond(2022) wtaf
28 Collingwood(2022) & North(2023)
27 Port(2023) Eagles(2023)
25 Richmond(2021) Lions(2022) North(2022) Essendon(2021)
24 Saints(2022) North(2021) Suns(2023) Crows(2022)
23 Bulldogs(2022) Swans(2022)
22 Richmond(2023) Hawks(2022 & 23)

So of 54 individual seasons teams played, Richmond's 3 seasons ranked 1st, 6th and 16th for the most penalised individual seasons.

In each of the 3 seasons Richmond ranked as most penalised:

2021 1st
2022 1st
2023 4th

* off campaigners.

There's one thing that's certain.

It can't be put down to our style of play.

 

[Achilles Heel]

Here's an interesting tidbit of information, shows the 50m penalties given away by each club and I'm gobsmacked to see us leading the pack by a considerable margin.



View attachment 1877028

I’m shocked to be sitting here

 

[beema limapep]

Geelong pretty much bottom for 50m given away.

Nothing to see here.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Here's an interesting tidbit of information, shows the 50m penalties given away by each club and I'm gobsmacked to see us leading the pack by a considerable margin.



View attachment 1877028

tbh 2021, and 2023 don't look too bad. 2022 is the outlier, not sure what happened there.

 

[4tune8]

tbh 2021, and 2023 don't look too bad. 2022 is the outlier, not sure what happened there.

In 2021 we gave away (were penalized) the highest amount of 50m penalties in the comp, for comparison the Pies were penalized 11, 2023 saw us coming back to the pack when it was realized that we were no longer a threat.

 

[Lacustrus]

42 last year when they guinea pigged us with the new dissent 50 rule lmao

totally no corruption

It came in 2021

 

[Groupie_]

It came in 2021

wasnt that stand

 

[Lacustrus]

wasnt that stand

They were red hot on us first game back from 2020 gf where Jack Graham gave the ump a spray , so c was lol it whatever , they were setting an example.

In many ways , we were too stupid to learn quickly and desist imo

 

[Groupie_]

They were red hot on us first game back from 2020 gf where Jack Graham gave the ump a spray , so c was lol it whatever , they were setting an example.

In many ways , we were too stupid to learn quickly and desist imo

they did it in 2022 as well

blooze won cos of it

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Lol, 3rd most penalised team has conceded 5% more 50m penalties than the 7th most penalised team, and 28% more than the 17th most penalised team.

Richmond has conceded 39% more than the 3rd most penalised team and a near unbelievable 100+% more than of the least penalised team.

The most conceded in a single season is Richmond with 42 in 2022 when we were looking a bit too threatening, obviously.

Most in a single season:

42 Richmond(2022) wtaf
28 Collingwood(2022) & North(2023)
27 Port(2023) Eagles(2023)
25 Richmond(2021) Lions(2022) North(2022) Essendon(2021)
24 Saints(2022) North(2021) Suns(2023) Crows(2022)
23 Bulldogs(2022) Swans(2022)
22 Richmond(2023) Hawks(2022 & 23)

So of 54 individual seasons teams played, Richmond's 3 seasons ranked 1st, 6th and 16th for the most penalised individual seasons.

In each of the 3 seasons Richmond ranked as most penalised:

2021 1st
2022 1st
2023 4th

* off campaigners.

But...but...butt...butttt...we are a team renowned for playing close to the "edge" and over!

 

[Meteoric Rise]

But...but...butt...butttt...we are a team renowned for playing close to the "edge" and over!

Every team is and was trying to play close to the edge of what is acceptable Jak. Richmond were never unique in that regard.

The AFL are campaigners.

 

[Rocco sifreddi]

Can't wait to be last again in the free kick count
And the pies sucked off again