Van Berlo Leaving?

[Ferris_rules]

Will the Judd trade involve Judd to Carlton, Gibbs to Crows and Van Berlo and pick 3 to the Eagles?

 

[jackster83]

No!
Van Berlo > Gibbs

 

[Farmy]

No thanks

 

[bus24]

Nopidy Nope Nope.

 

[crow87]

It wont happen, but VB for Gibbs? In the blink of an eye.

 

[crowsarethebest]

NO. Delete Thread.

 

[21knights]

Will the Judd trade involve Judd to Carlton, Gibbs to Crows and Van Berlo and pick 3 to the Eagles?

You're on crack. Prepare to be struck down by the almighty.

 

[Ferris_rules]

I personally believe imo that there is a possibility that this deal may transpire.

It is a win-win for all clubs.

Especially as I can assume Van Berlo will one day want to return home, likewise Gibbs.

The salary cap for Carlton will leave no room for Gibbs when he becomes a genuine star in the competition. You could argue who is the biggest loser, but really its a win-win-win for all three clubs.

Awesome thread

 

[Mismatched]

Won't happen, Eagles will want more, but would do Gibbs for VB no worries, but I don't see him being given off anytime soon.

 

[Duffman87]

No Chance! Gibbs has so much more potential than VB and is the better player. And plus Gibbs is a future captian of the club, thus never going to get traded. What a stupid Thread

 

[21knights]

I personally believe imo that there is a possibility that this deal may transpire.

It is a win-win for all clubs.

Especially as I can assume Van Berlo will one day want to return home, likewise Gibbs.

The salary cap for Carlton will leave no room for Gibbs when he becomes a genuine star in the competition. You could argue who is the biggest loser, but really its a win-win-win for all three clubs.

Awesome thread

I stand by my comment that you're on crack. Why would you reply to your own thread and call it awesome?!?

 

[SS_Fury]

I think VB is better than Gibbs at the moment atleast....VB is another rosa, butler type of midfielder though, not sure WC want that?

 

[Smoooothy]

I personally believe imo that there is a possibility that this deal may transpire.

It is a win-win for all clubs.

Especially as I can assume Van Berlo will one day want to return home, likewise Gibbs.

The salary cap for Carlton will leave no room for Gibbs when he becomes a genuine star in the competition. You could argue who is the biggest loser, but really its a win-win-win for all three clubs.

Awesome thread

it better not

who will bay 114 support now!!

are you chris knights by any chance??

 

[-VC-]

No. Ridiculous thread.

Coincidence that the only person to reply that said 'Awesome thread' was the thread starter? I think not.

 

[crow87]

I personally believe imo that there is a possibility that this deal may transpire.

It is a win-win for all clubs.

Especially as I can assume Van Berlo will one day want to return home, likewise Gibbs.

The salary cap for Carlton will leave no room for Gibbs when he becomes a genuine star in the competition. You could argue who is the biggest loser, but really its a win-win-win for all three clubs.

Awesome thread

I personally believe imo that there is no way in hell that this deal will ever transpire (but I hope you're right ).
And did you just call your own thread awesome?

 

[21knights]

No Chance! VB has so much more potential than Gibbs and is the better player. And plus VB is a future captian of the club, thus never going to get traded. What a stupid Thread

I couldn't agree more.

 

[Ferris_rules]

WC will want pick 1, but will have to settle for pick 3 from Carlton. However throw in Van Berlo to them and the deal will be done.

Adelaide may need to offer something extra to Carlton to get Gibbs, Meesen, Jericho or Mattner?

 

[-CG-]

I personally believe imo that there is a possibility that this deal may transpire.

It is a win-win for all clubs.

Especially as I can assume Van Berlo will one day want to return home, likewise Gibbs.

The salary cap for Carlton will leave no room for Gibbs when he becomes a genuine star in the competition. You could argue who is the biggest loser, but really its a win-win-win for all three clubs.

Awesome thread

How can you just assume VB will want to return home? He hasn't shown any signs of homesickness and has said he enjoys it at the Club.

 

[Ferris_rules]

Van Berlo will eventually go home......................

 

[-CG-]

Van Berlo will eventually go home......................

Maybe when he's old and retired

 

[21knights]

Van Berlo will eventually go home......................

You're always so wrong. You're just joking around right?

 

[Ferris_rules]

Food for thought.

Good players in WA and SA originating from outside these states always want to return home.

lol, I was referrring to the comments and feedback as awesome, provokes some discussion, no need to be hostile.

 

[Ferris_rules]

Do you believe Reilly, Knights and Van Berlo will be at our clubs for the entirety of their careers?

I mean honestly?

 

[crowsarethebest]

Food for thought.

Good players in WA and SA originating from outside these states always want to return home.

lol, I was referrring to the comments and feedback as awesome, provokes some discussion, no need to be hostile.

Hahaha. SO you start a rumour saying VB wants to go home because other people from other states do? What a joke. Now, Mods delete thread.

 

[NikkiNoo]

Van Berlo will eventually go home......................

Is this just a gut feeling? From what I have seen of the young man he is very happy here, and you don't throw away a chance at captaining an AFL club....

Yeah he may head back to WA but I would suggest that it will be after his afl career is over.