Votes for the Preliminary?

[fishman]

Surprised no one started one yet...

5 Ottens (you champ)
4 G Ablett
3 Bartel
2 Stokes
1 S Johnson

For Collingwood I would start with 5 votes to the three yellow maggots. Terrible.

 

[FTW_]

5. Joel Corey
4. Brad Ottens
3. Gaz Jnr
2. Dasher Milburn
1. Jimmy Bartel

Unlucky: Byrnes, Scarlo & Dog.

 

[GIMP2]

5 Ottens (now officially worth his weight in gold)
4 Bartel
3 Jnr
2 Corey
1 Dash

Complimentry vote to the umps. Disgraceful

 

[AM]

Otto
Junior
Bartel
Corey
Dash

Lingy, Moons, Chappy, Nath and half a dozen others were really down. Nath must be close to going.

 

[vc_viking]

5.Ottens/Scarlett I can't decide!!
4.Corey
3.Ablett
2.Stokes
1.Byrnes

I thought Shannon Byrnes has played one of his better games, he seemed to get into the hard ball gets and has shown he's capable of stepping up to the plate when it counts....(well just for tonight)

 

[Rhombus]

.....

 

[foxdog50]

5 Otto ( how good was he )
4 Joel Coery
3 G Ablett
2 M Scarlett ( for his job on Rocca)
1 J Bartell

Lets hope we can win 1 more game

 

[crosby123]

5. Ottens
4. Corey
3. G. Ablett
2. Scarlett
1. S. Johnson

 

[setanta17]

5-Corey- i absolutely love him and is a star-his smother on Bryan was breathtaking
4-G Ablett
3-Ottens
2-Bartel
1-Scarlett

 

[CF]

5. Gary Ablett
4. Brad ottens
3. Joel Corey
2. Jimmy bartel
1. Darren Milburn

 

[chapmanmagic35]

5. Ottens
4. Gazza
3. Bartel
2. Johnson
1. Stokes

 

[ChuckNorris]

5- Brad Ottens - An absolute clear best on ground.
4 - Joel Corey - Underrated and consistent as usual.
3 - Gary Ablett - Game Breaker. Provided spark in last quarter
2. - Jimmy Bartel - consistent and perfectly poised game.
1. - Steve Johnson - Again, another game breaker. Got off the bench and turned the game around

 

[Linx]

5. Ottens (Most dominant player on the ground. The difference)
4. Gablett (The spark and class)
3. Bartel (War Machine)
2. Corey (The smother of the year)
1. S Johnson (2 crucial goals)

 

[Tristagi]

5. Joel Corey - Won us the game
4. Brad Ottens - Star
3. Gary Ablett - In Gaz We Trust
2. Jimmy Bartel - JIMMY!
1. Matthew Stokes - WOW, great first quarter.

 

[thegerman]

5 - Otttttttttttttttto
4 - Jnr
3 - Bartel
2 - J Corey
1 - Stokesy

Those putting up Byrnes as having a good game and unlucky to miss out must be taking the Pi$$. Gone, Out, Get lost, You don't deserve to be here, Dropped, Kicked out, Go home.

If Egan is fit, he is in. Otherwise, the Pris can now play in two GF's in two weeks.

 

[Generalissimo]

5. Brad Ottens
4. Gary Ablett
3. Jimmy Bartel
2. Matthew Scarlett
1. Joel Corey

Scott McLaren can sob into his beer tonight... despite his best efforts the better side won.

 

[SirRooke]

5 G Ablett
4. Ottens
3. Bartel
2. Corey
1. Scarlett

 

[Hoffy95]

5. Ottens - Best game for the club yet. Amazing.
4. Ablett - Stood up when required and handled the ball so cleanly.
3. Scarlett - Again destroyed Rocca. Such a crucial player to subdue.
2. Bartel - Solid all game, and again stood up when we needed him most
1. Corey - The smother . Oh and besides that not a half bad game either!

Scott McLaren secured 5 votes for Collingwood, IMO the most important influential individual on the ground. I just wanted to punch him in that nose.

 

[ball]

5 Ottens
4 Ablett
3 Corey
2 Bartel
1 Scarlett

A few too many struggled. Collingwood very impressive - defence was excellent, think the Cat midfield was the difference. Lots more of the ball, but lacking targets.

 

[Big Nasty]

5) Brad Ottens
4) Gary Ablett
3) Jimmy Bartel
2) Matthew Scarlett
1) James Kelly

 

[hoody]

5. Ottens - Best game for the club yet. Amazing.
4. Ablett - Stood up when required and handled the ball so cleanly.
3. Scarlett - Again destroyed Rocca. Such a crucial player to subdue.
2. Bartel - Solid all game, and again stood up when we needed him most
1. Corey - The smother . Oh and besides that not a half bad game either!

Scott McLaren secured 5 votes for Collingwood, IMO the most important influential individual on the ground. I just wanted to punch him in that nose.

My votes are identical.

But I don't think McLaren was a standout. The other two pricks weren't much better.
IMO, the standout worst match of the year as far as umpiring goes.

 

[thehoff]

5. Ottens
4.G.Ablett
3. M.Scarlett
2. J.Corey
1. M.Stokes

 

[griff]

5. otto
4. corey - cozz' smother just the spark we needed when we were flat as a tac
3. gablett - busting runs
2. scarlett - awesome when our backline was getting peppered
1. chapstick - I'd hate to think what we'd be like without his influence

stevie j's 2 goals, dasha and course stokesy's first quarter need mentions

 

[Number32]

it was a hard one between ottens and ablett however

5 G Ablett
4 B Ottens
3 D Milburn
2 J Bartel
1 S Johnson

M Scarlett (only reason i didnt have scarlett in the top 5 was because rocca isnt much of an opponent, especially when you put a half decent defender on him..however as ussual scarlett dominated and ran off and created continually) and J Corey was very good as well

 

[finrod]

5. Ottens - everywhere
5. Corey - awesome smother in Collingwood forward line... both Ottens and Corey should get 5 votes!

3. G. Ablett
2. Bartel
1. Stokes