Votes round 5

[mighty tiges]

3. Brown - You are all class! Feel sorry for him. He must be wondering what he's got himself into.
2. Fleming - He's doesn't belong at AFL level but at least he unlike 90% of his teammates had a dip.
1. Krakouer - absent first half but was very good in the second.

That's about it

 

[Northerly01]

The bloke who produced the gollie!! - 0 Votes!!

 

[Fishfinger]

3 - Brown
2 - Fleming
1 - Fiora

 

[wagstaff]

3 - Fleming (Richmond's best by a country mile. The only player who played was even close to the intensity and directness and urgency that is required at AFL level. Even his mistakes in the final quarter could be forgiven because at least he was trying to be creative and assertive)

2 - Krakouer (Did some brillant things in the 2nd half, although quiet in the 1st half)

1 - Brown (Did some good things, but all his performance underlined tonight was what I suspected when he first got him, that for all his class and goal-kicking abilities he wasn't what Richmond needed. At least in the short term.)

 

[kretchy]

3 - Fleming
2 - Brown
1 - Krakouer

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

3-fleming[for all his faults skill wise.at least he gave 110% tonight unlike most of his gutless teamates excluding brown and the cubs].
2-brown.
1-Krakour.

cheers!

 

[oxx]

Originally posted by kretchy
3 - Fleming
2 - Brown
1 - Krakouer

SAME.

LMAO@the fact that Timmy showed them how to have heart.
Well done Peggy!!
It takes a real man to have a go when the rest are playing
like scared little girls.
For someone who cops it a lot u have guts mate
cheers.

 

[tigermania]

3. Brown
2.Hartigan
1.Fleming

 

[rfctigerarmy]

3: Fleming (did he try his guts out or what..)
2: Krakouer (skill, determination.. the list continues. Pure class)
1: Tivendale (was really on fire at the start of the match)

Unlucky: Brown, Hartigan

 

[CJH]

3. Fleming
2. Brown
1. Krakouer

Fleming has the least talent of anyone on our list but he was the only one to show any ticker, especially through that second quarter.

The only other worthy mentions are Fiora who looks so much better on a wing as well as Hartigan and Roach who play with plenty of entusiasm.

 

[froars]

3 - Hartigan
2 - Krak
1 - Timmy

 

[Wrenny]

3. Tim Fleming
2. Andrew Krakouer
1. Nathan Brown

Special consideration towards hartigans and roachs goal. They have had their first game and both kicked their first goals so come on lets get a win to get their confidence up. How much of a steel was hartigan at 78?

 

[Richmondfan#1]

3. Fleming
2. Brown
1. Krakouer

Special mention to Hartigan.

 

[sante]

3 - Fleming - well done mate
2 - Krakouer - has been very good this year
1 - Hartigan - he has been very consistent and gives us run each week

Fiora, Brown and Roach were also good

 

[DirtyDogTiger]

votes

Originally posted by sante2003
3 - Fleming - well done mate
2 - Krakouer - has been very good this year
1 - Hartigan - he has been very consistent and gives us run each week

Fiora, Brown and Roach were also good

ditto

 

[sante]

Great minds think alike

 

[WilliamPowell]

3 - Fleming - our best by so far it is a further indictment on the so called "stars of our team. Give me 22 Tim's having dip any day compared to the Joel Bowden's of this world

2 - Andy Krakouer

1 - Brent Hartigan

Special mentions to Tommy Roach and Nathan Brown.

5 people following the plan of going in getting the ball and kicking long and direct - go figure

 

[kretchy]

Final votes for Round 5

5 - Tim Fleming 39
4 - Nathan Brown 21
3 - Andrew Krakouer 20
2 - Brent Hartigan 8
0.5 - Aaron Fiora 1
0.5 - Greg Tivendale 1

Leaderboard

Nathan Brown - 17
Andrew Krakouer - 13
Kane Johnson - 11
Wayne Campbell - 5
Joel Bowden - 5
Tim Fleming - 5
Greg Tivendale - 4.5
Matthew Richardson - 3
Brad Ottens - 3
Ty Zantuck - 2
Tom Roach - 2
Brent Hartigan - 2
Andrew Kellaway - 1
Ray Hall - 1
Aaron Fiora - 0.5