Votes v. Carlton

[Bartram_Class]

Jamar you gun.

 

[Supermercado]

Not a great deal deserving of top marks today so I'm spreading it across the midcard.

2 - Jamar
2 - Robertson
1 - Jetta
1 - Davey
1 - Frawley
1 - McDonald
1 - Sylvia
1 - Bate
1 - Moloney
1 - Rivers

 

[cannons]

2 - Jamar
2- Robertson
2 - Sylvia
2 - Frawley
2 - Davey
1 - Jetta
1 - Morton

 

[Grandmaster_B]

Jetta - 3
Jamar - 3
Sylvia - 3
Frawley - 2
Morton - 1

 

[omit]

2 - Jamar
2 - Robertson
2 - Sylvia
1 - Bate
1 - Frawley
1 - Jetta


and no more

 

[TelkoTheGreat]

4 - Sylvia
3 - Jamar
3 - Jetta
1 - McDonald
1 - Robertson

 

[half back flank]

3- Sylvia
3- Jamar
2- McDonald
2- Jetta- shuld get that rising star nominee- really improved for me
2- Robbo- leading goals now from 12 games. i still think he deserved 1 more year because he needs a pre season- but in saying that im not to angry because it free's our list

oh and i loved that we played all 4 ruckman!! and not dunn, bloody typical

 

[Bartram_Class]

3 - Jetta
3 - Davey
2 - Jamar
2 - Robertson
1 - Sylvia
1 - McDonald

24 touches and 2 goals from Jetta, superb.

 

[Dez!]

3 - Jamar
3 - Robbo
3 - Jetta
1 - Sylvia
1 - McDonald
1 - Frawley

 

[Headless]

3 - Mark Jamar
3 - Neville Jetta
2 - Colin Sylvia
2 - James McDonald
1 - Russell Robertson
1 - James Frawley

 

[Surkin]

4 - Jetta
3 - Davey
2 - Jamar
2 - Sylvia
1 - Robbo

 

[melbournemartin]

2 - Jamar
2 - Jetta
2 - Robertson
2 - McDonald
1 - Sylvia
1 - Moloney
1 - Davey
1 - Bate

I'm not really liking all the Frawley love on here. He played okay at the start but then dropped off terribly. This was partially due to Bailey screwing him around with McNamara but he still didn't tighten up on Fevola enough. He's our best FB prospect for the future and I do like the look of him but we really are looking down the barrel at pity votes

 

[Headless]

3 - Mark Jamar
3 - Neville Jetta
2 - Colin Sylvia
2 - James McDonald
1 - Russell Robertson
1 - James Frawley

Also,

12 - Matthew Whelan. Going to miss you, Wheels.

 

[AlfredE]

Hi guys,

not being a troll, but I thought Frawley held Fev early, he'd only kicked two on him, then for some unknown reason was taken off. McNamara went onto Fev and Fev got on top. I believe you guys were right in it until this point. Was Frawley injured, cause he came back on later?

 

[Dez!]

Hi guys,

not being a troll, but I thought Frawley held Fev early, he'd only kicked two on him, then for some unknown reason was taken off. McNamara went onto Fev and Fev got on top. I believe you guys were right in it until this point. Was Frawley injured, cause he came back on later?

Surely a Carlton supporter of all people can see tanking when it happens?

Frawley + Good = Bench

McNamara + 5 goals = Staying on Fev

 

[00Stinger]

4- Sylvia
4- Jamar
2- Robo
1- Davey
1- McDonald

 

[demonfan9]

Frawley did very well early on against Fevola. Just two goals (a free kick and a snap) and no marks. Then he was moved off him, and it all went downhill from there.


2 - Jamar
2 - Robertson
2 - Jetta
2 - Robertson
2 - Davey
1 - Morton
1 - Sylvia

 

[whelan=legend]

3- Sylvia
2- Jamar
2- Jetta
2- Robbo
2- Frawley
1- Davey

 

[The Dr]

4 Jamar
2 Jetta
2 Davey
2 Sylvia
1 Frawley
1 Robbo

 

[saj_21]

3 - Sylvia
2 - Jamar
2 - Davey
2 - Jetta
2 - Robertson
1 - Bate

 

[BlueDW]

A few thoughts from a Carlton fan.

• No intensity in the game, so cameos from players who havent shown much up until now should be taken with a grain of salt. eg Garlett and Jetta
• Davey was disappointing in that he hardly got the ball forward of centre, basically spent the whole game getting cheap kicks.
• Tanking, well not much can be added there, take the picks when you can get them.
• Chip Frawley showed a bit, got away with a fair bit though in terms of holding.
• Sylvia can play, a shame it has taken so long to get his head right.

Attending the game was like going to your Mother in laws birthday party - you have to be there but doesnt mean you have to like it. Very disappointed with effort by the Blues, if we go that hard next week against the Crows we will get smashed. Dees will be ok, but going to take some time to get there. I would seriously consider trading pick 2 for an established star.

 

[2 Dogs]

3- Jamar
3- Sylvia
2- Jetta
2- Robbo
1- Chip
1- Junior

 

[Grandmaster_B]

A few thoughts from a Carlton fan.

• No intensity in the game, so cameos from players who havent shown much up until now should be taken with a grain of salt. eg Garlett and Jetta
• Davey was disappointing in that he hardly got the ball forward of centre, basically spent the whole game getting cheap kicks.
• Tanking, well not much can be added there, take the picks when you can get them.
• Chip Frawley showed a bit, got away with a fair bit though in terms of holding.
• Sylvia can play, a shame it has taken so long to get his head right.

Attending the game was like going to your Mother in laws birthday party - you have to be there but doesnt mean you have to like it. Very disappointed with effort by the Blues, if we go that hard next week against the Crows we will get smashed. Dees will be ok, but going to take some time to get there. I would seriously consider trading pick 2 for an established star.

The weekends game was nothing compared to Round 22, 2007.

We wont be trading pick 2, not a chance.

Davey may have been quiet, but his role will change completely in 2010 as the list managing for picks debacle will be over. Davey will be doing his work forward of the centre next year and beyond. Look out!

And you will never see Sylvia play in the back line again, even though he was sensational.