Votes V Geelong

[jules101]

3- MJ... Played well all night
2- JJ - Tried all night, Bendigo did him some good
1- Fletch just... Toss up b/w Fletch Welsh and Stants but just Fletch

HM: Welsh, Johns, Stants, Monfries

 

[S.C[BANKS]]

1.Mark Jonhson
2.Jason jonhson
3.Angus Monfries

Iam voting from best the top 3 so number 1 is the best.

 

[marcuz]

Votes vs geelong

3 - MJ...Was a throwback of MJ circa 2000 tonight.
2 - JJ....All heart.
1 - laycock...he made some mistakes but i thought he was good.

The kids had a dip also, they all show a bit and IMO give us some hope for the future. Also thought Solly played great in defence when he was shifted.

NLM was pathetic, where the **** did that effort come from after a good start?

 

[jules101]

Re: Votes vs geelong

3 - MJ...Was a throwback of MJ circa 2000 tonight.
2 - JJ....All heart.
1 - laycock...he made some mistakes but i thought he was good.

The kids had a dip also, they all show a bit and IMO give us some hope for the future. Also thought Solly played great in defence when he was shifted.

NLM was pathetic, where the **** did that effort come from after a good start?

didnt like my thread Marcuz???

 

[The D-ROD]

Re: Votes vs geelong

3- mj
2- fletch
1- jj

spec mentions: lacock, lucas, johns(1st half)

hav a look in a mirror: mcphee

youn kids were ordinary when it counted tonight....

 

[Riddell_Bombers]

Re: Votes vs geelong

3. Jason Johnson
2. Dustin Fletcher
1. Mark Johnson

 

[The D-ROD]

shizer...bit of deja vu ...swear i already did votes....mmmmmmm...just to be sure...

3-mj
2-fletch
1-jj

 

[mikeula]

3- MJ... Played well all night
2- JJ - Tried all night, Bendigo did him some good
1- Fletch just... Toss up b/w Fletch Welsh and Stants but just Fletch

HM: Welsh, Johns, Stants, Monfries

Reckon you would find it very hard to find honourable mentions for that effort!

Welsh and Stants werent great. If anything thought Lucas shcould have been included in your list.

 

[marcuz]

Re: Votes vs geelong

didnt like my thread Marcuz???

Sorry mate i've had a few sherbets tonight, all fixed now.

 

[jules101]

Reckon you would find it very hard to find honourable mentions for that effort!

Welsh and Stants werent great. If anything thought Lucas shcould have been included in your list.

Welsh played well tonight. What did he do wrong?
Scotty Scotty Scotty... 3.4 with one not making the distance. Not good enough in my eyes. Missed a few he should get.

 

[jules101]

Re: Votes vs geelong

Sorry mate i've had a few sherbets tonight, all fixed now.

hehe thats alright.. Drown the sorrows after another not so great show by the boys

 

[bmwofoz]

3 Mark Johnson
2 Jascon Johnson
1 Courtney Johns

 

[mcphee_is_a_gun]

3 JJ
2 MJ
1 Fletch

Good to see Solomon find a bit of form.

 

[mikeula]

Welsh played well tonight. What did he do wrong?
Scotty Scotty Scotty... 3.4 with one not making the distance. Not good enough in my eyes. Missed a few he should get.

Welsh - How about the fair few occasions when he tried to bump players instead of tackling or his rubbish 20 metre chip kicks that go sideways and dont always hit a target.

Lucas - 3.4 from him with the rubbish supply that he was given was a fantastic effort. He tried his guts out leading up and prob took about 12 marks and chasing all game. He was that tired that he couldnt make the distance.

 

[ant555]

Scotty Scotty Scotty... 3.4 with one not making the distance. Not good enough in my eyes. Missed a few he should get.

Very harsh , yes he did mis a couple of gettable goals but he did have 20 possessions and 14 marks.

 

[jules101]

Very harsh , yes he did mis a couple of gettable goals but he did have 20 possessions and 14 marks.

Scotty would have been our best if he converted better. He played well but its just frustrating for someone who can kick so well to kick more points then goals

 

[mikeula]

Re: Votes vs geelong

3 - MJ...Was a throwback of MJ circa 2000 tonight.
2 - JJ....All heart.
1 - laycock...he made some mistakes but i thought he was good.

The kids had a dip also, they all show a bit and IMO give us some hope for the future. Also thought Solly played great in defence when he was shifted.

NLM was pathetic, where the **** did that effort come from after a good start?

Not wrong about Lovett-Murray. He was shocking. Every facet of his game was terrible. His disposal, decision making, dropping marks and that spoiling attempt in the first quarter was laughable when he had the sit.

 

[Jem]

3- JJ
2-MJ
1-Fletch

Good to see that both the johnsons are out of their slumps

 

[DaSawx]

Welsh played well tonight. What did he do wrong?
Scotty Scotty Scotty... 3.4 with one not making the distance. Not good enough in my eyes. Missed a few he should get.

Jesus Christ Scotty tried his guts out last night

Pev and Courtney Johns should be getting a mention for a good game last night

Can agree, NLM was shocking

3- JJ
2- Fletch
1- Johns

 

[Hirdy!!]

3. jj
2. mj
1. fletch

 

[jules101]

Jesus Christ Scotty tried his guts out last night

Pev and Courtney Johns should be getting a mention for a good game last night

Can agree, NLM was shocking

3- JJ
2- Fletch
1- Johns

He's there to kick goals... He played well but he needs to convert better. Im only hard on him because he is such a good player and he is usually a very good kick.

 

[DaSawx]

He's there to kick goals... He played well but he needs to convert better. Im only hard on him because he is such a good player and he is usually a very good kick.

So he has to kick perfectly every single week while trying his guts out and trying to carry the entire forward line on his shoulders? Cut him a little slack please, there were way too many other worrying events last night than Scotty's kicking for goal

 

[jules101]

So he has to kick perfectly every single week while trying his guts out and trying to carry the entire forward line on his shoulders? Cut him a little slack please, there were way too many other worrying events last night than Scotty's kicking for goal

43% accuracy for our best forward is worrying in my eyes. The last few weeks kicking at goal has been pretty bad from the whole team. Last night was a bit better... I am just saying that if Lloyd had 7 shots at goals we would expect 5 goals.. Why shouldn't Scotty be the same.. Ah well 2 goals wouldnt have changed too much so I dont really care.
I think that the delivery into the forward line was pretty bad last night, as well as that as soon as the ball hit the ground in our forwrd line we never got it.

 

[DaSawx]

I am just saying that if Lloyd had 7 shots at goals we would expect 5 goals.. Why shouldn't Scotty be the same..

We should expect it, but we just won't get it every single week, not even from Lloydy, just sums up how we are travelling atm, the senior guys are working their butts of and the rewards aren't showing.

I think that the delivery into the forward line was pretty bad last night, as well as that as soon as the ball hit the ground in our forwrd line we never got it.

Yeah, it definately was frustrating, with so much inexperience in the side these days I can see a few more frustrating days ahead unfortunately.

We need Hird, Campo, Rioli and Lovett to be playing just to steady the ship and insert a little more leadership

 

[mikeula]

43% accuracy for our best forward is worrying in my eyes. The last few weeks kicking at goal has been pretty bad from the whole team. Last night was a bit better... I am just saying that if Lloyd had 7 shots at goals we would expect 5 goals.. Why shouldn't Scotty be the same.. Ah well 2 goals wouldnt have changed too much so I dont really care.
I think that the delivery into the forward line was pretty bad last night, as well as that as soon as the ball hit the ground in our forwrd line we never got it.

Definitely ease up on him. Reckon only one of those misses was bad and that was the one in the third when he played on and tried to snap it. He looked totally spent in the last quarter hence why he might have been struggling to get the distance and therefore missed a few.