Votes vs Saints

[Sylvia Saint]

5 - Neitz (wow)
4 - McLean (man this kid is good)
3 - McDonald
2 - Carroll
1 - White

Solid win, not pretty at times but effective none the less.

 

[goDees22]

agree completely with your votes SS.

5 - Neitz (good to do it against a good opponent)
4 - McLean (Gun, probably overtaken Bruce into 2nd B&F place atm)
3 - McDonald (B&F winner so far i reckon, hasn't played a bad game)
2 - Carroll (Riewoldt kicked 2, and played ok but chopper still did a great job)
1 - White (Dominated as he should have against a poor ruck division)


How huge will the Queens Birthday game be?

 

[dutchy12]

5: Neitz 6 goals by the 10 minute mark of the 2nd quarter. What a champion. Next week Fred Fannings record
4: Brock- love watching him play, his aggression, his deceptive pace the complete package really
3: McDonald- Consistent his last quarter was brillaint
2-Carrol solid
1- Dutchy Holland- lol great to have him back in the side, but serioulsy i think he did alright except for that blunder inthe 3rd quarter

W.O.G: Godfrey - know he tries but god his skilllevels are that poor

 

[Headless]

5. Neitz
4. McLean
3. McDonald
2. Yze
1. White

Bruce a bit stiff to miss out.

 

[goal sneak]

5. Neitz (8 goals.. enough said)
4. McLean (31 possesions and another 8 tackles)
3. McDonald (27 possesions and 7 tackles)
2. White (22 possesions and 27 hitouts)
1. Johnstone (stood up in last quarter)

Honourable mentions:
Yze - 27 touches
Dutchy - beat Fraser
Johnson - 20 touches, all class
Carrol - Killed Rooy
Bate - 20 touches

 

[StingaArmstrong]

5. Neitz (8 goals.. enough said)
4. McLean (31 possesions and another 8 tackles)
3. McDonald (27 possesions and 7 tackles)
2. White (22 possesions and 27 hitouts)
1. Johnstone (stood up in last quarter)

Honourable mentions:
Yze - 27 touches
Dutchy - beat Fraser
Johnson - 20 touches, all class
Carrol - Killed Rooy
Bate - 20 touches

Agreed.

 

[Marns]

5 - David Neitz (8 goals, dominated. The ball stuck to his hands and timed so very sweetly with his boot.)
4 - Brocky McLean (How old is he again?)
3 - Nathan Carroll (I feel very very safe with Carroll and Rivers as our two key Defenders. Carroll killed Roo all day)
2 - Jimmy Mac (Best start to a season I've seen junior play. He is a gun)
1 - White (Better 2nd half for whitey, played very well)

 

[Jimi]

No one rates Chris Johnson's game?

 

[melbournemartin]

5. Neitz
4. Holland
3. Carroll
2. Bartram
1. McLean

yeh wierd votes, i figure brock will finish 2 at the end anyway but i thought our defence was supurb. Gerhig normally rips us a new one and if he doesn't, Riewoldt does...or they both do.

i loved Bartrams run out of defence. he has a lot more confidence now and a lot of pace.

but yeh McLean...I actually didn't rate it as his best game of the year, even though his stats suggest otherwise. When is he going to play a bad game? He is mature beyond his age. His clearance skills are supurb. He was against Ball for a bit and he beat Ball who is apparently 1 of the league's best midfielders though I rate Dal Santo much more highly

 

[Lord_Travis]

5 - Neitz (wonderful effort, and well deserving of the BOG and the records he is breaking)
4 - Mclean (this kid is a gun and was the best midfielder out there, which is becoming a regular occurance now. Beat Ball when he was on him, and we all know how highly rated Ball is)
3 - Mcdonald (finally getting some of the respect he deserves for being a great soldier for us)
2 - White (better game from him, as I think he has been pretty poor this year. Some great taps today)
1 - Johnstone (shone with 10 disposals in the last, and always seems to be in the thick of it when the game is up for grabs at the end. He is our superstar and always leads us to victory)

Apologies to Yze, Carroll, C.Johnson

 

[Canna7]

5 - Neitz (8.3 goals was the difference in his record breaking game)
4 - McDonald (would've got BOG if it wasn't for Neita's effort)
3 - McLean (another sensational game, he is already a star)
2 - White (the team played much better when he was on the ground)
1 - Johnson (backed up last week with another fine performance)

 

[Klyntonius]

5. Neitz - Best milestone game ever?
4. McLean - continues to improve and is fast becoming an elite midfielder in the league
3. Carroll - goes from strength to strength. Set the scene with some aggressive work on Riewoldt in the first term and his best attribute is that he backs himself
2. Holland - 2 matches this year for 2 good games in defence. Miller will have to work his way back into the team
1. Bartram - attacks the ball with ferocity and brings blokes down in tackles that by rights (because of his lack of size) he shouldn't be able to

Apologies to Jeff White and James McDonald in particular. They worked hard all game and I reckon Junior is in career best form. Godfrey had his best game for a long time (by his standards - he actually hit some targets and created today) and if Bartram has hurt his shoulder he will probably remain next week. Yze provided good run and Whelan thrashed Milne til he went off injured. A good team effort. Just need to sort out our third quarters though.

 

[Deestroy]

5 - Neitz
4 - McLean
3 - McDonald
2 - Bate
1 - C.Johnson

Appologies to White & Carroll.

 

[Theseventhhamster]

5 Neita
4 Brock
3 Jmac
2 Yze
1 Bate
I like being sober at the footy it means I can do votes!

 

[cannons]

Okay, I haven't seen any stats so this is based on what I saw live at the game without whoever got 45 possesions influence.

5- Neitz (I think that's pretty easy)
4- Johnstone (He really stood out with his composure under pressure)
3- Brock (Another great game)
2- Junior Burger (Was also really good)
1- Pickett (Did some very classy things esp. setting up Bate)

Carrol and Holland did well down back, except for Holland's kicking.
Chris Johnson was great in the first half. Bate was good too as was Bartram.
I could keep going but I'll just put an end to it now.

 

[AllStar7]

5- Brock. Yes big controversy, but he got those balls down to Neita.

4- Neita. Like a good wine, gets better with age... well at least today

3- McDonland. Great in and under game

2- Carroll. Huge effort on Reiwoldt

1- Dutchy.

 

[Bartram_Class]

5 - Neitz
4 - JMac
3 - McLean
2 - Carroll
1 - Bartram

 

[Spirit of 26]

5: Neitz 6 goals by the 10 minute mark of the 2nd quarter. What a champion. Next week Fred Fannings record
4: Brock- love watching him play, his aggression, his deceptive pace the complete package really
3: McDonald- Consistent his last quarter was brillaint
2-Carrol solid
1- Dutchy Holland- lol great to have him back in the side, but serioulsy i think he did alright except for that blunder inthe 3rd quarter

W.O.G: Godfrey - know he tries but god his skilllevels are that poor

Do I note a touch of favouritism? But it was a solid effort by Holland and its good we have him as an option for the big, slow forwards like Gehrig.

 

[melbournemartin]

i gave dutchey some votes...he played very well.

 

[Pipefitter]

5. Neitz (I havent seen him play like that for a long time)
4. Mclean (Cant say enough about him, another great performance, Sylvia has some catching up to do)
3. McDonald (Another solid hard game from the most underated)
2. Carrol (Made Roo earn the little impact he had)
1. Rivers (Zoned off very well, stopped quite a few forward entries)

 

[Supermercado]

5 - McLean
4 - Neitz
3 - McDonald
2 - Rivers
1 - Holland