2nds WAFL/WAFL Reserves Thread 2015

[JordanWCE]

Karpany has to go at season's end.

 

[CoastersFlag No.5]

Rosa with 27 possessions will be pushing for selection. Cavka won't be in the ressies for long if he keeps kicking goals and playing well.

 

[kane249]

I'd swap Newman and Karpany at the end of the season in terms of demotion and promotion to the rookie list.

It's labelled as a poor draft this year, would rather retain Karpany and put him on an incentive based deal than go the unknown.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

I'd swap Newman and Karpany at the end of the season in terms of demotion and promotion to the rookie list.

It's labelled as a poor draft this year, would rather retain Karpany and put him on an incentive based deal than go the unknown.

I don't even see the value of Karpany as a rookie listed player at this stage. Let's give somebody a chance who actually has some hunger.

 

[kane249]

I don't even see the value of Karpany as a rookie listed player at this stage. Let's give somebody a chance who actually has some hunger.

He's had a death in the family this year which might still be screwing with his head. I'd be willing to give him a one year deal on the rookie list to see if he will respond otherwise cut our losses the following year.

 

[Wet Toast Rule]

He's had a death in the family this year which might still be screwing with his head. I'd be willing to give him a one year deal on the rookie list to see if he will respond otherwise cut our losses the following year.

Sorry, poor excuse.

Maybe for a game or two, not for awhile year.

See N Riewoldt today

 

[Johnno22]

I see Lucas is getting some big numbers.

How is he actually playing?

 

[Godfather32]

Sorry, poor excuse.

Maybe for a game or two, not for awhile year.

See N Riewoldt today

You can't just arbitrarily say that though, some people are back at work the next day, some never get over it.

 

[Monocle]

Adamson and Cavka are both goal scoring mids, exciting.

RE did you get to watch Cavka ??? and if so thoughts.!!!!

 

[kane249]

You can't just arbitrarily say that though, some people are back at work the next day, some never get over it.

Exactly, especially for Indigenous people who are very tight knit with their families

 

[grimlock]

 

[royalsfan]

Bloody Ross Lyon dropping Xac Clarke for this game. Peel were the land of the giants in their forward line - at one stage they had Clarke, Hannath and Griffen in there. I didn't count them all, but I think two thirds at least of the Peel team were FD.
Lucas played his best game so far, Bennell was classy, Karpany was extremely quiet, Brophy still learning, does some dumb things, Powell meh,Newman was good, Colledge wasn't a standout, didn't really notice him much at all, Rosa great to see him back, won't be long out of the Eagles, Hutch was very good, tough as nails.

 

[neng]

Bloody Ross Lyon dropping Xac Clarke for this game. Peel were the land of the giants in their forward line - at one stage they had Clarke, Hannath and Griffen in there. I didn't count them all, but I think two thirds at least of the Peel team were FD.
Lucas played his best game so far, Bennell was classy, Karpany was extremely quiet, Brophy still learning, does some dumb things, Powell meh,Newman was good, Colledge wasn't a standout, didn't really notice him much at all, Rosa great to see him back, won't be long out of the Eagles, Hutch was very good, tough as nails.

Can't have been Hannath mate, he was on the Gold Coast yesterday

 

[kane249]

Probably meant Moller

 

[sey666]

Sorry, poor excuse.

Maybe for a game or two, not for awhile year.

See N Riewoldt today

Can you really compare a 20 year old indegenious kid who has not yet played a game of AFL football to a 32 year old superstar who has played nearly 300 games?

 

[West Coast 06]

Sorry, poor excuse.

Maybe for a game or two, not for awhile year.

See N Riewoldt today

Don't really know what to say to this post.

Insensitive is the most polite word I can think of.

 

[royalsfan]

Probably meant Moller

Is he the weird looking guy with dreadlocks? If so, that's him.

 

[WCEswift]

Is he the weird looking guy with dreadlocks? If so, that's him.

Ya total mongy looking dude

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

I didn't count them all, but I think two thirds at least of the Peel team were FD.

14/22 according to the table Grimlock posted.

 

[kane249]

14/22 according to the table Grimlock posted.

Of the remaining 8 you have Ugle, Bootsma and Jetta who have been on AFL lists as well.

 

[SpaceClef]

I see Lucas is getting some big numbers.

How is he actually playing?

Like a first round draft pick

 

[Goldfish]

Like a first round draft pick

National or rookie?

 

[SpaceClef]

National or rookie?

2001 National Draft

 

[vWestCoast]

Can you really compare a 20 year old indegenious kid who has not yet played a game of AFL football to a 32 year old superstar who has played nearly 300 games?

I'm sorry but how is it at all relevant he is indigenous....

 

[boondy]

I see Lucas is getting some big numbers.

How is he actually playing?

Handballing while tackled to someone else tackled . Kicks backwards . Klanger kicks . He is no good