MRP / Trib. Week 2 vs Geelong - Ballantyne 2 weeks

[purplerunsdeep]

Anything we have to worry about?


- Ballas might get a week
- Pav's errant arm throw might get looked at
- Did Fyfe do anything?

A lot of niggle and cheap shots all over the ground, a lot in the second half when Geelong started playing the man, not the ball. MRP will be busy with this game

 

[freo84]

Nothing to see here.....Ballaz was accidental and so was Pav's. Both were playing the ball not the man.

 

[Moo]

Pav no chance.

Balla will be looked at.

Smed is dead- 2 weeks min

Hopefully they look at Clark and his ridiculous and extended jumper punching episode...$'s only

 

[leungtl]

Hopefully they look at Clark and his ridiculous and extended jumper punching episode...$'s only

I feel like if you land more jumper punches than you have touches in a game of footy, you should be automatically banned.

 

[Freo88]

I feel like if you land more jumper punches than you have touches in a game of footy, you should be automatically banned.

This - more for the good of the game than anything else.

 

[go_the_dockers]

Pav no chance.

Balla will be looked at.

Smed is dead- 2 weeks min

Hopefully they look at Clark and his ridiculous and extended jumper punching episode...$'s only

Clark - Should be a holding the man free kick straight away, that would stop it.

Applying the Purple rule, Smed will get a fine and Ballas will get 3-4.

Seppo - do you have a copy of the image which shows the new MRP rules, with special grading for Sydney and Freo? I can't find it and I think you posted it from memory.

 

[Freoforever86]

Someone flattened a dockers player in the centre way off the ball in the 3rd. Think it was the young fella Cockatoo

 

[Mr Peabody]

Someone flattened a dockers player in the centre way off the ball in the 3rd. Think it was the young fella Cockatoo

Saw that too but hard to ascertain who he sniped - was it Fyfey?

 

[Zacy boy]

Saw that too but hard to ascertain who he sniped - was it Fyfey?

It was Fyfe who he got, 02:42 3rd quarter. Top right of screen.

 

[beetz]

The revamped MRP should see a few fines dished out, nothing more.

As opposed to last year, where you would of seen Ballantyne get 3 months incarceration.

 

[go_the_dockers]

The revamped MRP should see a few fines dished out, nothing more.

As opposed to last year, where you would of seen Ballantyne get 3 months incarceration.

Ballas will either get a fine or 2-3 weeks due to bad record

 

[yoong]

I had a look at the MRP chart.
Based on Ballas's reaction it's hard to grade that as intentional.
So for careless, if the impact is graded as low, $1000 fine. If medium, 1 week. Not sure if Ballas is considered having a bad record with the new system, but if so, 1 additional week.
Personally, it depends on Geelong's medical record (oh no). Also considering that Taylor stayed down for a while and had to get off the field, I think it'll be a medium.

Brace yourselves for 2 weeks folks.

 

[purplerunsdeep]

I had a look at the MRP chart.
Based on Ballas's reaction it's hard to grade that as intentional.
So for careless, if the impact is graded as low, $1000 fine. If medium, 1 week. Not sure if Ballas is considered having a bad record with the new system, but if so, 1 additional week.
Personally, it depends on Geelong's medical record (oh no). Also considering that Taylor stayed down for a while and had to get off the field, I think it'll be a medium.

Brace yourselves for 2 weeks folks.

Maybe the knock to taylor's head made him angry - he came out with some cheap shots after that incident which should also be looked at

also should make any team doc report from geelong irrelevant - he played on and was fine

my thoughts it wasn't intentional - but possibly careless - kept his shoulder in and I don't think he left the ground

1 week maybe with bad record

 

[Nothing]

It will be one of:
- Nothing
- Monetary fine
- 2 week suspension as allas has a +1 week penalty if suspended.

 

[yoong]

Maybe the knock to taylor's head made him angry - he came out with some cheap shots after that incident which should also be looked at

also should make any team doc report from geelong irrelevant - he played on and was fine

my thoughts it wasn't intentional - but possibly careless - kept his shoulder in and I don't think he left the ground

1 week maybe with bad record

Assuming careless (not intentional)
Low impact - $1000 fine
Medium impact - 1 week + 1 week (bad record)

It's either a fine or 2 weeks, depending on how they judge the impact.

If it's graded intentional it'll be much worse.

 

[tofushark]

no bad records at the moment, hence why s. johnson got a fine only last week

 

[Nothing]

no bad records at the moment, hence why s. johnson got a fine only last week

There are some players with carry over bad records, I'm pretty sure Ballas is one of them.

 

[yoong]

no bad records at the moment, hence why s. johnson got a fine only last week

No. Johnson was lucky caused it ended as a fine. But if he got weeks then it's +1 for him too.

 

[tofushark]

my bad

A week's additional suspension for bad record, where players have been suspended for two matches in the previous 24 months.

 

[MadDocker]

What time does the MRP sit? Interested to see how they interpret this and what happens with the new system. Will be happily shocked if Ballas doesn't sit out a couple.

 

[Moist Biscuit]

 

[Moist Biscuit]

Careless, Low impact -fine
careless, medium impact- 1 week.

 

[MadDocker]

Bet you he cops careless, medium & 2 weeks. If only Taylor got up instead of having a quick breather on the deck...

 

[Mr Peabody]

View attachment 124035

They need another Category in that Table under "INTENTIONAL" called "INSPIRATIONAL" where it involves anyone cleaning up Steve Johnson.
I'm pretty sure it was he who had Duffield in a headlock and made out he was trying to handball the Sherrin but instead connected with his head....

 

[go_the_dockers]

Careless, Low impact -fine
careless, medium impact- 1 week.

2 weeks for Ballas due to bad record.