West Coast Eagles Questionnaire

[Eagle Number1000]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
When Scott Cummings kick 14 goals in one game against Adelaide back in 1999- I still remember even if others don't.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Micheal Gardiners miss shot at goal, straight in front in 2005 grand final.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
Micheal O goal against us in the Qualifing final of 2006

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment- Hawthorn

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- 55 point comback against Geelong at skilled in 2006 season

6. Fav win including finals of all time- against Adeliade 2006 prem final

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time- would be Ben Cousins from 2006 onwards- became very annoying and frustrating.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time- would be Jeff Farmer,
J Hird,

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations- would be Ash Sampi- had so much potential,

10. Fav player not WCE of all time- A Kouta (Carlton), G Ablett senior

 

[joeyavalanche]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
That Judd game vs Brisbane. I didnt know if he was going to stop kicking goals that game.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Something Chad Fletcher, i do not understand why he still is employed.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
That mark. Leo Barry

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment-
St Kilda

5. Whats your fav win not including finals-
55 point Geelong comeback

6. Fav win including finals of all time-
That 2006 flag. Although that Adelaide game was amazing

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time-
Chadwick Fletcher

8. Most hated player from another club of all time-
Way too many, hated Hird, hated Farmer, hate Cornes, theres lots

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations
Ash Sampi, Trav Gasper, Andrew McDougall, Brad Smith

10. Fav player not WCE of all time-
Gary Ablett Jnr

 

[WCEforeverman]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
Matera sets sail for home, and the Eagles hit the front. I grew up watching Matera. He seemed to be able to do anything.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
The whole 2005 grand final. I havent watched any of it since GF day 2005. Not even highlights (except for Barry's mark which was played ad nauseum for a while)

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE - Anytime we play Melbourne and Robertson tries to milk any contact he gets. He really pisses me off.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment- Carlton (but really anyone really, depending on who we are playing on the weekend)

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- 1998 (?) game against the Bulldogs at the WACA, where they kicked 7 or so in the first quarter, then we kicked the same for it to be all square at halftime. We won by about 13 IIRC. Round 1 2007 against Sydney was also a great game.

6. Fav win including finals of all time - 2006 Grand Final. I was in primary school when the other two cups were won, and didn't appreciate them as much.

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time - Ben Cousins. How he is still liked by some supporters astounds me. Never put a player infront of the club. It's a privledge for a player to wear our jumper. Not the other way around.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time - Jeff Farmer, Akermanis, Milne.

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations- Cummings. Great first year the faded into obscurity.

10. Fav player not WCE of all time- Richo. Sure he chucks the odd tanty, but you can tell how much he loves his club. I wish two of our past captains had his passion.

 

[Miguel Sanchez]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
Chick's smother, handball, shepherd. The best individual moment of the 06 grand final, which is my favourite Eagles memory because I was there.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Sumich hitting the post in the final vs Collingwood in 1990 to tie the scores when a goal would have won the match. We went on to lose the replay and Collingwood went on the win the flag. (Can't really blame Suma though, he was deep in the wrong pocket).

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
Danny Southern choking Suma into unconsciousness
Wanted to say Leo Barry's mark but I have to admit to a non-Eagles fan it would've been absolutely sensational.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment- Probably Carlton, just ahead of Collingwood.

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- The comeback at Kardinia.

6. Fav win including finals of all time- the 2006 granny.

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time- There's a few I haven't been too fond of, but I wouldn't say I hated any of them.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time - Greg Williams or Tony Liberatore or Danny Southern, take your pick.

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations - this question is tailor-made for Sampi.

10. Fav player not WCE of all time - Hird or Harvey.

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
When Scott Cummings kick 14 goals in one game against Adelaide back in 1999- I still remember even if others don't.

It was in 2000, and he followed it up with 10 against Freo when we smashed them all over Subiaco Oval

 

[The_Eagles]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
Matera 'sets sail for home' goal.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Brent Staker's fumble in the goalsquare in the 2005 GF.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
Paul Salmon kicking the sealer in a 1993 Final.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment- Hawthorn

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- 55 point comback against Geelong at skilled in 2006 season

6. Fav win including finals of all time- against Adeliade 2006 prem final

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time- don't have one really, Nicoski for banging a girl I liked.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time-

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations- would be Ash Sampi- had so much potential,

10. Fav player not WCE of all time- W. Carey

 

[Crimson King]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history - Daniel Chick's ultimate 1%.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE - Michael Gardiner's 2005 GF.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE - Leo Barry's mark. Only because they keep replaying it

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment - Carlton

5. Whats your fav win not including finals - Kardinya Park, 2006. Brilliant game.

6. Fav win including finals of all time - 2006 grand final, 2006 PF very close behind.

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time - No-one really.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time - Farmer.

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations - Ash Sampi

10. Fav player not WCE of all time- James Hird

 

[Crimson King]

7. Most hated player for wce of all time- don't have one really, nicoski for banging a girl i liked.

lol

 

[Ochre]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history
Sampi's mark

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE
Ben Cousins <insert any event from 2007 here>

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE
Learning Hall got off and could play in 05 GF

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment
R***t*** or Freo

5. Whats your fav win not including finals
44(?) point comeback v Carlton at Subi, week after the 54(?) point comeback v Geelong

6. Fav win including finals of all time
06 Granny

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time
Ben Cousins

8. Most hated player from another club of all time
Josh Carr

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations
Brad Smith, not his fault though

10. Fav player not WCE of all time
Richo

 

[KamakazeSalami]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
Chick's smother/handball in 06 GF

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Staker's fumble in front of goal 05 GF

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
Micky O's sealer in the 06 QF

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment- Carlton

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- R1 2007 v Sydney at ANZ Stadium (Cox, Embley out, Cousins suspended... all the crap leading up to the game PLUS the Sydney factor PLUS we won by 1 point... AGAIN!! PLUS I was there )

6. Fav win including finals of all time- 2006 GF (lucky enough to be there)

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time- Chris Judd (yes, I have some bridges to build).

8. Most hated player from another club of all time- Chris Judd

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations- Fraser Gehrig

10. Fav player not WCE of all time- Voss/Hird

 

[wirra44]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history- Cummings 14 goals, Cuzzy's comeback game against Sydney, chicks smother and shepard in 2006 GF and Nic Naitanui 3 goal last qtr.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE- Michael Gardiner missing from so close in the 2005 GF.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE- James Hird kicking a goal against us to win the game.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment- Carlton or Freo.

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- Comeback against Geelong and Carlton and Round 1 2007 against Sydney.

6. Fav win including finals of all time- Of course 2006 Grand Final or 2006 Prelim

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time- Chris Judd

8. Most hated player from another club of all time- Cam Mooney and Brain Lake

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations- Ash Sampi

10. Fav player not WCE of all time- Tony Lockett, Richo and Shane Crawford..

 

[Byron_Clanger]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
Adam Hunters goal in the 06 Grand Final, the sealer

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Chris Judd's departure press conference

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
Leo Barry's 05 Grand Final Mark, while Sampi and Judd were getting scragged in the pack with no free kick paid.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment-
Fremantle

5. Whats your fav win not including finals-
1 point win, round 1 vs Sydney season 07

6. Fav win including finals of all time-
92, 94, 06 Grand Final

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time-
Mark Nicoski

8. Most hated player from another club of all time-
Chris Judd, you screwed us mate

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations
Ash Sampi, Daniel Mconnell

10. Fav player not WCE of all time-
Brendan Fevola

 

[billy ransom]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-

tie:

1. Matera running out of the square and kicking a goal in the 92 GF

2. Kerr 06 GF. Eagles are kicking towards city end. The ball is kicked in the middle of some players on the left HFF, Kerr runs through the pack and controls the volleying ball deftly with his left hand at full pace, leaves the players in his wake and then hits a leading Lynch on the chest with a left foot pass.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-

When that ketchup-headed **** hair was given a 3 year contract when he was clearly past it.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-

Brett Burton going to the tribunal and snitching. Leave it on the field you one man dog act.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment

Port or Adelaide. Both teams are full of pole smokers.

5. Whats your fav win not including finals

3-way tie:

1. 55 point comback against Geelong at skilled in 2006 season
2. Late 90s v Bulldogs. The kicked 9 goals to zip first quarter then we kicked 10 goals to zip second quarter.
3. Big come back against Saints in 89-sh at the WACA. Was at the game.

6. Fav win including finals of all time-

06 GF. Some people never get to see their team win a GF in their lifetime on TV, let alone at the MCG. I sat on the 1st tier, 5 rows back at the Punt Rd end and saw my team win a cracker by 1 pt.

Some people have a list of things they want to experience and/or achieve during their lifetime. Visit Europe, skydive, travel on the orient express, have a threesome, go deep sea fishing etc.

I have 1 thing and 1 thing only on my list. And I have done it.

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time-

Rowan Jones.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time-

Brett Burton, Des headland.

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations-

Warren Ralph.

10. Fav player not WCE of all time

Hird

 

[THE411]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
Have to say Naita's 3 goals against Hawthorn are right up there.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Staker's shocking mistakes late in the 2005 Grand Final, still makes me angry whenever i think about it. So costly.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
James Hird's goal and celebration with the crowd member cut me deep as it won Essendon the game against us and was replayed so often. Quite like Hird overall though.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment-
Freo. No doubt.

5. Whats your fav win not including finals-
117 point win over Fremantle was pretty special

6. Fav win including finals of all time-
2006 Premiership, no contest.

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time-
Would never hate an Eagle but Fletcher has become really frustrating over the last couple of years, especially considering he was an All australian in the past.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time -
Jeff Farmer.

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations -
Not sure his expectations were ever really too high, but always loved Josh Wooden and his god like good looks.

10. Fav player not WCE of all time -
Probably Voss. Legend.

 

[eagles rule]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
Natinui 3 goals in the last quarter against Hawks

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Chris Judd abandoning the ship

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
Dale Kickett `s brainsnap in the derby

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment- Carltank

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- 55 point comback against Geelong at skilled in 2006 season yeah this one.

6. Fav win including finals of all time-Besides the 2006 G/F It was against Sydney 2005 2nd semi final in perth

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time- PASS

8. Most hated player from another club of all time-
Akermanis mainly for accusing Braun of using perf drugs

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations- would be Ash Sampi- David Antonowics-David Haynes

10. Fav player not WCE of all time- on) James Hird

 

[WCE Ebert #18]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
Chick's tackle, smother, handball and shepard to hunter in the 06 GF. Still brings a tear to my eye.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Moments in the 05 GF where players stuffed up, such as Staker and Gardiner.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
Leo Barry's mark in the 05 GF.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment-
Freo. Always has been and always will.

5. Whats your fav win not including finals-
The comeback against Geelong in 2006 at Skilled.

6. Fav win including finals of all time-
Obviously the 06 GF, but every time we win a final i am rather happy

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time-
Probably Fletcher.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time-
Mostly Freo twats, such as Headland, Farmer, Carr (2x), Solomon, Crowley... etc.

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations-
McDougall

10. Fav player not WCE of all time-
Swan and Bartel.

 

[Emerald]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history - I didn't appreciate it at the time, I was five, but Peter Matera 'sets sail for home' gives me shivers now.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE - On the field Gardy's 2005 GF efforts, off the field Ben Cousins running from the booze bus.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE - Barry Hall KO'ing Brent Staker, ties with Danny Southern choking Peter Sumich. Both vicious, unsportsmanlike acts.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment - Carlton

5. Whats your fav win not including finals - The come back at Kardinia, also the win against Carlton at Optus Oval in 2002 I remember quite well.

6. Fav win including finals of all time - The qualifying final in 2005, I know there were better 'wins' but that moment, that atmosphere was just electric and I lost my voice for 3 days afterwards. It was also the first final I'd ever been to.

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time - I hate what Chris Judd did to us; he is also very smug. No love.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time - Tony Liberatore

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations - I always really liked Kane Munro and he literally NEVER made it.

10. Fav player not WCE of all time - Michael Voss

 

[Eagle Ant]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history- 1992 GF :Matera sets sail for home and the Eagles have hit the front.........That whole game was awesome

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE- Every time RoJo had a set shot at Goal, was always gonna miss.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE- 1991 GF bad day.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment- Collingwood

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- their is a lot and as the geelong game has been metioned already I will go with Hawks from this season, Beat the reigning premiers, Naitanui starrred, young blokes stood up.

6. Fav win including finals of all time- 1992 GF the first will always be the best, and I was in melbourne at the time.

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time- Micheal Gardiner total Tosser.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time- would be Jeff Farmer

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations- Brad Smith: God how good could he have been for us...

10. Fav player not WCE of all time- Micheal Voss

11. Fav WCE player of all time: Ive got 3, 1 from each era.
90s- Woosha
<<< 2007- Chicky
2005 >> Beau Waters.

 

[Adam Selwood]

Good thread mate

West Coast Eagles Questionnaire
1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history
Peter Matera 7 goals against Essendon on Friday night 1998. Malthouse threw him forward after Phil went off injured

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE
Benny Cousins doing his hammy against Port in the QF in 2007. Cost us the game

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE
Leo Barry's mark, James Hird's goal when he hugged the spectator

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment
Failmantle or St Kilda. Essendon close behind

5. Whats your fav win not including finals
Probably when we thrashed Brisbane up at the GABBA in 03 or 04. When Judd went nuts with 5 goals.

6. Fav win including finals of all time
06 GF

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time
No one really springs to mind. Maybe Judd just cos I'm bitter still

8. Most hated player from another club of all time
James Hird, Des Headland, Pavlich, Chad Cornes, Jeff Farmer, few other flogs from Failmantle

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations
Andrew Donnelly

10. Fav player not WCE of all time
Scott Pendlebury

 

[Quinz]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history
'O'Keefe ducks the head! Kick smothered.... Chick! HUNTER!!!' The umtimate 1%er on the most important day of the year.

'Judd, couldn't do it again could he? Five in a half I think so... I think so!' The real beginning of an incredible player, against the reigning premiers at home.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE
Michael Gardiner 05 GF And the Ben Cousins hamstring in 07 that signalled the end of our season.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE
Hird kick that goal, as he always did against us, amazing game though. And the Leo Barry mark of course, two moments that will constantly be replayed.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment
All of them, especially Port, but especially Carlton.

5. Whats your fav win not including finals
- The Judd 5 goal game
- The Geelong 54 point comeback
- The Carlton 44 point comeback
- Sydney games in 2006 and 2007, both close wins
- The Hawthorn game two weeks ago

6. Fav win including finals of all time
2006 Grand Final, and the 05 QF because I was at that one.

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time
No one

8. Most hated player from another club of all time
Milne, Farmer, Headland, Chad Cornes, Mooney

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations
Chipper Adkins

10. Fav player not WCE of all time
Judd , actually probably Michael Voss.

 

[GOEAGLES 08]

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- 55 point comback against Geelong at skilled in 2006 season

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- 55 point comback against Geelong at skilled in 2006 season

it was 54 points guys

 

[Ochre]

55 sounds better

 

[billyboy 21]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history -The Chick and Hunter combo for goal.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE - Cousins ripping his hammy in 07

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE - Lucas going off in Q4 rd 22 07. Cost us the percentage to keep the home game.

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment - Will always be freo. "yeah but who won the derby." Ill take the cup every time.

5. Whats your fav win not including finals - The comeback at the cattery

6. Fav win including finals of all time - 92 grand final. As an 11 year old in Bunbury walking down one of the main streets half hour after the game and not a person in sight. It was like the whole town stopped for the game.

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time - Richard Taylor

8. Most hated player from another club of all time - Milne, I swear he only plays good against us. Didak and Josh Carr

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations - Michael Collica

10. Fav player not WCE of all time - Richo easily

 

[Snooperclyde]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
When Scott Cummings kick 14 goals in one game against Adelaide back in 1999- I still remember even if others don't.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Micheal Gardiners miss shot at goal, straight in front in 2005 grand final.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
Micheal O goal against us in the Qualifing final of 2006

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment- Hawthorn

5. Whats your fav win not including finals- 55 point comback against Geelong at skilled in 2006 season

6. Fav win including finals of all time- against Adeliade 2006 prem final

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time- would be Ben Cousins from 2006 onwards- became very annoying and frustrating.

8. Most hated player from another club of all time- would be Jeff Farmer,
J Hird,

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations- would be Ash Sampi- had so much potential,

10. Fav player not WCE of all time- A Kouta (Carlton), G Ablett senior

Never diss James Hird

 

[Snooperclyde]

1. Whats your fav individual player moment in history-
That Judd game vs Brisbane. I didnt know if he was going to stop kicking goals that game.

2. Whats your most hated individual player moment in history WCE-
Something Chad Fletcher, i do not understand why he still is employed.

3. Whats your most hated player individual moment not WCE-
That mark. Leo Barry

4. Whats your most hated club opposition at the moment-
St Kilda

5. Whats your fav win not including finals-
55 point Geelong comeback

6. Fav win including finals of all time-
That 2006 flag. Although that Adelaide game was amazing

7. Most hated player for WCE of all time-
Chadwick Fletcher

8. Most hated player from another club of all time-
Way too many, hated Hird, hated Farmer, hate Cornes, theres lots

9. Player that you liked that never lived up to expectations
Ash Sampi, Trav Gasper, Andrew McDougall, Brad Smith

10. Fav player not WCE of all time-
Gary Ablett Jnr

Yes, yes, yes. suck all you Geelong supporters old enough to remember.