What do you think of this trade?

[Brahma Bull]

Ive posted this trade afew times already in different boards.

Coll lose: First round pick, N.Brown, Didak, *
Coll gain: Judd

WCE lose: Judd
WCE gainick 5, pick 14-17, N.Brown/ ben reid, *

WB loseick 5
WB gain:McGregor/Hudson, pick 10

Adel lose: Pick 10, McGregor/Hudson
Adel gain: Didak


*Pies may need to give another play to WCE


I would like to know your thoughts/any suggestions etc.

 

[jenny61_99]

Ive posted this trade afew times already in different boards.

Coll lose: First round pick, N.Brown, Didak, *
Coll gain: Judd

WCE lose: Judd
WCE gainick 5, pick 14-17, N.Brown/ ben reid, *

WB loseick 5
WB gain:McGregor/Hudson, pick 10

Adel lose: Pick 10, McGregor/Hudson
Adel gain: Didak


*Pies may need to give another play to WCE


I would like to know your thoughts/any suggestions etc.

So we lose pick 10 AND McGregor AND Hudson for Didak?????


You can't be serious!

 

[AndrewJo]

Ive posted this trade afew times already in different boards.

Coll lose: First round pick, N.Brown, Didak, *
Coll gain: Judd

WCE lose: Judd
WCE gainick 5, pick 14-17, N.Brown/ ben reid, *

WB loseick 5
WB gain:McGregor/Hudson, pick 10

Adel lose: Pick 10, McGregor/Hudson
Adel gain: Didak


*Pies may need to give another play to WCE


I would like to know your thoughts/any suggestions etc.

No chance doing that with Adelaide. Lose 2 players and Pick 10 for Didak....Nope

 

[Gets!]

No means McGregor or Hudson...I think.

 

[porpouglas]

Adel lose: Pick 10, McGregor/Hudson
Adel gain: Didak

You're takin the p*#s surely!!

 

[Brahma Bull]

No i mean you lose McGregor OR Hudson, not both

 

[jenny61_99]

No i mean you lose McGregor OR Hudson, not both

A good player (Huddo) and a first round pick for a good player. Hmmm. Nope, have to pass thanks.

 

[porpouglas]

No i mean you lose McGregor OR Hudson, not both

Still too much - Didak for Huddo straight swap or Huddo and a later pick maybe

Edit: "Just saw Didak's goal in the 2nd half of the prelim, I've changed my mind now."

 

[The Crows Truth]

Ive posted this trade afew times already in different boards.

Coll lose: First round pick, N.Brown, Didak, *
Coll gain: Judd

WCE lose: Judd
WCE gainick 5, pick 14-17, N.Brown/ ben reid, *

WB loseick 5
WB gain:McGregor/Hudson, pick 10

Adel lose: Pick 10, McGregor/Hudson
Adel gain: Didak


*Pies may need to give another play to WCE


I would like to know your thoughts/any suggestions etc.

seems pretty reasonable from a crows perspective - i would do it

 

[earlsta]

Ive posted this trade afew times already in different boards.

Coll lose: First round pick, N.Brown, Didak, *
Coll gain: Judd

WCE lose: Judd
WCE gainick 5, pick 14-17, N.Brown/ ben reid, *

WB loseick 5
WB gain:McGregor/Hudson, pick 10

Adel lose: Pick 10, McGregor/Hudson
Adel gain: Didak


*Pies may need to give another play to WCE


I would like to know your thoughts/any suggestions etc.

Nathan Brown from the Superdraft of 2006? Twin brother at West coast?

I'm pretty sure your not allowed to trade 1st year players, hence they are all signed on two year contracts in their first AFL season.

Same with Ben Reid, your absolutely nuts if your planning on giving away Reid or Brown, they're going to be absolute guns, especially Reid.

He's the youngest in the AFL, and a KPP and has already played a few games, not bad for a guy that turned 18 in april or something this year.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Nathan Brown from the Superdraft of 2006? Twin brother at West coast?

I'm pretty sure your not allowed to trade 1st year players, hence they are all signed on two year contracts in their first AFL season.

Same with Ben Reid, your absolutely nuts if your planning on giving away Reid or Brown, they're going to be absolute guns, especially Reid.

He's the youngest in the AFL, and a KPP and has already played a few games, not bad for a guy that turned 18 in april or something this year.

You CAN trade 1st year players. Ben Finnin ring a bell?

 

[Mismatched]

Sounds alright, but from a crows perspective would want more than just Didak for a McGregor/Hudson and a first round draft pick, maybe Didak and a later draft pick eg 2nd or 3rd round, however, I think the crows are desperate for that number 5 pick to get Brad Ebert and will definitely want atleast 1 first round draft pick.

 

[cleveland]

We will not be touching our first round draft pick

 

[CarnCrows]

Ive posted this trade afew times already in different boards.

Coll lose: First round pick, N.Brown, Didak, *
Coll gain: Judd

WCE lose: Judd
WCE gainick 5, pick 14-17, N.Brown/ ben reid, *

WB loseick 5
WB gain:McGregor/Hudson, pick 10

Adel lose: Pick 10, McGregor/Hudson
Adel gain: Didak


*Pies may need to give another play to WCE


I would like to know your thoughts/any suggestions etc.

Adelaide would love this deal.

Seriously if you need pick 5 just go straight to the source. Cloak for pick 5. WBD would like that.

 

[relapse]

Adel lose: Pick 10, McGregor/Hudson
Adel gain: Didak

You're takin the p*#s surely!!

Take out the pick 10 and make it our 2nd round pick and you might have a deal.

 

[MickyCrow]

We will not be touching our first round draft pick

We will see come trde week

 

[timaah]

We will not be touching our first round draft pick

The bulldogs are the biggest winner by far here. The get two players, and they are two players who would be starting 18 easily for 3-4 years for just a downgrade in first round picks 5 to 10. Where the straight deal between us and the bulldogs is strongly rumored to be hudson and mcgregor for pick 5, and mcmahan (plus tiller even). Ridiculous trade suggestion.

 

[crowsarethebest]

IMO its pretty fair for the Weagles, Collingwood get their but kicked, Doggies win slightly and we get away with a very very good deal.

 

[johnnypanther]

Didak for pick 10 plus Hudson or McGregor

i would sign this deal anyday

 

[cocka]

No i mean you lose McGregor OR Hudson, not both

Didak for pick 10 and Hudson, or Didak for pick 10 and McGregor, done deal in a heartbeat! I'd even let Collingwood take their pick.

 

[Slick Dog Johnson]

So we lose pick 10 AND McGregor AND Hudson for Didak?????


You can't be serious!

LOL. Can you actually read or what?

Theres a big '/' between Hudson and McGregor which means 'OR'.

I don't think the trade is too far fetched BTW.

 

[crowgirl]

Adel lose: Pick 10, McGregor/Hudson
Adel gain: Didak


*Pies may need to give another play to WCE


I would like to know your thoughts/any suggestions etc.

I like the sound of that!