Remove this Banner Ad

What to do with Garlett and Lucas?

  • Thread starter Thread starter chipzac
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

chipzac

Club Legend
Joined
Jan 10, 2011
Posts
1,589
Reaction score
2,741
AFL Club
Carlton
Like everyone here, I hope we recruit the best possible talent from the draft (or from other clubs), but I'm not sure about what we are doing to develop, support and keep the talent we have at the club. I'm sure we are going to great lengths to find and recruit new talent but I think we should be working just as hard to assist and maintain the players we already have, too.

There are differing opinions on our handling of past players such as Jacobs, Betts and Laidler and whether they could/should have remained at the club, and what we should do with current players like Watson, Garlett and Lucas. The last two in particular seem like they have hit a brick wall and are going nowhere. Both have shown they can (or could) play AFL and both have (deservedly) been relegated to the VFL, but is the club doing enough in trying to help them resurrect their careers?

It may be that both players have attitude problems, and if so, I hope we are doing more than just 'plonking' them in the Northern Blues and telling them to get their acts together. I think both Buckley and Yarran had at one stage struggled with consistency and their defensive games until they were given defensive roles, so I'm wondering whether that is one thing that could be tried with these two as that seems to be one aspect of their games that is lacking?

Maybe their AFL days are over, but I just hope they are being offered plenty of support and that we are exploring every avenue before they leave the club. Talent is not so easily come by so it shouldn't be dispensed with without us knowing that we tried everything we could.
 
I wouldn't delist either of those players, but if we can get a fair trade for Lucas I'd be ok with it. Garlett I still hold out hope for that we can overcome his personal issues and he can make a Yarran-like resurgence.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Happy to keep Jeffy G, keep Watson he has been good up forward he is a ripper kick

Ditch Lucas
 
Keep Jeffy if he wants to stay.

He's worth more to us than what others will offer.
 
This just makes me sad. I hate getting rid of players. I hope Jeffy gets to stay but only if he wants to. I am happy for Watto to stay as he hasn't had a chance to prove himself at either end of the ground.
 
Can we lay off the smart-arse "list clogger" and "bury" cracks? The bloke's did their best to make it, no-one's fault they struggled.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Can we lay off the smart-arse "list clogger" and "bury" cracks? The bloke's did their best to make it, no-one's fault they struggled.

Don't get too precious, these blokes are getting 200k for not being very good at their job.

3rd year plumber, no matter how good, is on what, 40k.
 
To be honest I've been surprised at how quick the (BF) supporter base have given up on Garlett. Talk of effectively giving him away/using him as steak knives is crazy. Not to be disrespectful but if Ellard can manage to remain on the list for 6 years, Jefferey has more than earned himself another season - he is far from finished.
 
All over for both. Lucas' papers were stamped in front of plenty of witnesses quite some time ago. Shame we'll be selling both at their least valuable point.
 
I've just been saying in the trade thread, maybe we could package them together to maximize their value and ask for a second rounder. I could see them both playing good footy under someone like Ross Lyon.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom