What would it take..?

[Cerpin Taxt]

To get pick 2 off you, assuming we have pick 3?

I know it's a difficult question to answer without knowing what Miller is thinking, but give it a shot.

I think we'll accept 3, 20, and Kennedy for Judd (because I can't see a better deal being offered). We also really really want Cotchin. I gather you guys are also keen on him, but also lookign quite seriously at Cale Morton.

If we can secure #3, would #3 and M.Morton for #2 do it? I honestly have no idea. If you're after C.Morton then it probably would, but otherwise we might have to offer pick 13?

 

[banzai]

To get pick 2 off you, assuming we have pick 3?

I know it's a difficult question to answer without knowing what Miller is thinking, but give it a shot.

I think we'll accept 3, 20, and Kennedy for Judd (because I can't see a better deal being offered). We also really really want Cotchin. I gather you guys are also keen on him, but also lookign quite seriously at Cale Morton.

If we can secure #3, would #3 and M.Morton for #2 do it? I honestly have no idea. If you're after C.Morton then it probably would, but otherwise we might have to offer pick 13?

It depends on who Miller and co want to draft. If we are very keen on Cotchin i doubt you will be able to get pick 2 at all (im sure Cox + 3 would do it though). If we are going to take Morton anyway then we may as well take M Morton and 3 as we are getting him for free then.

 

[CoggaRules]

To get pick 2 off you, assuming we have pick 3?

I know it's a difficult question to answer without knowing what Miller is thinking, but give it a shot.

I think we'll accept 3, 20, and Kennedy for Judd (because I can't see a better deal being offered). We also really really want Cotchin. I gather you guys are also keen on him, but also lookign quite seriously at Cale Morton.

If we can secure #3, would #3 and M.Morton for #2 do it? I honestly have no idea. If you're after C.Morton then it probably would, but otherwise we might have to offer pick 13?

priddis and pick 3.

 

[_RT_]

To get pick 2 off you, assuming we have pick 3?

I know it's a difficult question to answer without knowing what Miller is thinking, but give it a shot.

I think we'll accept 3, 20, and Kennedy for Judd (because I can't see a better deal being offered). We also really really want Cotchin. I gather you guys are also keen on him, but also lookign quite seriously at Cale Morton.

If we can secure #3, would #3 and M.Morton for #2 do it? I honestly have no idea. If you're after C.Morton then it probably would, but otherwise we might have to offer pick 13?

Either M.Brown or Priddis and M.Morton plus pick 3 assuming we are set on picking Cale.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

Its bound to fall flat on our faces if we drop 1 pick back, I can see it all now. #3 will be a dud, #2 a superstar. The trade has to be very much tipped to our side (I hope) if we are to drop back 1 place so early in the draft.

 

[Yellow n Black]

priddis and mitch morton and pick 3 for pick 2 then we'll do a dodgy n pick up cotchin anyway...hAhAhA

 

[Cerpin Taxt]

Are you guys deadly serious? Priddis, Morton and Pick 3, for Pick 2?

 

[Tetley Tigers]

Why would Richmond swap pick 2 for pick 3 - that doesn't make sense?!? With Richmond having pick 2 they can take any player - draft pick 67 if they want. Having the number 2 pick gets Richmond 2nd crack at the total draft list, not the 2nd ranked player in the draft.

 

[Cerpin Taxt]

Thanks for that magnificent insight on the number line.

 

[TFLUA-Tiger]

Mitch Morton and #3 would be sufficient

 

[TimeFor11]

Well knowing Kennedy has said he doesnt want to go to WCE because of lack of oppurtunity he can come with that #3 for the #2 as he'd happily be our CHF. I think that every Richmond person would be relatively happy with that.

We'd then get Cale with #3 and Mitch in the PSD.

 

[Bojangles17]

Mitch Morton and #3 would be sufficient

$^$#sh_t it would, he's a risk , having done nothing in 3 years...at best we'd offer 18/19 given he was so highly rated....To drop from 2 to 3 for a risky 21 , nice try but NO THANKS

 

[parrot]

To get pick 2 off you, assuming we have pick 3?

I know it's a difficult question to answer without knowing what Miller is thinking, but give it a shot.

I think we'll accept 3, 20, and Kennedy for Judd (because I can't see a better deal being offered). We also really really want Cotchin. I gather you guys are also keen on him, but also lookign quite seriously at Cale Morton.

If we can secure #3, would #3 and M.Morton for #2 do it? I honestly have no idea. If you're after C.Morton then it probably would, but otherwise we might have to offer pick 13?

The Blues have decided to only give the Weagles pick #3 now. Kennedy and pick #20 are off the table. Pick #1 and Fev were always off the table.

 

[parrot]

The real issue is what Club Judd wants to go to.Doesn't matter who offers what, if Judd doesn't go there the deal won't happen. He has ruled out:

1. Collingwood. Wasn't impressed with Eddie apparently. And now Eddie has been attacking Judd publically, so we can cross the Pies off the list.

2. Dons. Didn't even have a coach when h saw them, and Matty Lloyd seemed to in charge of list management, because of distraction with internal infighting. So cross them off the list

3. Dees. They didn't have any training facilities. A small backward Club. Cross them off

4. Tiges. Not sure exactly why, but Judd has refused to even talk to these guys despite repeated request from Miller and co.

 

[emperor]

The real issue is what Club Judd wants to go to.Doesn't matter who offers what, if Judd doesn't go there the deal won't happen. He has ruled out:

1. Collingwood. Wasn't impressed with Eddie apparently. And now Eddie has been attacking Judd publically, so we can cross the Pies off the list.

2. Dons. Didn't even have a coach when h saw them, and Matty Lloyd seemed to in charge of list management, because of distraction with internal infighting. So cross them off the list

3. Dees. They didn't have any training facilities. A small backward Club. Cross them off

4. Tiges. Not sure exactly why, but Judd has refused to even talk to these guys despite repeated request from Miller and co.

that leaves only Carlton with whom West Coast are seemingly becoming less and less accomodating but if carlton are playing hardball and west coast aren't going to come to the party, I hope GM isnt cooking up any unncessary trades when PSD could be our best friend

 

[IDGAF]

Correct me if i`m wrong ... but as Rodan was taken in the National draft last year , whats to say Judd can`t put himself in the national draft thus only costing the Blues thier first pick ?

When i heard West Coast say they wanted pix 1 -3 and 20 ... i could not help but think of this scenario

 

[hudson22]

4. Tiges. Not sure exactly why, but Judd has refused to even talk to these guys despite repeated request from Miller and co.

can someone fill me in on when Judd refused to talk to us, i was under the impression we never sought a meeting with him either????

 

[hotdogandsauce]

The real issue is what Club Judd wants to go to.Doesn't matter who offers what, if Judd doesn't go there the deal won't happen. He has ruled out:

1. Collingwood. Wasn't impressed with Eddie apparently. And now Eddie has been attacking Judd publically, so we can cross the Pies off the list.

2. Dons. Didn't even have a coach when h saw them, and Matty Lloyd seemed to in charge of list management, because of distraction with internal infighting. So cross them off the list

3. Dees. They didn't have any training facilities. A small backward Club. Cross them off

4. Tiges. Not sure exactly why, but Judd has refused to even talk to these guys despite repeated request from Miller and co.

keep trotting out the "repeated requests"...it didnt/hasnt happened...FACT...we dont have to because you guys are gonna stuff it up all by yourselves anyway...

 

[hotdogandsauce]

can someone fill me in on when Judd refused to talk to us, i was under the impression we never sought a meeting with him either????

we havent...Parrot just keeps chipping away....much like the bloos thinking we cant afford Judd...more fools them....

now how good is this Swan bloke they keep talking about bloosland...look at his past history not much of a story to tell there...go ask Eddie...

 

[hotdogandsauce]

that leaves only Carlton with whom West Coast are seemingly becoming less and less accomodating but if carlton are playing hardball and west coast aren't going to come to the party, I hope GM isnt cooking up any unncessary trades when PSD could be our best friend

we dont have to do anything...thats why we havent contacted Judd or Connors....just quietly go about our business....we have had at least 3 meetings with Westcoast over the last 2 months....

 

[parrot]

keep trotting out the "repeated requests"...it didnt/hasnt happened...FACT...we dont have to because you guys are gonna stuff it up all by yourselves anyway...

There were at least 3 separate reports of Miller contacting Judds management last week alone. God knows how many times he's been calling him. Judd still hasn't met with the Tiges for whatever reason. The Tiges are the only Club that can beat the Blues picks. Draw your own conclusions as to why the meeting hasn't happened. Seems a bit strange that the Tiges are publically saying that they're extremely keen to get Judd if the Blues can't strike an agreement with Weaglland, BUT THE TIGERS ARE STILL TO MEET JUDD! All this talk about the Tiges getting Judd has been between Miller and the Weagleland CEO but not Judd! . Doesn't it strike you as just a little strange.

 

[hotdogandsauce]

There were at least 3 separate reports of Miller contacting Judds management last week alone. God knows how many times he's been calling him. Judd still hasn't met with the Tiges for whatever reason. The Tiges are the only Club that can beat the Blues picks. Draw your own conclusions as to why the meeting hasn't happened. Seems a bit strange that the Tiges are publically saying that they're extremely keen to get Judd if the Blues can't strike an agreement with Weaglland, BUT THE TIGERS ARE STILL TO MEET JUDD! All this talk about the Tiges getting Judd has been between Miller and the Weagleland CEO but not Judd! . Doesn't it strike you as just a little strange.

wrong again on all counts.....you are a funny one...lol...where are you getting these so-called reports about miller trying to contact Judd? (link would be nice)...

i reckon nesbitt and miller are playing the game a bit better than your mate Swan a.t.m.

perhaps the bloos should have sat on Judd wanting to come to them and pick 1 was wasnt on the table...because perhaps just perhaps you might end up losing one or the other...

personally dont want Judd...but just am not liking the assasination of our football club by bloos suppoters thinking they are the ducks guts...

 

[hudson22]

There were at least 3 separate reports of Miller contacting Judds management last week alone. God knows how many times he's been calling him. Judd still hasn't met with the Tiges for whatever reason. The Tiges are the only Club that can beat the Blues picks. Draw your own conclusions as to why the meeting hasn't happened. Seems a bit strange that the Tiges are publically saying that they're extremely keen to get Judd if the Blues can't strike an agreement with Weaglland, BUT THE TIGERS ARE STILL TO MEET JUDD! All this talk about the Tiges getting Judd has been between Miller and the Weagleland CEO but not Judd! . Doesn't it strike you as just a little strange.

once again can u remind me or give me a link to where Miller or any1 else said they were extremely keen to get judd??? do u keep making things up or have i been living under a rock?

 

[Heisenberg_]

Correct me if i`m wrong ... but as Rodan was taken in the National draft last year , whats to say Judd can`t put himself in the national draft thus only costing the Blues thier first pick ?

When i heard West Coast say they wanted pix 1 -3 and 20 ... i could not help but think of this scenario

Rodan was in the draft because he was delisted.
PSD is for out of contract players, and players who were overlooked in the national draft.
The national draft is open to kids and delisted players