Whats Your Decision

[_RT_]

With the Pies and Tigers both showing fairly poor Pre Season form. I think the Pies have been a little worse than the Tigers. I thought I would pose this question.

Who Will Finish Higher?

 

[demonandy]

I think both teams will finish lower than they did in 06.
But Collingwood has a better list - more established senior players and youngsters who have already taken the next step (H Shaw, Swan)

Richmond's young guns (like Foley/Tambling/Meyer) will need another year I think

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Pies will vie for the eight, Richmond won't.

Just my opinion.

 

[_RT_]

Finally the Tigers are winning a poll

 

[lids2004roar]

Sydney and Brisbane had **** pre seasons then went on to win premierships.

We are primed to get better as the season goes on, that's all

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

I'm quite happy for most to have us as a bottom 4 team...

It will mean that the season is a surprise for those people.

 

[Rocky Rambo]

With the Pies and Tigers both showing fairly poor Pre Season form. I think the Pies have been a little worse than the Tigers. I thought I would pose this question.

Who Will Finish Higher?

Pre Season form means jack crap.

 

[lids2004roar]

I'm quite happy for most to have us as a bottom 4 team...

It will mean that the season is a surprise for those people.

Yep.

Plus it's funny how everyone says "if you do good in pre season in doesn't mean you'll do good in the real season" yet if you do badly pre season they think you're destined to fail

Apparently you will probably do badly in the real season no matter if you win or lose pre season.


I'd so laugh if it were a Richmond Collingwood Grand Final

 

[_RT_]

I'm quite happy for most to have us as a bottom 4 team...

It will mean that the season is a surprise for those people.

Pre Season form means jack crap.

Didn't say we would be fighting it out for bottom 4 just that neither sides forms this pre season has inspired the masses with a lot of confidence in our sides likely outcomes for the year. In fact I think both will be there abouts for the bottom half of the 8.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Didn't say we would be fighting it out for bottom 4 just that neither sides forms this pre season has inspired the masses with a lot of confidence in our sides likely outcomes for the year. In fact I think both will be there abouts for the bottom half of the 8.

It's simple logic - Since most people think that Richmond won't play finals, and evidently, as they're winning this poll, they think that Collingwood will finish below Richmond, it means that these people have Collingwood picked to be around the bottom 4.

I find it unlikely.