Opinion Where do Gawn, Petracca, and Oliver rank in our all-time greats?

[Topkent]

All 3 are easily in the 22 if you were to select the best ever side of MFC players past & present.

Stynes and Gawn would be an interesting ruck combination.

Hard to say easily when you have no idea about the dominant Melbourne sides of the pre 70s. If you wanna say 1970 and after then sure

 

[Dory_77]

Hard to compare across generations. I've only been watching since late 90's so both would comfortably make top 5 of who I've watched in terms of overall best players. Maybe Neitz, Jones or Yze in there too.

I did love watching Flash, Robbo, Jurrah and even blokes like Bugg being a pest. Would probably have them as more fun to see, albeit less consistently good.