Where will St. Kilda finish this year?

[StFly]

Exactly, role reverse, instea dof us playing the eventual premiers into form, they can play us into form and we can then listen as to their excuses why they couldn't overcome little old lowly us.

Also, not sure about tanking, might have mad Monday on the day before their finals campaign though "yeah we made finals, lets go out and get blotto! Woo successful season!" rock up to game drunk, lose horribly "yeah we made finals, lets go out and get blotto! Woo successful season!"

 

[Plugger35]

A2R, I'm not entirely convinced on either. My gut tells me Collingwood rather than Carlton OR Richmond, but the Tigers looked a little ordinary against Collingwood, and I don't trust Wallace any more, and I was once one of his biggest fans. Although I like some of Richmond's pick ups (Cousins, Nahas, Thomson, the bloke from Essendon). I just think Judd and Fevola are going to have big years, they have a really good collection of small and medium sized defenders, and they remind me a bit of us in 2004.

The problem for Carlton is that they are still very reliant on a handful of star players, if either Judd or Fevola went down with a long term injury they would be bottom 4 candidates again. Also their defence is still pretty suspect.

I think teams like Collingwood and Richmond have a much more even spread of talent and both should be genuine finals contenders this year. I thought Richmond were very impressive at times last year and now they have added Cousins that should be enough to push them into the top 8. I'd also much rather see Richmond playing finals than either Carlton or Collingwood.

 

[IllBeTheJudge]

Their defence is still pretty suspect.

I'd also much rather see Richmond playing finals than either Carlton or Collingwood.

Edited slightly , but I second that motion.
Hearing the commentators in the Blues last game, they were all over Thornton as if they were presented with Scarlet Johansson and a giant honey-pot.

Blues defence; suspect
Richmond play finals for the 2nd time in ages; I'd like to see that

 

[CHBench]

Richmond play finals for the 2nd time in ages; I'd like to see that

Deow neow nenene neow newo neow neow neow nenene neow neow neow.

[YOUTUBE]kqVk9qvyeoM[/YOUTUBE]

 

[IllBeTheJudge]

Deow neow nenene neow newo neow neow neow nenene neow neow neow.

[YOUTUBE]kqVk9qvyeoM[/YOUTUBE]

unbelievable

 

[dg102]

Saints to win the minor premiership.... Id like to see that!

Geelong wont win the minor this year. They will loose more games this year. Carlton will win alot of games this year, maybe top 4. Sydney, Collingwood, Adelaide to drop out of 8.
Anyway thats my tips. I see alot of StKilda circa 2004 in Carlton this year.

 

[Sir Robert]

Saints to win the minor premiership.... Id like to see that!

Geelong wont win the minor this year. They will loose more games this year. Carlton will win alot of games this year, maybe top 4. Sydney, Collingwood, Adelaide to drop out of 8.
Anyway thats my tips. I see alot of StKilda circa 2004 in Carlton this year.

Kildanon will red card you for that comparison

I for one hope Carlton finish 9th - just high enough for them not to get the creme of the crop again - probably wishful thinking tho.