Which would you prefer?

[Beats]

It's unlikely to happen at this point and is not guaranteed that if it does happen, that Melbourne would have been in the same position... but GWS are a possibility to trade early picks for Kurt Tippett, quite possibly picks 3 & 13. (https://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/149727/default.aspx)-

GREATER Western Sydney dominates trade talk on Tuesday morning, with newspapers across Australia reporting they are prepared to part with early NAB AFL Draft picks to secure a star player.

So in a world where Tippett wouldn't have said no to coming to us which would you prefer, Kurt Tippett or Hogan/ Barry/ Pick 20?

 

[Demon 16]

Hogan is obviously going to be the greatest centre half forward of all time, and Barry is the next McLeod.

Easy decision.

 

[syl]

Kurt Tippett doesn't want to live in Melbourne and is incredibly overrated.

Would take Hogan/Barry/Dawes any day.

 

[Bluelegs]

Hope they do. Will leave either Wines or Toumpas for us.

 

[BigSexc]

Hope they do. Will leave either Wines or Toumpas for us.

Explain why you made that statement?

I'm pretty sure one of them will be there regardless.

Even if pick 3 gets traded, another club still gets to use it, it doesn't just disappear.

 

[Carusiii]

Explain why you made that statement?

I'm pretty sure one of them will be there regardless.

Even if pick 3 gets traded, another club still gets to use it, it doesn't just disappear.

I think he means you then probably see grundy taken in the top 3?

 

[SuburbanMe]

Kirk Tippett Seems like a total jerk off, So whateverrrrrr.

Much prefer what we have over tippett.

 

[Supermercado]

If if we could take out a draft insurance policy on his egg shell skull.

 

[00Stinger]

Kurt Tippett doesn't want to live in Melbourne and is incredibly overrated.

Would take Hogan/Barry/Dawes any day.

You didn't bother to read this?

So in a world where Tippett wouldn't have said no to coming to us

or you just thought you would rehash something the OP has already stated?

 

[syl]

You didn't bother to read this?


or you just thought you would rehash something the OP has already stated?

I read it. It's just a stupid premise - he has stated he is not coming to Melbourne, who gives a **** about him?! He is overrated to boot.

 

[BigSexc]

I think he means you then probably see grundy taken in the top 3?

will most likely be taken there anyway

 

[Bluelegs]

Explain why you made that statement?

I'm pretty sure one of them will be there regardless.

Even if pick 3 gets traded, another club still gets to use it, it doesn't just disappear.

I was just saying that there was the possibility of them taking both. Reckon Adelaide would go for Grundy.

 

[Marlowe]

The Hulk, brother. Screw massive head wound Kurt.

 

[Wonaeamirri33]

Vive la Hulk!

 

[deeman87]

Can we choose the option where we still have picks 3 and 13? Although i do love me some Hulk.

 

[demon_dynasty13]

Im amazed how overrated Tippett is.

Has zero leadershp ability, little physical presence and is a couple of concussions away from serious questions about his playing career continuing.

The Swans supporters I know are hoping that GWS get him, cos they dont want him at the Swans.

 

[PureFooty]

Played a great Prelim Final, I'm more than satisfied with what we have got so far, and wouldn't trade it for Tippett. But in saying that I think Tippett deserves more on field credit than what he is getting, overrated forwards don't kick 4 goals in prelim finals. Especially considering he could barely string consecutive weeks together in the latter stages of the competition.

 

[Viney]

Im amazed how overrated Tippett is.

Has zero leadershp ability, little physical presence and is a couple of concussions away from serious questions about his playing career continuing.

The Swans supporters I know are hoping that GWS get him, cos they dont want him at the Swans.

As an aside, also a very un-Sydney like thing to do, offering an OOC player $900k odd per season (if thats what's actually being offered)

Would this not potentially cause disharmony to their "model"