Who would you prefer, shaw-obree-williams-or-walker?

[PIE-BOI]

Definatlely not obree or williams there time at collingwood should have been finished last year.
rhyce shaw will have this year to prove he can play well.
walker will be given time bcause there are some good signs by him so he looks good for the future.

 

[browny4PM]

I'd say Williams is the only one of those 4 that doesn't have the potential to improve, or rediscover form.

The other 3 must stay for now. O'bree has the year to prove himself, Shaw has already shown huge improvement to his mental approach and Tex will be given a lot of time and rightfully so.

 

[PIE-BOI]

I'd say Williams is the only one of those 4 that doesn't have the potential to improve, or rediscover form.

The other 3 must stay for now. O'bree has the year to prove himself, Shaw has already shown huge improvement to his mental approach and Tex will be given a lot of time and rightfully so.

well said

 

[leonmagic]

I love Tex.

I've been saying all along that OB and Rhyce will come back, and thus far they have.

Williams.......well I seriously would rather BK.

 

[bradrowe#32]

Shaw, O'bree and Williams have all had a good run. We should be putting in Rowe, B & H Shaw and the other youngsters. We have 8 players on the list that haven't played yet, so put them in if they are ready. We are not going to win a flag with these guys running around.

Tex has improved. I don't know why he has so many detractors.

 

[Murray]

Tex has improved. I don't know why he has so many detractors.

That is relatively simple to answer.

He doesn't know the first thing about how to play football.

 

[grayza]

That is relatively simple to answer.

He doesn't know the first thing about how to play football.

that is true

he kicked that great goal though after dodging grant or darcy or whoever it was....from my spot in the Ponsford it looked pretty good

 

[Cosmic Starchild]

Definatlely not obree or williams there time at collingwood should have been finished last year.
rhyce shaw will have this year to prove he can play well.
walker will be given time bcause there are some good signs by him so he looks good for the future.

Here are four reasons while Collingwood is re-entering another rebuilding phase.

Would any of these guys get a regular game at a top 8 side? Maybe Walker as a project player, but the others are scrapheap material.

6 years down, 2 years up, 6 years down......

 

[Jabso]

Cosmic Starchild sounds like a theatrical dance production where the main character is a young boy coming to grips with his sexuality and comes out of the closet and grows to become the greatest ballet performer the world has seen.

 

[Cosmic Starchild]

Cosmic Starchild sounds like a theatrical dance production where the main character is a young boy coming to grips with his sexuality and comes out of the closet and grows to become the greatest ballet performer the world has seen.

If you're looking for a name for your autobiography, I suggest you take out a patent.