Worst "elite" DT player?

[dont bowl there]

Just a bit of fun and im sure it will spark some arguing which is always nice on a boring work day.

Who do you think is the worst "elite" dream team player in terms of actual football impact. Last year it was without a doubt P.Bowden, this year i am going for C.Bruce. One of the absolute guns of DT but rarely has any impact on AFL games.

 

[Blinger]

H.Scotland would be my choice out of the elite dreamteamers.

 

[dont bowl there]

H.Scotland would be my choice out of the elite dreamteamers.

Very nice choice indeed! Forgot about Scotland.

 

[banana_bus]

H.Scotland would be my choice out of the elite dreamteamers.

heres 2 others to rival him;

dane swan
kane cornes

both absolute utter hacks who never win their own ball. if i had 5 cents for the amount of times ive seen cornes run around the back of a defender to get a cheap kick, i would be on the BRW rich list.

swan seriously has to be the most uninfluential individual in the history of the game.

 

[Kaiser Powser]

Adam Simpson - Mark Thompson admitted that he didn't bother putting an opponent on him because his disposal and impact are so poor.

 

[big_slick]

heres 2 others to rival him;

dane swan
kane cornes

both absolute utter hacks who never win their own ball. if i had 5 cents for the amount of times ive seen cornes run around the back of a defender to get a cheap kick, i would be on the BRW rich list.

swan seriously has to be the most uninfluential individual in the history of the game.

Footy isn't always about going in and getting the hard ball, if every player did it then no-one would be outside of the packs waiting for that handball to then set up the attack. It's a different role and i think it's fairly important.

Sure you do need to go when your time is up but you do need those outside players in your team.

 

[Doza]

Well Lockyer is currently sitting 12th

 

[moose54]

Personally the king of the them all is Cameron Ling... Maybe not a mega elite but he's been up there in the past and he is completly useless. Next time he plays pay attention to what he does with the ball. absoutly nothing.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Heath Scotland and Kane Cornes

Case closed.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

heres 2 others to rival him;

dane swan
kane cornes

both absolute utter hacks who never win their own ball. if i had 5 cents for the amount of times ive seen cornes run around the back of a defender to get a cheap kick, i would be on the BRW rich list.

swan seriously has to be the most uninfluential individual in the history of the game.

Joel Bowden
Patrick Bowden

You have NFI.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

swan seriously has to be the most uninfluential individual in the history of the game.

You ****ing clown.

That award is named after the Bowdens

 

[Juddy88]

Definetely Bowden of the Joel variety
watching the Eagles game he got at least half of his possesions chipping around inside of his defensive 50.
All the Eagles did was create a wall on the wing and let that style just continue for as long as they want and when it was over they just ended up having to bomb most of the time.
A few of his possesions were when he'd kick it to an team mate, they'd mark, and kick back to him straight away.

 

[hawka_fan]

yep the bowden sisters are the winners here

 

[trueblue_91]

Heath Scotland and Kane Cornes

Case closed.

Scotland and K Cornes get the cheapest and possesions. Not even very effective they jsut chip it around themselves

 

[Blue and Gold Blood]

Luke Power, Adam Goodes?

 

[baenzale]

The bowdens are there, lade and fraser would be up there.

 

[Juddy88]

The bowdens are there, lade and fraser would be up there.

Lade??
one of the best tap ruckmen going around
i think not

 

[Juddy88]

Luke Power, Adam Goodes?

LOL dual Brownlow medalist

 

[GoSydneySwans]

Luke Power, Adam Goodes?

Nice one, Goodes is one of the best users of the ball in the game. Admittedly I would've liked him to have been getting the ball a bit more lately, but it doesn't change the fact that he is one of the best players in the league.

Don't watch Brisbane a great deal, but Power isn't that bad at all.

 

[Blue and Gold Blood]

^^ lol, whoops. I misread the thread. I thought it meant the worst DT performers of this year who are guns.

 

[sante]

Dane Swan, easily.

One from left field - Scotty West, he racks them up whether the Dogs win or lose, does he actually impact the game? No...

 

[BarcaRulz]

Bruce no impact? What the hell are you on?

 

[dont bowl there]

Bruce no impact? What the hell are you on?

His disposal is shocking and never hurts the opposition with run. He gets a lot of the ball but does f all with it.

 

[baenzale]

Lade is a good ruck but he aint as good as his dt points sugested last year. He was the second best DT ruck of last year and 5th best player. IMO he aint the second best ruck or the 5th best player. Cox is far far better. I would even say jolly, white, simmons and even brogan are all better. Fraser is the same to.

Another player that is good at DT but usless on the field is Ben Johnson. Kicks choppers.

 

[johncocksasuperstar]

Dane Swan, easily.

One from left field - Scotty West, he racks them up whether the Dogs win or lose, does he actually impact the game? No...

most of scott wests possessions are handballs...he has a shitload of contested possessions. one of the guns of the competition or why the **** would he have been that close to a brownlow like 5 times