- Sep 10, 2010
- 28,939
- 42,098
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Toronto Maple Leafs
Was that a deliberate mis-use of punctuation to highlight a double-entendre?No one is disputing that, but you’re not the captain Josh is.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

BigFooty AFLW Notice Img
AFLW 2025 - AFLW Trade and Draft - All the player moves
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Was that a deliberate mis-use of punctuation to highlight a double-entendre?No one is disputing that, but you’re not the captain Josh is.
It must go back to what is listed in the Squad Submissions which is Josh solely as captain.Dav is not in the Committee and has repeatedly claimed captaincy despite my attempts to dissuade him. If he repeatedly claims captaincy and posts the team as evidence to this effect how can their not be two captains? He said so.
So we should either ban you or Josh?
He most certainly did.But you've also claimed that you are.
Who are we to believe?
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Was that a deliberate mis-use of punctuation to highlight a double-entendre?
But we must, it’s the rules. We know you feel like shit for ****ing up but that is what comes with the territory mate.JWS didn't delegate the responsibility to me, he transferred it. He is not able to post teamsheets at the moment and wouldn't have been able to if we were to make it to the Grand Final. Next season my captaincy would go public, so for all intents and purposes he was completely finished posting them.
So don't punish JWS.
Yes, that's always been the debate lol
YepSo JWS gets suspended?
I'm just saying you can't double dip. The claim that Josh is captain based on the squad submission and the claim that I am captain based on internal decisions and committee appointments are mutually exclusive and are against eachother; that's why I'm having this debate in the first place.
You can't turn around and say "Well Josh is captain in the squad submission and Cadaver is captain based on committee/teamsheet so let's ban both of them" because those two statements contradict one another.
Go away Far Kern.
But we must, it’s the rules. We know you feel like **** for ******* up but that is what comes with the territory mate.
You can’t have your cake and eat it too bro
I tried to convince him otherwise. The evidence of actually posting the team sheet is clear. The evidence of this thread is on the record. It speaks for itself.It must go back to what is listed in the Squad Submissions which is Josh solely as captain.
Are we actually believing for one minute here that JoshWoodenSpoon stepped down as captain of a SFA club going into a Preliminary Final?
I tried to convince him otherwise. The evidence of actually posting the team sheet is clear. The evidence of this thread is on the record. It speaks for itself.
which rock have you been under for the last 6 pages, go away ffs.So we should either ban you or Josh?
which rock have you been under for the last 6 pages, go away ffs.
I am the captain. I know my responsibilities. I would accept the consequences for any indiscretion my team mates made.If you say you wouldn't fight to make sure your captain wasn't suspended for a potential Grand Final because of your own mistake, you'd be lying.
My real opinion is that this should most definitely not be goals against the team. I’ve had great fun with you, but could not care less who gets suspended.I'm just saying you can't double dip. The claim that Josh is captain based on the squad submission and the claim that I am captain based on internal decisions and committee appointments are mutually exclusive and are against eachother; that's why I'm having this debate in the first place.
You can't turn around and say "Well Josh is captain in the squad submission and Cadaver is captain based on committee/teamsheet so let's ban both of them" because those two statements contradict one another.
Go away Far Kern.
No. Joshy is the captain and would have to institute the change in Committee. That may have been an oversight but it didn't happen.
Otherwise rfctiger74 could just claim captain, post a spread sheet and be captain.
I am the captain. I know my responsibilities. I would accept the consequences for any indiscretion my team mates made.
Mate, if Josh was was about he’d say it’s all good. One more time. I think it’s noble you are fighting to protect your captain... fact is you can’t. You’ve made it clear you acknowledge you ****** up but you need to realise you can’t protect your captain from the consequences of your blue no matter how bad you feel. Does that make sense?
Bullshit!! Mt Buller should be declared winners right now and go straight through to the Granny now!!! And have a12 goal head startMy real opinion is that this should most definitely not be goals against the team. I’ve had great fun with you, but could not care less who gets suspended.
The outcome of the game should not be altered by this. Cloud_
But surely you can see how ****ING boring this is for the league? We are sick and tired of the suspended sentences, tip toeing around the crawly bumlick PC, SJW, sooky sooky la la , little babies BS. Cop it on the chin and take your medicine man!!!I understand what you're saying, but until a ruling is made, I'll keep fighting. Mitigating factors can cause the ban to become suspended and I believe I have made it pretty clear the circumstances of this and that it is not a case of the captain being away for a day and delegating it to a LG member.
This should NOT effect the outcome of the game.
It is hilarious and I’ve gone for it, this is what makes the SFA fun.
Cloud_ there should be no match penalty for this in a Prelim. Let them play.