Your favourite dud

[Pedro]

Ross Brewer

He's excused. I remember him winning us a final against Fitzroy yonks ago. Snapped a goal with seconds to go putting us in front. May have even been a Preliminary Final. I was only young, but I remember thinking that he was a star!!

 

[Wymarra #1]

There's been so much talk lately of the Wild's, Richardson's and the like. Who's YOUR favourite dud to ever pull on the black and white stripes?

My top 3:

1. Stephen Ryan
2. Michael Gardiner
3. Ricky Olarenshaw

Special mentions to Brad Fuller, Jon Barnett and Athos Hrysoulakis

Cheers

2 of them names are associated with the club i am at now (local club)

 

[Madd Matt]

madmatt, thank god ur not on our recruiting panel, ud make us even worse. if u think those group of players, who starved us from playing finals for virtually 10 years were servicable or ok, u should just shoot urself right now. Absolute dead set, they were bloody useless players and it shows in their career stats. Back then collingwood was run poorly and it shows bvy the playing list.

THATS WAT LEIGH MATTHEWS WILL DO TO BRISBANE WHEN HE ********ES OFF, LEAVE THEM IN A PILE OF CRAP, USELESS PLAYERS

relax dude, I was just making light of the situation. Every one of those players were ordinary. I retierate that my last sentence in that post SHOWS that I acknowledged that they were all duds. I was implying that individually you can get away with each of them in a side, but our problem was that they all played in the SAME side!

 

[rota69]

chris tarrant

 

[armchair_expert]

ricky olerenshaw was actually a really good bloke met him at a family day once

biggest dud? what about Kent butcher

 

[Nardz]

chris tarrant

--> Matthew Richardson Board

 

[Murray]

chris tarrant

Oh the irony - a club built around duds

 

[bradrowe#32]

My ultimate favourite is Cameron Venables.

I think he was PSD pick in 1999 (?) and only got selected because he ran through Gavin Brown in a practice match.

 

[ouu 5]

one of Shawry's favorites:

Luke Godden

 

[Bombers 2003]

My favorite duds at Collingwood
P Daicos
S Wowoedin
R o'Connor
Honorable Mention
Graeme "jerker"Jenkin.

 

[Madd Matt]

My favorite duds at Collingwood
P Daicos
S Wowoedin
R o'Connor
Honorable Mention
Graeme "jerker"Jenkin.

My favourite dud in BigFooty:
bombers2003

 

[Bombers 2003]

My favourite dud in BigFooty:
bombers2003

Madd Matt-I din'a knae aboot a Dud,but he can go off.

 

[PieLebo87]

r shaw was a definite 'dud' before this year but look at the change that has occurred.. all it takes is 1 big year in the AFL to rise from ruins i believe..
by the way.. VERY disappointed with the tom davidson decision.. was he a dud? or was collingwood mistaken in getting rid of him?

 

[PIE-BOI]

Oh all these memories that what DUD'S we saw in the black and white jumper lol . my fav was M. Francis and Robbie Ahmat . but i hated C.King the most

 

[Murray]

My favourite dud in BigFooty:
bombers2003

Gee Matt, if we were to start on that we would have pages of them

 

[rychenroller]

by the way.. VERY disappointed with the tom davidson decision.. was he a dud? or was collingwood mistaken in getting rid of him?

Crook knees, crook ankle, achilles....another Lee Walker. We'd keep him on the list for 10 years for 50 games. As much as he looked the goods for his one game, I dont blame the club at all.

 

[PieLebo87]

Crook knees, crook ankle, achilles....another Lee Walker. We'd keep him on the list for 10 years for 50 games. As much as he looked the goods for his one game, I dont blame the club at all.

fairn enough.. but still even without that 1 game, my brothers would tell me hes got a better mark then chris tarrant.. so i really would've loved 2 see more of him.. ow well.. then theres sean rustling!!

 

[BarraKouta]

Maybe we should adopt the Carlton board strategy, negative word about our club and you are banned

Anyway, who can forget the Biggest dud of them all, Nathan Buckley, never did anything for this club yet still managed to play 250+ games, captain our side, win a brownlow and is still on the list I believe, unbelievable

 

[PieLebo87]

Maybe we should adopt the Carlton board strategy, negative word about our club and you are banned

Anyway, who can forget the Biggest dud of them all, Nathan Buckley, never did anything for this club yet still managed to play 250+ games, captain our side, win a brownlow and is still on the list I believe, unbelievable

bloody oath!! cant believe he was allowed 2 wear the gr8 number 5 which was OWNED by the gr8 ron mckewon who made it famous

 

[skillsy_44]

Barry Mitchell, then we got him!

Kent Butcher and Mark Orchard and Robbie Ahmat weren't good, Sydney thought differently though.

 

[Winterstick]

Frankie Razo

 

[nature boy]

Some duds on our list over the years Danny Seow ,Fatui Ataata .Paul Rizonico.Mracov, Wes Fellowes possibly the worst player to have won the Copeland.How can we forget the Tony Shaws coaching era to of his favourite young guns Paul Sharkey and Jason Wilde.

 

[Johnson#26]

Marty Warry and Paul Sharkey.

 

[Murray]

bloody oath!! cant believe he was allowed 2 wear the gr8 number 5 which was OWNED by the gr8 ron mckewon who made it famous

wasup mi man
yo, wich ya on dat 1
yo da man rt on

 

[PieLebo87]

wasup mi man
yo, wich ya on dat 1
yo da man rt on

ok you are REALLY scaring me, why are you following me around different forums saying that?