You're The List Manager

[_RT_]

Everyone likes to have their opinion on what the clubs needs to improve. Everyone likes to think they know what it takes to get us into finals. So here is your chance to shine. In this thread you get to play the role of list manger. You get to decide who stays and who goes. You get to decide who we should target in the off season regarding trade week and also the drafts.

All you have to do is answer the following questions:
1. Who should be delisted?
2. Who should be retained?
3. Who/What should we try and trade for?
4. Who should we be targetting in the drafts?

I ask that people respect the opinions of others for there is no right or wrong answer.

 

[Kyusss]

Everyone likes to have their opinion on what the clubs needs to improve. Everyone likes to think they know what it takes to get us into finals. So here is your chance to shine. In this thread you get to play the role of list manger. You get to decide who stays and who goes. You get to decide who we should target in the off season regarding trade week and also the drafts.

All you have to do is answer the following questions:
1. Who should be delisted?
2. Who should be retained?
3. Who/What should we try and trade for?
4. Who should we be targetting in the drafts?

I ask that people respect the opinions of others for there is no right or wrong answer.

How many players must either retire or be delisted each year is it 4?

 

[nut]

You must have 3 picks in the National Draft.

This my view and it's not what I think the club will do. I think we need a second rebuild. When the players he have now that are around 21-24 are getting to 24-27 it would be good to have another wave of quality kids coming through.

(Bearing i mind I have been advocating for trading for prismall, the reason being I think the club is chasing Warnock and Kerr. Personally I'd rather go back into the draft)

IN the trade period, offer the following players up for Trade.


Hughes= maybe a top 25 pick
Shulz= around a top 25 aswell
Hyde= No Value
Jake King= top 40 pick
Raines= top 40 pick
JON= top 50 pick
Cogs= top 50 pick.... no value trading

Off loading not more than one tall or one small so reducing the list by 2. For arguments sake we get Ports second round pick for Hughes and pick 34 for King. or we could swap picks and get early picks

I would then delist Chris Hyde and Tivendale, which would leave us with 4 picks in the National draft.

We now have picks 10, 22 (for hughes to port),26, 34 (for king) 42, we then could offer Geelong Picks 10 and 22 for Prismall and pick 18 leaving us with

Prismall pick 18, 26, 34, 42,

In order to use pick 42 we would have to delist 1 more.


pick 18...Best Available Midfielder

26... 190-192 mobile utility

34.... Ruck

42.... 190-192 mobile utility.

 

[tugga]

You must have 3 picks in the National Draft.

This my view and it's not what I think the club will do. I think we need a second rebuild. When the players he have now that are around 21-24 are getting to 24-27 it would be good to have another wave of quality kids coming through.

(Bearing i mind I have been advocating for trading for prismall, the reason being I think the club is chasing Warnock and Kerr. Personally I'd rather go back into the draft)

IN the trade period, offer the following players up for Trade.


Hughes= maybe a top 25 pick
Shulz= around a top 25 aswell
Hyde= No Value
Jake King= top 40 pick
Raines= top 40 pick
JON= top 50 pick
Cogs= top 50 pick.... no value trading

Off loading not more than one tall or one small so reducing the list by 2. For arguments sake we get Ports second round pick for Hughes and pick 34 for King. or we could swap picks and get early picks

I would then delist Chris Hyde and Tivendale, which would leave us with 4 picks in the National draft.

We now have picks 10, 22 (for hughes to port),26, 34 (for king) 42, we then could offer Geelong Picks 10 and 22 for Prismall and pick 18 leaving us with

Prismall pick 18, 26, 34, 42,

In order to use pick 42 we would have to delist 1 more.


pick 18...Best Available Midfielder

26... 190-192 mobile utility

34.... Ruck

42.... 190-192 mobile utility.

Great effort nut. Just one question. Where did you arrive at pick No 10? We'll finish 9th, which will give us pick no 8.

 

[CoggaRules]

Great effort nut. Just one question. Where did you arrive at pick No 10? We'll finish 9th, which will give us pick no 8.

the dreaded pick 8, the pick that just keeps on giving. Reckon we change the strategy, trade it for pick 9 and hope things change. Let someone else get it wrong.

 

[nut]

Great effort nut. Just one question. Where did you arrive at pick No 10? We'll finish 9th, which will give us pick no 8.

woops... was thinking 2 PP but they are after the first round of picks.

 

[29-little-CHAMP]

Delist ) 1. Greg Tivs.
2. Mark Cogs.
3. Jordan Mc. Turn over king ! 12 possi 7 clangers on weekend.
4. Kane Pets.
5. A.Raines .... Could be Gold Coast bound.
6. Danny Myer , ? Back to S.A.
7. Jake King . Hard. but is he at the level ?

Retained 2) All other's should be retained . But 2009 there will be a couple let go !

Trade for 3) Inside mid - strong nutt.
1) D.Kerr ... on radar
2) P.Chappman .... out of contract wants more money and should get it at the cats but wont.
Strong defender
3) D.Merrert..
4) Z.Dawson , not getting a game at hawks could be a target.
5) J.Kossi ... May be he needs the move away from saint's would be hanndy.

Draft 4 )
1) Height Notthing ... Notthing under 188 cm in our first couple of picks ,
When G17 come in we want to have upper hand in this deppartment,

We have Bling,Edwards,Lid's,Polo,White,Axcel,Connors,Cotch, all will be
together for that 2011 PERIOD (hope).

Footnote )

N.Buckley would be warmly welcomed down at the club .... in some sort of way.

 

[TimeFor11]

Delisted/Retire
Tivendale
Hyde
Casserly
Pettifer
King
On the edge
Meyer
Jackson
JON
Collins
Graham
Polak ???

From that list I would have thought Gus is the most likely. I am all for keeping Meyer, JON and even all of them if we can.

Trade Bait
Polo as he hasnt set the world on fire with his performances however there is definate quality there. Pick 35-45 is probably the most so I would only do it as a straight player swap.

Pettifer if any side is interested they can have him for free basically as we would accept pick 60's for him I am guessing poor guy knee came at the worst possible time.

King as somehow some other coach may think he has the tools and they can actually make a player out of him. I cant see it being done but wouldnt be suprised if some team thought it could. Pick 50+ he is worth on the market

So I wouldnt trade anyone unless we have a great deal put infront of us.

In the draft we should use our first pick on best player available and continue that through.

 

[PHX]

All you have to do is answer the following questions:
1. Who should be delisted?

Hyde, Tivendale and Pettifer should be delisted.

2. Who should be retained?
Cogs and JoN who could go, should stay.

Sylvester, Cartledge and Howat can be delisted from rookie list.

Only Collard is retained as a rookie.


3. Who/What should we try and trade for?

We should trade Jake King and Andrew Raines if we can get a decent deal.

We should check out the currency of Schulz and Hughes.


We should trade for picks and not players unless the player has a shown good record and is under 22.


4. Who should we be targetting in the drafts?

A defender that can control small forwards.

A Ruckman.

A strong key forward.

 

[nut]

so the prismall trade would be picks 8 and 22 for Prismall and pick 16.

Any takers??

 

[PHX]

so the prismall trade would be picks 8 and 22 for Prismall and pick 16.

Any takers??

Nup, it doesnt fill a need.

If there is one thing we have got, it's a plethora of young midfielders.

 

[getthefooty]

Everyone likes to have their opinion on what the clubs needs to improve. Everyone likes to think they know what it takes to get us into finals. So here is your chance to shine. In this thread you get to play the role of list manger. You get to decide who stays and who goes. You get to decide who we should target in the off season regarding trade week and also the drafts.

All you have to do is answer the following questions:
1. Who should be delisted?
2. Who should be retained?
3. Who/What should we try and trade for?
4. Who should we be targetting in the drafts?

I ask that people respect the opinions of others for there is no right or wrong answer.

Delist - Hyde, Tivendale, Pettifer
Retain - Coughlan, Casserly, Hughes
Shop for Prismall, but don't give up anything more than a 2nd rounder. See if King, JON are worth anything on the market. 3rd/4th rounders?

That would leave us with 3, probably 4 picks.
1st round - Best available - Ziebell if there but I doubt it.
2nd- Ruck - wouldn't mind Vickery but he will definitely be gone. Maybe Roughhead?
3rd & 4th - best available with a slant towards mids or small defender.

No need for the preseason draft.

 

[TonyFree]

1. Who should be delisted?
Hyde, Tivendale

2. Who should be retained?
Cogs and JoN.

3. Who/What should we try and trade for?

Daniel Kerr, if available. The guy can play, giving us an extra dimension and depth in the midfield, if he is in the same rotation as foley, would free one of them up.

4. Who should we be targetting in the drafts?
Someone to fill CHF.

 

[beaver fever]

so the prismall trade would be picks 8 and 22 for Prismall and pick 16.

Any takers??

You are massively overstating what Prismall is worth.

And thanks a lot RT, I was going to set up this exact same thread after round 22.

 

[nut]

Delist - Hyde, Tivendale, Pettifer
Retain - Coughlan, Casserly, Hughes
Shop for Prismall, but don't give up anything more than a 2nd rounder. See if King, JON are worth anything on the market. 3rd/4th rounders?

That would leave us with 3, probably 4 picks.
1st round - Best available - Ziebell if there but I doubt it.
2nd- Ruck - wouldn't mind Vickery but he will definitely be gone. Maybe Roughhead?
3rd & 4th - best available with a slant towards mids or small defender.

No need for the preseason draft.

I like that

 

[beaver fever]

Trying to stay realistic

1. Who should be delisted?

Hyde, Tivendale, Pettifer, Polak

Silvestor and Howat

2. Who should be retained?
Promote Cartledge to the senior list. Demote Polak to the rookie list. Retain Collard.

3. Who/What should we try and trade for?
See what we can get for King, Hughes, Pattison, Schulz, JON.

We should be targeting more picks. Only players I would consider are Warnock, Djerrkura, Renouf and T.Tuck.


4. Who should we be targetting in the drafts?

Pick 1 - best available talent

With the rest of the picks we should target KPPs, an inside midfielder and a ruckman.

Rookie list a ruckman and KP Forward.

 

[Sausage roll]

I like that

Trade for JON?

Are you guys out of your mind? Who in their right mind would trade anything for him?

He can't get a kick in the VFL in his third season...remember TW"S claim that he "would silence his critics" this year!! LMAO! The amount of times he gets run down is frightening.

Perhaps we could put him on ebay and see what we get?

The snag has spoken.

 

[the ranger]

Delist: Hyde, Tivendale, Howat (R), Cartledge (R)
Retain: Collard and Silvester on the rookie list, get permission from AFL to keep Polak on the payroll but use his spot on the list for another player (I don't know if it's possible).

If we do all that, we have 3 vacancies.

Trade Pettifer and pick 42 for a pick in the 30s.
Trade King and pick 58 for a pick in the 40s.

Now there are 5 vacancies and we have picks 8, 26, 30 something and 40 something.

8 - Best KPP
26 - Best mid
30 something - Best ruck
40 something - Best mid

PSD - Best available player

 

[Goldust]

Retirement: Tivendale, Polak.
Delist: JON, Hyde, Casserly, Silvester.
Potential trades: Newman (for the right deal), Tambling (for the right deal), Pettifer (obviously low draft pick), King (?????).
Promote: Cartledge.
Needs: Key forward, small defender, one more class midfielder.

At the risk of being howled down, I suggest Newman as a trade as he is the one player who might be able to deliver us a better player.
Quite happy to have him stay, but if we're in the market for a good player, he is the one player with currency that is expendable!!!

 

[beaver fever]

I'd add Tambling to that list goldy. He is as expendable as Newman IMO.

 

[PHX]

Why dont you have your team as Richmond, Goldust?

 

[Accepted 04]

Delist: Hyde Casserley Silvester Howat
Retire: Tivendale Polak
Rookie: Silvester (Gone) Howat (Gone) Cartledge (Elevate) Collard (Retain)
Putt (Rookie List)
Trade (Possibles): King, Pettifer, Meyer, Schulz, Hughes, Polo, JON
Trade For: Warnock and/or Small shut-down defenders
Draft: 1st Pick= Best Avaliable
2nd Pick= Inside Mid/Ruckman/Utility
3rd Pick= Key Position/Ruckman/Inside Mid
4th Pick= Best Avaliable
PSD: Good Quality 23-25 yrs player

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

Out. Tiv,Hyde,Casserly,Collins,Jon,King,Graham. we must be realistic.Pettifer has no currency whilst in rehab,nor Cogs.
Of the above there really isn't much to trade.Take what picks we can,do not tade any players in at all.Just go to the draft with plenty of picks.

 

[Goldust]

I'd add Tambling to that list goldy. He is as expendable as Newman IMO.

Agree Beaver.....liked his game Saturday, but he should be doing more!

 

[Goldust]

Why dont you have your team as Richmond, Goldust?

Because I'm a Hawthorn fan, Phoenix.

As if!

I'm not entirely sure bud, think it was just an oversight when I signed up.

But there's plenty on here can vouch for my passion for the Tigers.

Stodd alongside a few good men on this here forum.

I'll fix it now!