Redo the 2009 draft.

[Bailey01]

He is 22!!

You must be so disappointed in Daniher. He is no where near as good as Buddy. At least Talia was good early and won the rising star award.

Lol he's got no idea.

 

[thetradesman]

Agree. Cunners and Fyfe are having stand out 2014!!!

No Martin in that bracket?

Fyfe is the best easily then Martin and Talia.



Then daylight.

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

Holy crap, Freo went okay that year

 

[Pegasaur]

No Martin in that bracket?

Fyfe is the best easily then Martin and Talia.



Then daylight.

He was joking dude.

 

[thetradesman]

My bad.

 

[Wild Bill]

My bad.

I should have used a pic to help in future.

 

[timtamWB]

Adelaide supporter says Fyfe and Talia are the standouts.
Richmond supporter says Fyfe and Martin are the standouts.

Can't we all agree that everyone is biased and that Fyfe is the only true 'standout'.
(I'm biased too but we all know Fyfe is the best in this draft)

Fyfe and Howard are the obvious standouts. I'd have Howard edging out Fyfe JUST, but that might be a bit of bias.

 

[RedmanWasHere]

Fyfe and Howard are the obvious standouts. I'd have Howard edging out Fyfe JUST, but that might be a bit of bias.

Whereas I'd go for Travis Colyer.

 

[E Shed]

Holy crap, Freo went okay that year

If Morabito maintains his successful comeback we got Mora, Fyfe and Barlow from this year but 2008 was the one.
Hill, Suban, Ballantyne, Clarke, Walters, DeBoer, Clancee Pearce.

 

[Spitta09]

So another year has gone so we revisit. Lewis Jetta is surely pushing top 5 status in this draft. Superb year and performance today..
jks most overhyped player in the game

 

[santa claws]

If Morabito maintains his successful comeback we got Mora, Fyfe and Barlow from this year but 2008 was the one.
Hill, Suban, Ballantyne, Clarke, Walters, DeBoer, Clancee Pearce.

hill is one i think whos terribly over rated. not saying hes a poor player hes been decent and is eyecatching with his run and carry im not sure theres been a hello f a lot more substance than that to his game.

 

[Spitta09]

hill is one i think whos terribly over rated. not saying hes a poor player hes been decent and is eyecatching with his run and carry im not sure theres been a hello f a lot more substance than that to his game.

Nah he is a very good and highly skilled player mate. Maybe not a worldbeater but plays his role very well.
Overrated is the definition of Lewis Jetta.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Stephen hill is a gun, any thoughts otherwise are lunacy

 

[_Owl_]

Nah he is a very good and highly skilled player mate. Maybe not a worldbeater but plays his role very well.
Overrated is the definition of Lewis Jetta.

Jetta is overrated but it is only because of his 2012 season that people rated him that highly. The 'rating' stuck even after consistently disappointing years. All expecting he can go back to that form.

 

[invinoveritas]

1 Nathan Fyfe
2 Dustin Martin
3 Michael Barlow
4 Daniel Talia
5 Jake Carlisle
6 Ben Cunnington
7 Jack Gunston
8 Allen Christensen
9 Matthew Jaensch
10 Stewart Crameri
11 Mitch Duncan
12 Lewis Jetta
13 Sam Reid
14 James Podsiadly
15 Mark Hutchings
16 Aaron Black
17 Tom Scully
18 Jack Trengove
19 Alex Silvagni
20 Ben Stratton

I personally believe that after the completion of the 2014 Season this is how I would rate the top 20... Should injury not have taken its toll I believe that Morabito, Menzel & Vardy would be top 10... It kills me every time I see Fyfe tearing it up for Freo instead of West Coast, but well done to them this was definitely their draft.

 

[Spitta09]

1 Nathan Fyfe
2 Dustin Martin
3 Michael Barlow
4 Daniel Talia
5 Jake Carlisle
6 Ben Cunnington
7 Jack Gunston
8 Allen Christensen
9 Matthew Jaensch
10 Stewart Crameri
11 Mitch Duncan
12 Lewis Jetta
13 Sam Reid
14 James Podsiadly
15 Mark Hutchings
16 Aaron Black
17 Tom Scully
18 Jack Trengove
19 Alex Silvagni
20 Ben Stratton

I personally believe that after the completion of the 2014 Season this is how I would rate the top 20... Should injury not have taken its toll I believe that Morabito, Menzel & Vardy would be top 10... It kills me every time I see Fyfe tearing it up for Freo instead of West Coast, but well done to them this was definitely their draft.

Pretty fair post. I would argue that cunnington had as good a season as barlow though. Also reid, black, scully, stratton even silvagni have more value than receiver Jetta who is still too high.

 

[Bailey01]

1 Nathan Fyfe
2 Dustin Martin
3 Michael Barlow
4 Daniel Talia
5 Jake Carlisle
6 Ben Cunnington
7 Jack Gunston
8 Allen Christensen
9 Matthew Jaensch
10 Stewart Crameri
11 Mitch Duncan
12 Lewis Jetta
13 Sam Reid
14 James Podsiadly
15 Mark Hutchings
16 Aaron Black
17 Tom Scully
18 Jack Trengove
19 Alex Silvagni
20 Ben Stratton

I personally believe that after the completion of the 2014 Season this is how I would rate the top 20... Should injury not have taken its toll I believe that Morabito, Menzel & Vardy would be top 10... It kills me every time I see Fyfe tearing it up for Freo instead of West Coast, but well done to them this was definitely their draft.

Good but I reckon Stratton should be ahead of Scully, Silvagni.

 

[The Falcon Strike]

If Morabito maintains his successful comeback we got Mora, Fyfe and Barlow from this year but 2008 was the one.
Hill, Suban, Ballantyne, Clarke, Walters, DeBoer, Clancee Pearce.

Given 3 of those are fringe, I'd prefer fyfe and Barlow .. Though Walters may have a say in that in future years

 

[Tragic sainter]

So another year has gone so we revisit. Lewis Jetta is surely pushing top 5 status in this draft. Superb year and performance today..
jks most overhyped player in the game

Yes Jett's had a poor grand final but he is still a very good player. Blinding pace and a very accurate penetrating kick. He's an 80m player.

 

[Spitta09]

Yes Jett's had a poor grand final but he is still a very good player. Blinding pace and a very accurate penetrating kick. He's an 80m player.

Good player at his best. Lazy and very poor at his worst. I disagree his kicking style looks penetrating but he turns it over a lot

 

[Tragic sainter]

Good player at his best. Lazy and very poor at his worst. I disagree his kicking style looks penetrating but he turns it over a lot

Lots of his kicks go inside 50 which are the hardest and he goes at 70%DE with only 1.5 clangers a game if you take out frees against. And he is a penetrating kick I don't really know how you can say he isn't. He had a terrible grand final but he's still a very good player.

 

[Bailey01]

Lots of his kicks go inside 50 which are the hardest and he goes at 70%DE with only 1.5 clangers a game if you take out frees against. And he is a penetrating kick I don't really know how you can say he isn't. He had a terrible grand final but he's still a very good player.

Jetta just doesn't impact games the way he did in 2012. That's why people are harshly judging him now.

 

[Tragic sainter]

Jetta just doesn't impact games the way he did in 2012. That's why people are harshly judging him now.

Yeah he's not as good as he was in 2012 but I don't think he is that far off it. He's just not kicking as many goals.

 

[Artax]

Was pretty good in the first final against Freo.. counts for nothing now though.

 

[Bailey01]

That grand final absolutely affects my opinion now. He was utterly pathetic yesterday.