JeffDunne
TheBrownDog
For those of you lacking year 7 comprehension skills, I'll explain again my point.
Cam currently has the luxury of not having to win games. That's because of two factors that have nothing to do with him (schedule & primarily his D).
Like all such QB's (see Russell Wilson for another example), without that dominance from the D they are forced to win games with their arm. That requires more than having a good arm too. I used the example of Freeman because Tampa Bay knew that without a stout D he would struggle to win games throwing the ball even though he had decent receivers. They couldn't fix that and weekly he was exposed.
Now if Panthers fans would like to show me examples of games where Cam hasn't had the support of the D to win a games then you might have a point.
Put him in the situation Freeman was facing and he'd probably perform similarly.
I can show countless examples of Cam staging, scrambling to the sidelines or sliding late to draw penalties, missing wide open receivers . . . I could go on . . . all of which tell me he's a) an A grade f/wit & b) not a very good QB.
Note, none of this is discussing how Freeman would have gone at Carolina. But I'd bet London to a brick his record would have been better playing with a dominate D - like it is for ALL QB's.
Cam currently has the luxury of not having to win games. That's because of two factors that have nothing to do with him (schedule & primarily his D).
Like all such QB's (see Russell Wilson for another example), without that dominance from the D they are forced to win games with their arm. That requires more than having a good arm too. I used the example of Freeman because Tampa Bay knew that without a stout D he would struggle to win games throwing the ball even though he had decent receivers. They couldn't fix that and weekly he was exposed.
Now if Panthers fans would like to show me examples of games where Cam hasn't had the support of the D to win a games then you might have a point.
Put him in the situation Freeman was facing and he'd probably perform similarly.
I can show countless examples of Cam staging, scrambling to the sidelines or sliding late to draw penalties, missing wide open receivers . . . I could go on . . . all of which tell me he's a) an A grade f/wit & b) not a very good QB.
Note, none of this is discussing how Freeman would have gone at Carolina. But I'd bet London to a brick his record would have been better playing with a dominate D - like it is for ALL QB's.