Player X vs Y

[toxic]

Who would you guys loop and start on the ground?

Robertson and Taylor?

robertson

 

[Embleberry]

Who would you start out of Tyson, Taylor and Crouch?

Would be nice if Crouch can continue going big!

 

[Monya Meow Meow]

Who would you start out of Tyson, Taylor and Crouch?

Would be nice if Crouch can continue going big!

Tyson or Crouch, not Taylor.
Leaning slightly towards Crouch at the moment.

 

[Krujan]

Which 1 gets benched Lloyd, Dunstan or Crouch?

 

[Krujan]

Can't decide who get's traded out Tyson or Dunstan?

 

[Embleberry]

Which 1 gets benched Lloyd, Dunstan or Crouch?

I would put Lloyd on the bench

Can't decide who get's traded out Tyson or Dunstan?

I see Dunstan scoring higher against Brisbane compared to how Tyson will score against Sydney. But they'll probably score quite similarly.

 

[Jiska]

Can't decide who get's traded out Tyson or Dunstan?

I'd back Dunstan in

 

[karaoke]

Who do I slaughter for Lloyd?

Cunningham
b/e 28
price peak diff - 75k

Taylor (DPP)
b/e 13
price peak diff - 24k

Impey
b/e 17
price peak diff - 55k

JKH
b/e -21
price peak diff - 36k

(price peak is what I estimate they could top out in price in latter weeks)

Without DPP, I would be getting rid of Taylor, but how much is having DPP worth?

With Cripps warming the bench, having Cunningham as emergency is handy, plus named as first rover this week (FWIW).

Thoughts?

 

[Jiska]

Who do I slaughter for Lloyd?

Cunningham
b/e 28
price peak diff - 75k

Taylor (DPP)
b/e 13
price peak diff - 24k

Impey
b/e 17
price peak diff - 55k

JKH
b/e -21
price peak diff - 36k

(price peak is what I estimate they could top out in price in latter weeks)

Without DPP, I would be getting rid of Taylor, but how much is having DPP worth?

With Cripps warming the bench, having Cunningham as emergency is handy, plus named as first rover this week (FWIW).

Thoughts?

Slaughter a MID and move Taylor up.

 

[karaoke]

Slaughter a MID and move Taylor up.

Are you saying Cunningham?

Otherwise, Tyson & Dunstan ATM are more valuable (than a JKH, Impey, Taylor etc) & still should make more money and be on-field scoring contributors.

 

[Imoster]

luke dahlhaus vs robbie gray

 

[toxic]

luke dahlhaus vs robbie gray

Gray, better side

 

[Lotch]

I'm going to upgrade Ellis and decided to play Aish.

So which player do I bench:

Polec vs Tyson vs Crouch.

 

[Jiska]

I'm going to upgrade Ellis and decided to play Aish.

So which player do I bench:

Polec vs Tyson vs Crouch.

Tyson

 

[BAK2BAK]

cant decide whether to get robbie gray in this week @$470 be35 or wait couple a weeks to get wingard for $420 ???
thoughts ??

 

[Krujan]

cant decide whether to get robbie gray in this week @$470 be35 or wait couple a weeks to get wingard for $420 ???
thoughts ??

Wingard

 

[Judd_Magic]

Wingard

Grays killing Wingard though and in better form.

I'd go Gray as he is also getting more midfield time too which Wingard isn't.

 

[Jiska]

Grays killing Wingard though and in better form.

I'd go Gray as he is also getting more midfield time too which Wingard isn't.

When you're sitting in Row M, Seat 42, it's hard for the coach to move you to the midfield

 

[Krujan]

Grays killing Wingard though and in better form.

I'd go Gray as he is also getting more midfield time too which Wingard isn't.

And when Wingard's fully fit he'll take Gray's midfield minutes.

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Walker or K Simpson?

I saw walks but he seems to s**t. Today on 60sc before HT.

Might be worth it

 

[Judd_Magic]

And when Wingard's fully fit he'll take Gray's midfield minutes.

Doubt it.

Wingard wasn't getting any midfield minutes at all when he was fit.

Was just playing half forward all the time.

 

[Judd_Magic]

When you're sitting in Row M, Seat 42, it's hard for the coach to move you to the midfield

That was one week.

I'm talking about every game so far.

As a Wingard owner I have been following him closely and he has had no time whatsoever in the midfield compared to Gray.

All his gametime has been at half forward compared to last year when he was actually playing midifeld.

If I had of known that Wingard wasn't going to play midfield at all this year then I would have just stuck with Gray.

 

[GAsnr]

Walker or K Simpson?

I saw walks but he seems to s**t. Today on 60sc before HT.

Might be worth it

Simpson.

I assume you were barracking against him today because you wanted him this week?

The bloke is consistent. I snagged him at bottom 480k 2 weeks ago. See below. Happy.

I think there's more to it than Carlton being s**t.

Simpson scored 128 in a losing side on the weekend. Scored 105 and 86 against Port and Essendon respectively. His break even is 53, and while I'm not getting him in to make money, I don't think he'll get much cheaper. He's 480k. Carlton may be s**t, but he's still averaging 95.

Premiums are still premiums and would expect as Carlton get better, so too would Simpson.

 

[Amazing Bombers]

Jack or JPK?

 

[SnappyHappy]

Jack or JPK?

I'd go JPK at this stage. Jack still looks to be carrying a rib injury. Still scored 111 tonight but it clearly affected him so treat warily.

WATSON v. FYFE v. MURPHY