Drafts Gone By - I was Wrong

[natedog]

I thought Malcom Lynch would be a gun goalsneak when he kicked 3 against Sydney in a pre-season game as an 18 year old

Same. Saw Lynch in a pre-season game and thought he'd be a gun.

 

[AjsGuns]

2012: Wanted a Wines and Mayes combo with 5/6, was happy with Macrae and content/ok with Stringer
2013: Really wanted Aish, thought he was the best midfielder in the draft and a safe bet to be a 250 game player, was pretty pissed we took Bonti over him

Early days yet but I'd take Macrae, Stringer and Bonts over Wines, Mayes and Aish.
Macrae = Wines
Stringer > Mayes
Bonti > Aish

 

[cammo78]

2012: Wanted a Wines and Mayes combo with 5/6, was happy with Macrae and content/ok with Stringer
2013: Really wanted Aish, thought he was the best midfielder in the draft and a safe bet to be a 250 game player, was pretty pissed we took Bonti over him

Early days yet but I'd take Macrae, Stringer and Bonts over Wines, Mayes and Aish.
Macrae = Wines
Stringer > Mayes
Bonti > Aish

I was filthy we overlooked Scharenberg for Bonts.

Bloody insane.

 

[Dancing Dougy]

I was filthy we overlooked Scharenberg for Bonts.

Bloody insane.

Insane indeed!!! haha

 

[TheHoneyBadger]

I've probably already mentioned it in this thread, but I was filthy that we passed over Kade Kolodjashnij.

I'd still be stoked to add KK to the list (almost-go-home factor?), but let it be another reason why I should never be trusted with drafting/list management decisions.

 

[fronkalicious]

I've probably already mentioned it in this thread, but I was filthy that we passed over Kade Kolodjashnij.

I'd still be stoked to add KK to the list (almost-go-home factor?), but let it be another reason why I should never be trusted with drafting/list management decisions.

Kk is a beast and may end up as good as Bonti IMO. J mac should be all over him. Exactly what we need

 

[Bazza Bulldog]

I was filthy we overlooked Scharenberg for Bonts.

Bloody insane.

Due to injury Scharenberg hasn't played yet ... so might be too early to call this. Apparently he was too 'good' for us in his interview. So I'm not wishing him any luck in the RS this year.

 

[Unnamed1]

I was filthy we overlooked Scharenberg for Bonts.

Bloody insane.

I don't know if I'm happier that we got Bonts or that Collingwood didn't.

 

[Libba21]

DamienMcCormack thought he was gonna be the next thing 2 years later seen him working in a bank in southland. Lol

 

[Tommycash]

Gerald Ugle, I thought he was a certainty. Now he's just joined Peel who are aligned with Freo, so may still be a chance to make the AFL again. But still.

 

[Mofra]

DamienMcCormack thought he was gonna be the next thing 2 years later seen him working in a bank in southland. Lol

I actually thought he'd lockdown a back pocket for us. Had a few tricks, just never developed as much as we'd like