Position 2015 SuperCoach defenders

[Daniels]

Well played.

Funny thing is I'm considering 3 players for my D4 spot - KK, Higgins & Docherty.

I'm favouring Docherty as I think he can churn out a 85+ avg by years end IMHO.

Hehehehehehehe!

I know Higgins went FWD etc, but hey whatever...

 

[King_Steele]

Hehehehehehehe!

I know Higgins went FWD etc, but hey whatever...

Gotta go with your gut at the end of the day

 

[TheOz]

Was subbed out early. Maybe half time...?

Didnt inspire much confidence when he was on the ground.

 

[stevebbb]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

 

[KardiniaPark]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

b,91,y

 

[SnappyHappy]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

b,97,yes

 

[Big Sauce 21]

Is it possible for them to change Rich to Def before the season starts because he's clearly playing off HB this year

 

[Kadog]

Is it possible for them to change Rich to Def before the season starts because he's clearly playing off HB this year

THAT is fn great idea. Call CD and claim 'the Blicavs rule'

 

[toxic]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

A
88
yes

 

[Dubious 1]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

B,89,No

 

[King_Steele]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

B.
90.
No.

 

[TN25]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

1. B
2. 93
3. No

 

[Jiska]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

A
95
No

 

[Goats]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

A
88.5
Yes

 

[stevebbb]

cheers for the responses!

helped me confirm taking Shaw out (got Hibberd ), keeping Smith, and still undecided on Kade

 

[TN25]

cheers for the responses!

helped me confirm taking Shaw out (got Hibberd ), keeping Smith, and still undecided on Kade

I wouldn't pick Kade, get Newnes instead (if you don't have him already)

 

[King_Steele]

I wouldn't pick Kade, get Newnes instead (if you don't have him already)

+1.

Better value for money BUT we are Saints fans of course!

 

[stevebbb]

I wouldn't pick Kade, get Newnes instead (if you don't have him already)

+1.

Better value for money BUT we are Saints fans of course!

already got Newnes fellas
got a 4-1-3 atm, but hoping some defence rookies jump at us so I can drop Kade and grab another mid or fwd premo
do not trust KK, Ibbotson, Henderson, etc

 

[Jiska]

I wouldn't pick Kade, get Newnes instead (if you don't have him already)

In before he does a hammy four rounds in and has 100,000 coaches scrambling to trade him out.

Alex Fasolo 2014, Daisy Thomas 2013, how I loved you so for giving me an extra trade for the year than nearly everyone else

 

[JohnnyDrama1]

What do people realistically see Newnes averaging? Can see him going 90 at most but will still struggle big time in a bottom of the ladder club

 

[Super Hans]

What do people realistically see Newnes averaging? Can see him going 90 at most but will still struggle big time in a bottom of the ladder club

I'm not picking Newnes, but him being from a bottom team shouldn't be a factor. I actually prefer defenders from lower teams, mean they won't get rested (blokes like Enright and Birchall are always good for a rest here or there).

 

[Super Hans]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

B
89
Yes

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Smith won't drop his average.

Steady rising from 50, 65, 75, 93. At his age with reasonable consistency, I'm looking at around 105.


Gun

 

[Krujan]

Supercoach Premium Defenders Questionnaire

Q1. Heath Shaw will play a. 14-17, b. 18-21 or c. 22 games this season.
Q2. Brodie Smith will end the season with an average of ___.
Q3. Kade Simpson is a good in, will play all games and average around his usual 95 again. Yes/No

b
88
No

 

[JPod_31]

Who is the best option under 370k besides KK