Analysis 2016 Supercoach Discussion - Opposition Supporters Welcome

[bananatigz]

Is Vlaustin ever going to get out of the back pocket? I was hopeful he would get more HB/Mid roles but over the NAB he looks to be stuck playing more lockdown. Is that where he is set to stay?

I'd say his role is unlikely to change this year based on the fact he did it so well last year, finished 6th in our BnF I think. Long term he will move up the ground but unlikely to be this year

 

[Werewolf]

Hi guys, SC question about Menadue - how many games do you expect him to play and average score?

 

[Infamy]

Hi guys, SC question about Menadue - how many games do you expect him to play and average score?

You tell me this weeks tattslotto numbers and I'll give you your answer

 

[_DBF_]

Hi guys, SC question about Menadue - how many games do you expect him to play and average score?

I reckon he'll play 10 or 11, average 70.

 

[prodigy]

Hi guys, SC question about Menadue - how many games do you expect him to play and average score?

Depends on form and durability. If he plays round 1 and plays his role, he will play round 2. So on, so fourth. Competition for spots will be the best it's ever been here, so if he doesn't perform in consecutive games, don't expect him to hold his spot.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Charlie Pannam]

Hi guys, SC question about Menadue - how many games do you expect him to play and average score?

The guy will be a gun but I wouldn't pick him this year. I'M not sure that he'll get a regular game and when he does play could be more of an impact player, don't see him having an AFL ready body just yet to be playing any major role.

 

[rank and file]

Seriously thinking about slotting Jack in at F3.Good VC loophole for the first round.

 

[_DBF_]

Seriously thinking about slotting Jack in at F3.Good VC loophole for the first round.

Only if Dusty and Lids are F1 and F2

 

[rank and file]

Only if Dusty and Lids are F1 and F2

Houli D1,Dusty F1.Unless I can find a way to rort the salary cap,Lids is going to have to watch my team from the sidelines for a few weeks.

 

[harry000]

Hi guys.. sorry if this has been asked before. Am at work and don't have time to read the thread. Do you guys see T Vickery spending more time in the ruck this year due to the new sub/interchange rules?

 

[Grockadoc]

Hi guys.. sorry if this has been asked before. Am at work and don't have time to read the thread. Do you guys see T Vickery spending more time in the ruck this year due to the new sub/interchange rules?

I personally still see Maric playing the majority of the ruck rule. Vickery could float through there, but I still believe he'll spend 75% or so up forward. Could be an OK POD, but with his price, and the fact that Tyrone is consistently inconsistent, means there are probably better options out there.

 

[harry000]

I personally still see Maric playing the majority of the ruck rule. Vickery could float through there, but I still believe he'll spend 75% or so up forward. Could be an OK POD, but with his price, and the fact that Tyrone is consistently inconsistent, means there are probably better options out there.

Im thinking for my Ultimate Footy team with category scoring. I am targeting forwards that kick alot of goals and if he is getting hit outs too could make him valuable at my final forward slot?

 

[Grockadoc]

Im thinking for my Ultimate Footy team with category scoring. I am targeting forwards that kick alot of goals and if he is getting hit outs too could make him valuable at my final forward slot?

If you were after a forward, I would maybe look at Shane Edwards, if he is still available. But I am feeling optimistic about Vickery in terms of goal output this season, so in a category based scoring system, he could be worth it.

 

[harry000]

If you were after a forward, I would maybe look at Shane Edwards, if he is still available. But I am feeling optimistic about Vickery in terms of goal output this season, so in a category based scoring system, he could be worth it.

Thanks mate!

 

[Gosha]

Supercoach nerds, Crowley or Parish??? They're both at $202,800...

 

[RainMachine]

Hey lads, thoughts on Miles? Was surprised to see him at an average of only 87. How's he been so far this year and is he worth the selection?
Have $530k to spend but considering him as a value player

 

[DontArgue4]

Hey lads, thoughts on Miles? Was surprised to see him at an average of only 87. How's he been so far this year and is he worth the selection?
Have $530k to spend but considering him as a value player

Hes a decent fantasy player but i reckon with the inclusions to our midfield he might not take a step up, probably stay around where he was last year

Ive got Mitch Duncan as an under 500k mid who i believe will take it up a notch

 

[The Doozy]

Supercoach nerds, Crowley or Parish??? They're both at $202,800...[/QUOTE

im going with crowley

 

[prodigy]

Corey Ellis or Connor Menadue? - Both at a similar price, 193k and 155k respectively, both dual position players (MID/FWD), both look likely to play a large portion of the season. Genuine headache.

 

[bananatigz]

Supercoach nerds, Crowley or Parish??? They're both at $202,800...

Parish, Crowley a safer bet in terms of staying in the side but his best ever average is 66, he won't make you much cash if he averages that, Parish as long as he is in the team should score more.

 

[Gosha]

Parish, Crowley a safer bet in terms of staying in the side but his best ever average is 66, he won't make you much cash if he averages that, Parish as long as he is in the team should score more.

Scrapped em both and went with B. Crouch and Petracca.

 

[bananatigz]

Scrapped em both and went with B. Crouch and Petracca.

Good option if both are fit and firing, bit of doubt over both though so keep an eye on them

 

[Charlie Pannam]

Supercoach nerds, Crowley or Parish??? They're both at $202,800...

Crowley will have a more attacking role with the Bombers. Because he played such a negative game style for Freo it's difficult to know exactly what he's capable of. He could win a lot more of his own ball this year which would see his price increase significantly.

 

[Double the Fist]

Houli or Rance ladies and gentlemen!
Rance is a great full back, but can anyone see Bash lifting his average a bit this year? Another season, more experiance, better back 6?
Thankyou in advance for your time!~

 

[Infamy]

Houli or Rance ladies and gentlemen!
Rance is a great full back, but can anyone see Bash lifting his average a bit this year? Another season, more experiance, better back 6?
Thankyou in advance for your time!~

I think both depend on the performance of other players.
If Astbury or Elton can perform a good lock down role on the opposition's key tall then it will allow Rance to do what he does best and help him get consistently good numbers rather than the occasional down game when he's more defensive focussed.
Once Yarran is in the side then it will probably allow Houli to get less attention from the opposition, although Yarran could also take some of Houli's rebound stats from him too.

I currently have Rance in my Supercoach side, but don't have Houli at this stage (pending NAB 3 & intraclub results)