Position 2024 Fantasy Defenders
- Thread starter WaynesWorld19
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Just my thoughts on why I won't be picking N. Martin......
Essendon don't really have a history of HB players going 100+. As good as Martin might be, he still has to share plenty of the ball with McGrath and Redman.
I don't think he is of the Daicos/Sheezal mold where the team try and go through him all the time.
So I see him going 95-100, which might make him a top 10 defender but at his price and where he is currently positioned on AF, there are better value options out there in a mid spot!
Essendon don't really have a history of HB players going 100+. As good as Martin might be, he still has to share plenty of the ball with McGrath and Redman.
I don't think he is of the Daicos/Sheezal mold where the team try and go through him all the time.
So I see him going 95-100, which might make him a top 10 defender but at his price and where he is currently positioned on AF, there are better value options out there in a mid spot!
Zevon
Moderator
- Moderator
- #255
They will want the ball in his hands considerably more than they’ll want it to be with McGrath (neat kick but not damaging) or Redman (gets the ball and belts it 65 metres). Plus Martin runs hard to space far better than either of them.
You’re correct to say Essendon HB’s have never really racked up big numbers, but they’ve never had a player like Martin back there either. We’re talking a genuine ball magnet that wants the little sideways kick from a team mate as much as Daicos does. He had 8 scores above 100 last year playing on the wing, which has basically been a fantasy graveyard position lately. Can see him having a peak-Whitfield type season back there, without the Whitfield drama and injury risk.
Agreed. Avoid.
WaynesWorld19
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #256
- Aug 15, 2009
- 4,005
- 6,331
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Would they risk it with the Rd2 bye? Maybe you just sit him out for the first two and then play him go from Rd3?
Zevon
Moderator
- Moderator
- #259
Yeah very true. They’ve got a lot of options for how to ease him back in and they haven’t shown any signs that they’re going to take risks with him (understandably). Could be a sub candidate as well while they’re playing this cautious approach which would be a disaster for somebody priced at $400k.
Concerning.
- Mar 20, 2013
- 4,948
- 4,982
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
I think vfl doesn’t start until rd 4? This is another factor as it removes that pathway. Makes a return via the vest (sub in or out) a big risk too
WaynesWorld19
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #262
Wouldn't that throw the cat amongst the pigeons
Snuffaluphagus
Moderator
- Sep 10, 2015
- 21,255
- 71,637
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Moderator
- #263
Doubts? Young will start onball and only rest down back here and there. They are fully committed to Young being a mid first
When Fyfe went off at half time, Simpson, Erasmus and Brodie came on. All three of them went into the middle and Young went back to allow that. The doubt re Young's role is being way overplayed. Young was a lock in the CBAs for the first half, the role is safe.
- Mar 20, 2007
- 28,276
- 24,794
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Classic pre-season overreaction regarding Young
Happens every pre-season where one popular pick doesn't dominate Fantasy wise, and people start to go cold. Happened last year when Daicos got tagged in pre-season and alot jumped off.
I look mainly for role in pre-season games. If one of my starting picks scores well, thats a bonus.
Hoo boy don’t remind me, went with Duggan instead the useless kent
Snuffaluphagus
Moderator
- Sep 10, 2015
- 21,255
- 71,637
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Moderator
- #267
I understand the concerns on Fyfe stealing some points and competing with too many others for a share of the ball but people shouldnt doubt where he'll play, it'll be almost all onball.
JL keeps talking about needing a left footer in the midfield and Young is basically our only choice there, also says he likes his defensive mind.
If you were already on Young then its not time to jump off IMO
If you were already on Young then its not time to jump off IMO
WaynesWorld19
Moderator
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #269
Isn't it a case, FREO need a defensive MID .....all your mids are attacking minded ....and I loved the tackling pressure Young applied last year ..that's what he's there for
My own opinion is regardless of how many minutes any of Brayshaw Serong Young have to share time in the middle with simply wont matter the 3 of them are absolute guns and will still rack up plenty of points. I have no issue with having them all in my side you just can't beat class if you ask me.
Snuffaluphagus
Moderator
- Sep 10, 2015
- 21,255
- 71,637
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Moderator
- #271
You and me are going to be friends.
No but, I'm sure there are better ways to have your team in salary cap, would have no problem having all in draft however. I would still bet on Young going at above 95 and the other two above or around 105. Particularly while JL is in charge and likes handballing out of congestion and switching out of defence
Catastrophe!
Cancelled
- Jan 5, 2024
- 554
- 1,225
Buh bye Zac Williams - no chance I'm playing you off a VFL hitout that I won't even see:
Zac Williams will also take part in the VFL game for the Blues alongside Matthew Kennedy and Sam Durdin, with the match to be the running defender's first proper hit-out in more than 18 months having suffered a serious knee injury.
www.afl.com.au
Zac Williams will also take part in the VFL game for the Blues alongside Matthew Kennedy and Sam Durdin, with the match to be the running defender's first proper hit-out in more than 18 months having suffered a serious knee injury.
TEAMS: Dees make Clarry call, no Blues speedster
The teams have been announced for Wednesday night's AAMI Community Series match between Carlton and Melbourne
www.afl.com.au
Zevon
Moderator
- Moderator
- #273
You might get to see him in round 0 don’t forget… but admittedly that is looking less and less likely by the day. Reckon we need alternatives for sure.Buh bye Zac Williams - no chance I'm playing you off a VFL hitout that I won't even see:
Zac Williams will also take part in the VFL game for the Blues alongside Matthew Kennedy and Sam Durdin, with the match to be the running defender's first proper hit-out in more than 18 months having suffered a serious knee injury.
TEAMS: Dees make Clarry call, no Blues speedster
The teams have been announced for Wednesday night's AAMI Community Series match between Carlton and Melbourne
He's a R0 player. We either get a look at him then or he's still not right.Buh bye Zac Williams - no chance I'm playing you off a VFL hitout that I won't even see:
Zac Williams will also take part in the VFL game for the Blues alongside Matthew Kennedy and Sam Durdin, with the match to be the running defender's first proper hit-out in more than 18 months having suffered a serious knee injury.
TEAMS: Dees make Clarry call, no Blues speedster
The teams have been announced for Wednesday night's AAMI Community Series match between Carlton and Melbourne
The perfect player to have the R0
- Mar 20, 2007
- 28,276
- 24,794
- AFL Club
- West Coast
Priced similar - D'Ambrosio, BudarickBuh bye Zac Williams - no chance I'm playing you off a VFL hitout that I won't even see:
Zac Williams will also take part in the VFL game for the Blues alongside Matthew Kennedy and Sam Durdin, with the match to be the running defender's first proper hit-out in more than 18 months having suffered a serious knee injury.
TEAMS: Dees make Clarry call, no Blues speedster
The teams have been announced for Wednesday night's AAMI Community Series match between Carlton and Melbourne
Priced down - Nobody really if you already have Coffield
Priced up - Bowes, Windhager, Coleman
