speedytiger
Club Legend
The best off spinners (Murali, harbhajan etc) all average high numbers in Australia. It's more to do with the pitches i think. It's hard to judge an Australian offie in shield cricket on numbers alone as they'll often look bad. Lyon a classic example of thatThe majority of Lyon's First Class matches (43 of 79) have also come against tougher Test competition that Maxwell, too. Bizarrely though, Lyon's non-Test FC record is actually poorer than his Test record - 44.59 average, 3.13 economy rate, 85.5 strike rate. Better captaincy (fields being set, etc.) and teammates (building pressure) at Test level, making for more frequent wickets?
Still, Maxwell also avarages barely 11 overs per innings when he bowls (which isn't every time out, either). I wouldn't really trust him to bowl 20+ overs in an innings at Test level, and not get belted. To improve and really show his value as a bowler, he'll need to put up a lot more overs a lot more consistently at FC level, but I don't really think he'll get the opportunity to do that in the Victorian side while guys like Fawad Ahmed and Jon Holland are around. Not often really that much call for a 2nd or 3rd spinner to consistently bowl a good amount of overs in Sheffield Shield play.
One wonders whether Maxwell would be better served forgetting about the spin bowling lark and just focussing on his batting, a la Steve Smith.