Autopsy Best and worst vs Sydney round 5, changes for Melbourne Anzac Day eve

[Vitalogy]

In: Short
Out: MRJ

B- Vlastuin, Grimes, Young
Hb- Rioli, Balta, Short
C- Pickett, Baker, Kmac
Hf- Bolton, Riewoldt, Sonsie
Ff- Dusty, Ryan, Cumberland
R- Miller, Taranto, Hopper

I/C- Clarke, Prestia, Mansell, Ralphsmith
Sub- Cotchin

Cotchin brings no value as a sub

 

[Sir_Loin]

Cotchin brings no value as a sub

Not at the moment but if you needed a cool head in the second half then yes.

We clearly thought we’d be in a different ladder position this time of year

 

[Vitalogy]

Not at the moment but if you needed a cool head in the second half then yes.

We clearly thought we’d be in a different ladder position this time of year

We need run not a cool head who is barely finding the pill or impacting a game. Cumberland was the perfect example when he was sub.

 

[Sir_Loin]

We need run not a cool head who is barely finding the pill or impacting a game. Cumberland was the perfect example when he was sub.

What did I say?

 

[Rubber Hips]

Well Dow isn't getting a call up going by the VFL report. Just about first delisted IMO

VFL Report: Round 4

Richmond VFL coach Steve Morris provides a summary of how the Tigers’ players performed in last Friday night's Round 4 match against Carlton at Ikon Park.

www.richmondfc.com.au

Dow came back from Injury the week before

his numbers were good, attitude good…was solid as the report says

He was close to getting a game before being injured


Thomson Dow (20 disposals, five marks, four clearances)

"I thought he had a solid game without standing out. He was one of very few experienced players out on the grand from an AFL point of view, and I thought he approached the game with a fantastic attitude. He was a part of a midfield that was really able to respond from last week."

 

[Pattiger]

Yep, we've had no marking presence on the wing for a long time now. Other teams clunk them all day

Isnt that the role that Jack Reiwoldt has been playing getting to that contest on the wing purely for that purpose ?

 

[A Tiger 4 lyf]

Give Pickett a run in the guts, reads the play so well


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[prodigy]

_RT_ did you wanna do a preview thread this week? You've done a couple of big write ups that didn't make it as threads this year.

 

[tiger_tough]

Cotchin brings no value as a sub

He was decent the week before. I'd prefer to be pumping full games into the kids. When it's a hard slog through winter you want cotchin there.

Dow came back from Injury the week before

his numbers were good, attitude good…was solid as the report says

He was close to getting a game before being injured


Thomson Dow (20 disposals, five marks, four clearances)

"I thought he had a solid game without standing out. He was one of very few experienced players out on the grand from an AFL point of view, and I thought he approached the game with a fantastic attitude. He was a part of a midfield that was really able to respond from last week."

Hes a solid vfl player. A skinny inside mid that can't kick and can't get any outside ball. He's a bust without doubt. Was a s**t pick at the time and still is.

 

[Sol23]

Cotchin brings no value as a sub

Atm he brings no value on field

 

[_RT_]

_RT_ did you wanna do a preview thread this week? You've done a couple of big write ups that didn't make it as threads this year.

Doing one now.

Edit: Will have one up by 5pm tomorrow night. Unfortunately something has come up that I can't get it done tonight.

 

[smasha]

This bloke knows lol.

 

[TigerMoz1973]

in days of yore dimma said thats the way we play, on the edge. we were no 1 then so it was prob okay.

No probs with playing on the edge but Dimma never condoned poor discipline

 

[The Mighty]

This bloke knows lol.

Faaarkkkin at least show some modicum of professionalism and get out of the bedroom with and unmade bed as your backdrop you messy Campaigner!!

 

[Do the Dew]

I suspect that the AFL & SHocking, really wanted to limit the number of free kicks in a game, hoping that that would increase scoring. The rule changes made the rules deliberately less clear and requiring more interpretation. This way the umpires could pay less free while it became harder to say the umpire is right or wrong. Remember when the AFL changed the rule to stop hands in the back. Everyone got used to it and it was clear. Now they change rule back to allowing hands in the back "sometimes".
I actually feel sorry for the umpires trying to umpire a difficult game, with vague rules, and trying to instantly interpret whether a free kick is severe enough to earn a free or mild enough to ignore. It's impossible. The inconsistency annoys the hell out of me, but we should be yelling at the ALF not the umpires. The AFL pretend to support the umpires, but I believe that the AFL is happy to let the umpires cop the fan backlash as long as the scoring is reasonable high and there are plenty of add breaks for the broadcaster.

I kinda think it's the opposite. Pay more free kicks and more 50m penalties = more goals. More goals = more advertising revenue for the league. $$ has been the one consistent under Gilligan's reign.

 

[Grrr]

Melbourne work hard to stop the switch knowing that Max will win or at least neutralise the long kick down the line. For Miller to compete we need to ball to be kick long and low and for Miller to get to the front of the pack. If we kick it high down the line, we are stuffed

Gawn will kill Miller if he plays in front of him. Miller hasn't got enough mongrel to push and shove and jostle Gawn off the ball, and Gawn is very good in that respect. Reckon Miller plays him from behind and plays a backman's role on him spoiling the high ball. Just follow him around try to bring the ball to ground, then maybe use his speed to get off him.

 

[docko911]

Just need to bring in Vickery to do a clumsy whack to the face of Gawn and Grundy, and maybe Oliver and Petracca while he is at it.

Also, until we lodge paperwork what would stop us playing Castagna as a sniper, other than common decency. Could come in for a game knock out a few players with bad tackles and then we sub him.

 

[smasha]

Just need to bring in Vickery to do a clumsy whack to the face of Gawn and Grundy, and maybe Oliver and Petracca while he is at it.

Also, until we lodge paperwork what would stop us playing Castagna as a sniper, other than common decency. Could come in for a game knock out a few players with bad tackles and then we sub him.

#ChrisScottlikesthis

 

[Sir_Loin]

Faaarkkkin at least show some modicum of professionalism and get out of the bedroom with and unmade bed as your backdrop you messy Campaigner!!

 

[tiger_tough]

No Cumberland at training today. Hope he's not injured.

 

[rfctigerarmy]

This bloke knows lol.

Groupie?

 

[Grechy]

Broad still has a week to go...

For some reason I thought he copped 3.

 

[docko911]

For some reason I thought he copped 3.

He did but then they considered his history….








… no I’m not talking about his history in relation to reports which used to be a key consideration in sentencing. No the AFL remembered his grand final antics and the fact he is a 3 x premiership player for Richmond and it was settled. They would have increased it to 6 weeks but they were worried how they wouldn’t be able to convince the public when protected players get off with no suspension for the same tackle.

 

[Morro]

Give Pickett a run in the guts, reads the play so well


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

Agreed. We lack speed in the guts outside of Shai.

He looked great forward of centre also, so can rest forward alternating with Shai if needed.

 

[tora tora tora]

Just need to bring in Vickery to do a clumsy whack to the face of Gawn and Grundy, and maybe Oliver and Petracca while he is at it.

Also, until we lodge paperwork what would stop us playing Castagna as a sniper, other than common decency. Could come in for a game knock out a few players with bad tackles and then we sub him.

George could use his tattoo gun...
Channel these guys